Europeans court China’s help to keep climate action on track
ANTALYA, Turkey — European governments will hold crunch talks with China this week, in a last-ditch bid to preserve the role of scientific advice in global climate summits. On the sidelines of the U.N. climate conference in Turkey’s Antalya, senior officials from several European delegations are meeting with their Chinese counterparts to get Beijing onside in a messy fight over scientific reports, five negotiators told POLITICO. “There’s a big diplomatic move,” said Francesco Corvaro, Italy’s climate envoy.
“We’re working to create pressure.” The dispute ensnares the U.N.’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a body which produces scientific assessments every five to seven years, and whose advice is considered the ultimate authority on the state of knowledge on global warming — and how to fight it. The IPCC’s scientists hope to release their next series of reports in 2028. But the timeline is set by consensus among world governments, and a small group of countries led by India and Saudi Arabia are seeking to postpone publication.
As part of the dispute, they’re also blocking the body’s budget, throwing the IPCC into a funding crisis that could impede its work. Any delay to the next reports would deprive climate negotiators of fresh scientific input at the pivotal COP conference in 2028, when countries must assess their progress toward the Paris Agreement and take remedial action to fix shortfalls. (The exercise is known as the second global stocktake, or GST2).
“We have this issue with the IPCC — the alliance of Saudi Arabia and India that wants to postpone the reports,” said Corvaro. “Without the reports of the IPCC, it’s tough to have a good global stocktake. We need to know the details of how far we’re falling short if we want to respond.” European countries see China as key to resolving the impasse. If they manage to pull Beijing onside, the diplomats said, the blocking countries may fold.
Finding time The IPCC is due to publish three reports. The first will focus on the science, the second on how to prepare for the effects of climate change, and the third on how to ensure warming doesn’t get worse. The latter in particular is key for the global stocktake. Most countries want the body to deliver its reports in 2028, so that the stocktake at COP33 can draw on the latest scientific research. “It is essential that the IPCC continues its work and that the seventh assessment report can be delivered in good time to inform GST2,” EU chief negotiator Diana Acconcia told reporters last week.
“Europe stands on the side of science.” But India and Saudi Arabia want more time, arguing this will allow authors and governments from developing countries to review and approve the reports. “You have to give adequate time” to developing countries’ scientists, said an official from a developing country opposing the 2028 timeline. “It’s more of a principled position … not to stonewall or delay any studies.” The official spoke on condition his country not be identified.
Countries pushing for the 2028 timeline — which include not only European governments but many developing countries highly vulnerable to climate change — disagree. “We have seen efforts to undermine the IPCC and to block its reports informing the next global stocktake,” said Marshall Islands President Hilda Heine last week. “Our Pacific scientists tell us the work can and should be completed on time.” The leaders of Norway and Brazil also backed the IPCC’s role in their speeches in Antalya last week.
A French official told reporters that the Indian and Saudi Arabian efforts are “absolutely unacceptable because, in a way, it’s questioning science.” India and Saudi Arabia have suggested an alternate timeline that would deliver the first, science-only report in time for the stocktake — but push the other two, which focus on actions for countries to take, out to 2029. The process is highly political. The last stocktake, in 2023, produced a hard-fought decision signed by all governments to transition away from fossil fuels — the first time the need to do so was acknowledged in a conference decision.
Saudi Arabia has since sought to walk back that outcome. This time, the timeline debate has also dragged in questions about IPCC funding, which is already under pressure due to the exit of the United States. Without a budget, the body’s work cannot continue. The result is a diplomatic deadlock over what used to be a technical detail. For six consecutive meetings, the IPCC’s assembly has failed to reach an agreement. Last month’s gathering in Ethiopia was suspended without result.
Countries are due to meet again on Dec. 1. — the final chance to settle on a budget for the coming year. “It’s not blocking,” the developing country official insisted. “A consensus has to be found. You can’t pass the budget in a non-transparent way.” India and Saudi Arabia also have the backing of Kenya and Russia, and diplomats say China has also objected to a fast publication timeline. But they believe that Beijing can be swayed. “China is in the middle — not completely aligned with Saudi Arabia and India,” said Corvaro.
“We hope it’s possible to get a common understanding with them to underline the importance of science and data.” 'Everything is polarized' As the Antalya summit brings together ministers from across the world, countries are hopeful the dispute could be resolved this week. But the stakes are high. “We have an opportunity here to get consensus on the IPCC with ministers here,” said one European diplomat, who was not authorized to speak on the record.
“If they manage that, I can’t see next month’s IPCC meeting fail. Otherwise, it might be doomed.” Countries are mindful about not dragging the IPCC into a political debate at the COP — the two bodies fall under separate U.N. procedures — but say finding a resolution is a matter of urgency. “We have to be careful here. We don’t want to make things more difficult for the IPCC,” said a second European diplomat. “But if they don’t agree on a budget in December, it will delay and disrupt work on the next reports.
That’s unacceptable.” The governments of India and Saudi Arabia did not respond to requests for comment. The developing country official said his country would oppose any attempt to address the IPCC issue in the Antalya summit’s decision text. A first draft of the final conference decision , released Monday, suggests countries note the “importance of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change for the global stocktake.” The IPCC, for its part, has welcomed government talks in Antalya.
“I think governments talking here in this space [at COP] is extremely helpful,” said IPCC Vice Chair Diana Ürge-Vorsatz. “It’s crucial that we have a decision very soon, because it's very difficult for the scientists involved, it's difficult for the institution. It's very difficult for everyone to be in this uncertainty.” The fact that the IPCC’s bureaucratic procedures had become so political was “difficult to watch,” she added. “Why has it become polarized?
Because, unfortunately, at the moment everything is polarized. And because there are some parties that are trying to undermine what science is telling us, because they don't want to do what it takes to address climate change,” said Acconcia, the EU negotiator. The bloc would strive for a resolution in Antalya, she added. “We will fight for this outcome to be there.”
Read the original article on politico.eu (opens in a new tab)