Daily Mirror, on UK Politics, 28 October 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

- ''

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findings

They don’t mince their words in Makerfield. And when PM Andy Burnham pledged to make his Wigan constituency ‘a touchstone’ for future policy - a place where all of his national decisions could be judged - he knew voters here would hold him to it. He needn’t have worried. His government’s first Budget seems to have passed the ‘Makerfield Test’ with flying colours, with .

With millions of households to receive £100 to help with energy bills, fuel duty frozen again for drivers and help for small businesses announced, . “He’s done good hasn’t he?” was the smiling reaction from pensioner Brenda Holgate. Stay up to date with everything announced in our Budget 2026 live coverage . The 70-year-old retired chef voted for Andy Burnham in June and had been keen to see what this Budget would offer.

She’d hoped to see help for struggling families, for older people and businesses. And she wasn’t disappointed. As she put it: “Yes, he does pass the Makerfield test - how could he not? This helps a lot of people. Andy is one of us. He understands how life is.” Across the room, Sue Hughes 75, Chairperson at the busy Platt Bridge Community Centre described the Budget as ‘a win for the working class’ - and for the PM. “The verdict here is that this is a good Budget for lots of people,” she explains.

“It’s a win for the working class and for people who need the most help. The £100 payment might not sound like much if you’re well off but to those who are struggling or with young families it will make a massive difference. “And the standing charge is a major move. It’s not been fair that you can sit there wearing all the coats you want, being cold, and still pay. “He’s asked people what they want, he’s making major decisions and taking risks and here in Makerfield we’re already seeing a difference.”

In the shopping precinct, mum Georgia Dingsdale, 30, said she was happy to hear how the Budget would help so many. “Look, there’s no magic wand but this sounds like it’s providing support for people who need it - and need it now,” the teaching assistant says. “People kept telling us Andy Burnham was using us as a stepping stone but they’re wrong. He’s here all the time - this shows how he’s working hard for us and the country.” A couple of miles away at the Stubshaw Cross Community and Sports Club - where Andy Burnham held his campaign HQ in the summer - self-employed electrician Martin Knowles, 51, watched the Chancellor roll out new mileage rates, a further hold on fuel rate rises and a hike in the thresholds for small business rate relief.

His verdict? “That’s great that. He can’t attack everything straight away but he seems to be looking at a lot of the things what need addressing first, putting money back in people’s pockets.” The Club’s General Manager, Adam Arstall, 44, also approves. Back in June, he’d seen Andy’s team make some big promises. Today he saw those fine words being translated into meaningful change. “It feels like we’ve gone from being down and having no hope to having a government that’s on our side,” he says.

“The Threshold for Small Business Rate Relief will save us £100 a month straight away. “They’ve talked about passing the Makerfield Test - I think what he’s done so far and today, really does, it stacks up.”

Read the original article on mirror.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

The Mirror's headline puts in quotation marks the words 'and for Burnham', which no resident said; the reporter added 'and for the PM' outside Sue Hughes's quote. The Mirror quotes only approving residents and calls their reaction 'hearty approval' in its own voice, with no sceptical voice, though other outlets carried criticism of the same Budget.

  1. Headline goes beyond the article

    Minor

    “a win for the working class and for Burnham”

    Why this matters
    The headline puts the words 'a win for the working class and for Burnham' inside quotation marks, as if a Makerfield resident said them.
    The impression it gives
    A reader believes a constituent called the Budget a win for Burnham personally, in those words.
    The context
    Sue Hughes said 'a win for the working class and for people who need the most help'. The words 'and for the PM' were added outside the quotation marks in the reporter's own voice. Nobody in the article says 'and for Burnham'.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“It’s a win for the working class and for people who need the most help.”
    • Elsewhere in the article“described the Budget as ‘a win for the working class’ - and for the PM.”

    Show it in the article

    “Makerfield delivers verdict on Budget”

    Why this matters
    The words 'Makerfield delivers verdict' present the views of six people the reporter chose to quote as the judgement of a whole constituency.
    The impression it gives
    A reader believes Makerfield as a whole has given the Budget its approval.
    The context
    The article quotes six residents, all approving. It reports no poll or wider sample of the constituency, and no resident who disagreed.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“The Club’s General Manager, Adam Arstall, 44, also approves.”

    Show it in the article

  2. One side gets the space

    Minor

    “constituents reacting to Chancellor John Healey’s plans with hearty approval”

    Why this matters
    In its own voice the Mirror says constituents reacted with 'hearty approval', resting on the approving residents it chose to quote.
    The impression it gives
    A reader believes the Budget met with near universal approval.
    The context
    Every voice in the article approves. Other outlets reporting the same Budget carried criticism, including a 'fudge-it budget' verdict and a difficult response from the left-wing group that backed Burnham.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

    “the view from the streets of Makerfield were clear”

    Why this matters
    The Mirror states that the view of the streets was clear before quoting anyone, so a reader takes the selected praise as settled.
    The impression it gives
    A reader believes there is no dissent in the constituency about the Budget.
    The context
    The article gives no sceptical voice, while other reports noted that rough sleeping support falls sharply after two years.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Daily Mirror

  1. 29 OctMajor UK conscription update as Brits aged up to 65 could be called up to Army Reserves6.0
  2. 28 OctBudget 2026: 'I'm 92 and need more government help with care bills'3.0
  3. 28 OctBudget 2026 winners and losers revealed from energy bill payers to state pensioners3.0
  4. 28 OctTommy Robinson found guilty of harassing two Daily Mail journalists using 'bully-boy tactics'0.0
  5. 28 OctState pension rise confirmed in Budget but poorest households protected from paying tax3.0

Everything we scored from Daily Mirror