Middle East Eye, on Climate, 20 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

Cop31 draft agreement ‘the worst ever', campaigners warn

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findingsSee them marked on middleeasteye.net

Climate justice campaigners have hit out at the draft outcome of the global climate talks, describing it as the “worst” in the conference’s history. The draft agreement, which outlines the key commitments of the Cop31 climate summit in Turkey, was stripped of all references to a phase-out of fossil fuels, but backed “accelerating carbon capture, utilisation and storage”, which civil society actors have derided as a “false solution” to climate breakdown.

“It's much weaker language across all fronts, and overall, when we look at it, it’s aggressive, it is backtracking, and it's not going to help developing countries," Harjeet Singh, strategic adviser to the Fossil Fuel Treaty Initiative, told Middle East Eye. "Rather, it is going to help the private sector, fossil fuel industry, and that is not what we came here for,” Singh said. The “cover decision” is an overarching text which summarises the different negotiation outcomes, containing pledges intended to meet the goals of the Paris Agreement.

New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters An initial draft which appeared on Monday was heavily edited, with many of the main commitments, including a transition away from fossil fuels and a $120bn target for finance to help developing countries adapt to the climate crisis, stripped out. Crucially, the latest text substitutes a commitment to “transition away from fossil fuels” for a pledge to “irreversible global transition towards low greenhouse gas emissions and climate resilience”.

The new draft also centres controversial carbon capture technologies, pledging to increase them 20- to 40-fold by 2035. Cop31: Turkey signs $5.1bn loan deals to boost green transition Read More » Carbon capture technologies are costly and unreliable, with most projects initiated in the last three decades failing . “That just gives the fossil fuel industry an excuse to keep expanding fossil fuels and to keep drilling,” Andreas Sieber, head of political strategy at 350.org , told Middle East Eye.

“About 80 percent of CCS [carbon capture] projects are linked to new fossil fuel projects, and it's not like they actually neutralise the emissions from those projects; they just abate them a tiny bit,” he said. “They are basically the fig leaf on those new fossil fuel projects.” Climate finance negotiations produced similarly weak results, with of the Paris Agreement, which requires developed countries to provide financial resources to help developing countries with mitigation and adaptation.

A reference to the tripling of climate adaptation by 2035, a target stipulated the previous year at Belem, Brazil, was also removed from a previous draft, along with any mention of the historical responsibility of developed countries. ‘Dead in the water’ Saudi Arabia has been one of the main actors blocking the inclusion of references to a fossil-fuel phase-out in the final text. The Guardian reports, citing sources familiar with the talks, that the kingdom has held several meetings with the Cop presidency, and has consistently pushed for the weakening of the text’s language around fossil fuels and for the inclusion of a target for carbon capture and storage.

But when it comes to finance, . Erdogan condemns Gaza 'ecocide' at Cop31 climate summit in Turkey Read More » “When you look at finance, the European Union, Australia, and Norway are the ones who have been pushing back strongly,” Singh said. The EU ruled out fresh climate finance pledges , proclaiming them “dead in the water” ahead of this year’s conference. Henan Keskes of Greenpeace Mena said that climate finance is a question of survival in the region.

"We have rising sea levels. We have fires. We have droughts. We have heat waves. You name it. Adaptation is a huge, huge priority for us," Keskes told MEE. "The region as a whole receives a very, very tiny portion of the climate finance that's needed for mitigation and adaptation." Singh says the same set of countries have thwarted progress on the operationalisation of a Just Transition mechanism. The framework, which aims to support workers and protect communities as countries shift away from fossil fuel-based economies, was agreed to the previous year at Cop30.

But the operationalisation of the mechanism was left to Cop31. “When it came to now working on the elements and defining it further and turning into a proper mechanism, what we got here is again pushback from the same set of countries to say that we don't need such a mechanism, we don't need a new framework or a system to help countries who need to transition away from fossil fuels,” Singh said. “So that is something which is not acceptable.

And that's why we are calling it the worst ever Cop, because this text just doesn't help us at all.” Copyright © 2014 - 2026 . Middle East Eye. All rights reserved. Only England and Wales jurisdiction apply in all legal matters. Middle East Eye ISSN 2634-2456

Read the original article on middleeasteye.net (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

Middle East Eye reports campaigners' verdict that the Cop31 draft is the worst ever, and most of its quoted claims are attributed to named speakers. Its finance section puts the blame for weak climate finance only on campaigners' side, and it calls a draft still under negotiation the final text, both minor problems. Nothing in the article is severe or serious.

  1. One side gets the space

    Minor

    “climate campaigners point the finger at developed countries and the EU”

    Why this matters
    The words put the blame for weak climate finance on developed countries and the EU, presented as the campaigners' view, and that blame is the only account of the finance dispute the article gives.
    The impression it gives
    The finance failure is pinned on rich countries by a verdict the article never tests against their stated position.
    The context
    Coverage C3 reports the rich nations' stated reasons for resisting more adaptation money, citing budget constraints and insisting that big emerging economies such as China also contribute. The article does not use the word budget.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

  2. calls a draft still under negotiation the final text

    Minor

    “the final text containing no mention of Article 9.1”

    Why this matters
    The words call the text the final text, presenting the draft's finance wording as the settled outcome of the talks.
    The impression it gives
    The finance wording is the agreed outcome of Cop31 and is closed to change.
    The context
    The article itself calls the document a draft agreement, and coverage says the negotiators still had until Friday to strike a final agreement.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

What it gets right

  • “Harjeet Singh, strategic adviser to the Fossil Fuel Treaty Initiative”

    It names the speaker and the group he advises, so the reader knows whose view the strongest criticism is.

  • “The Guardian reports, citing sources familiar with the talks”

    It names the outlet behind the Saudi lobbying claim and says the report rests on sources familiar with the talks.

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Middle East Eye

  1. 13 NovGreta Thunberg at COP: Turkish energy shipments 'directly fuelling the genocide of Palestine'0.0
  2. 12 NovCop31: Turkey signs $5.1bn loan deals to boost green transition0.0
  3. 11 NovErdogan condemns Gaza 'ecocide' at Cop31 climate summit in Turkey0.0
  4. 10 NovAs heavy rains swamp Gaza's tents, Israel must face sanctions0.0
  5. 7 Nov‘We do not want to die from the cold’: Gaza families struggle as rain floods shelters0.0

Everything we scored from Middle East Eye