SAS soldiers being placed 'in real danger' by war crime inquiries in the courts, senior officers warn, saying hostile states and terrorists are exploiting legal proceedings to 'weaken' special forces
Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture
The Afghanistan inquiry has been shown images of dead Afghan males identified as killed in February 2011, and it is examining whether a £10m military police probe covered up war crimes. Without this, a reader sees the inquiry only as a threat to soldiers, when it is also examining the police handling of the case.
We do not republish articles from Daily Mail. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The Mail's headline turns the regimental association's fears that hostile states are exploiting the legal process into the outlet's own fact. In its own voice it calls the murder accusation against five soldiers a false allegation, though the article attributes that wrongfulness only to the SASRA letter. It also puts Badenoch's 'witch hunt' phrase into its own description without quotation marks.
Headline goes beyond the article
Serious
“hostile states and terrorists are exploiting legal proceedings”
Why this matters
The headline states as the outlet's own fact that hostile states and terrorists are exploiting legal proceedings. It drops the attribution the body gives.
The impression it gives
That Russia, China and terrorist groups have been shown to be exploiting the inquiries and courts against SAS soldiers.
The context
The body reports only that the regimental association has raised fears of this. The headline turns a party's fears into an assertion.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“The regimental association has raised fears that Russia and China”
The regimental association has raised fears that Russia and China, as well as terrorist groups, were exploiting legal proceedings at the Royal Courts of Justice.
States one side's claim as fact
Serious
“were wrongly accused of murder, a false allegation that damaged their careers”
Why this matters
States in the outlet's own voice, with no attribution in the sentence, that five named soldiers were wrongly accused of murder and that the accusation was false.
The impression it gives
That the murder accusation against the five men has been shown to be false.
The context
The only party the article ties to the word 'wrongful' is the SASRA letter, which S29 says cited the accusation. Nothing in the article's own sentences establishes the outcome for these five men.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“The letter also cited the wrongful accusation of murder levelled against five SAS soldiers”
Written straight
Five men, including 'Jay Cal', were accused of murder over the Syria shooting. The SAS regimental association says the accusation was wrongful.
Uses a loaded word
Minor
“to stop the SAS witch hunt by ending investigations”
Why this matters
Puts the phrase 'witch hunt' into the outlet's own description of the investigations, without the quotation marks that mark it as Badenoch's word in S17.
The impression it gives
That the investigations are a witch hunt, as the outlet itself describes them.
The context
The article's own S17 marks 'witch hunt' as Badenoch's characterisation. Whether the investigations are a witch hunt is a contested political claim.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch demanded that Prime Minister Andy Burnham”
Leaves out what changes the picture
Minor
What is missing
The Afghanistan inquiry has been shown images of dead Afghan males identified as killed in February 2011, and it is examining whether a £10m military police probe covered up war crimes. Without this, a reader sees the inquiry only as a threat to soldiers, when it is also examining the police handling of the case.