Could the status of Lancashire's two cities be at risk?
Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding
We do not republish articles from BBC News. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
This is a mostly factual explainer on whether Preston and Lancaster could lose their city status in local government reorganisation. Its one clear problem is S14, which states in the outlet's own voice that Rochester's loss of city status was an administrative oversight, while the council papers it quotes in S15 describe a conscious decision. The rest of the body gives the reader nothing I could show to mislead.
Makes a false claim
Serious
“This was down to an adminstrative oversight.”
Why this matters
The sentence gives the cause of Rochester losing its city status as an administrative oversight, a clerical slip, stated in the outlet's own voice.
The impression it gives
Rochester lost its city status by accident, through a paperwork error that nobody chose.
The context
The council papers quoted in S15 say that a conscious decision was made by the former Rochester upon Medway City Council not to appoint charter trustees. The article's own evidence contradicts the cause it gives.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“A conscious decision was made by the former Rochester upon Medway City Council not to proceed”
Written straight
Rochester lost its city status in the 1998 reorganisation because, according to council papers published in 2003, the former Rochester upon Medway City Council made a conscious decision not to appoint charter trustees.