Trump's Board of Peace warns Gaza ceasefire could collapse, faults Israel and Hamas
U.S. President Donald Trump's Board of Peace has accused both Israel and Hamas of failing to fulfill their commitments under the Gaza ceasefire agreement, warning that continued fighting, political deadlock and deteriorating humanitarian conditions could bring the fragile truce to the brink of collapse. In a 12-page report obtained by Reuters, the U.S.-led body overseeing Trump's Gaza peace plan delivered a critical assessment of progress since the ceasefire took effect in October 2025, concluding that the gap between the agreement and conditions on the ground remains the greatest threat to its survival.
"The distance between what has been agreed and what is happening on the ground nonetheless remains the principal risk to the process," the report said, warning that "a ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely." The report is the board's second to the United Nations Security Council since the ceasefire began 13 months ago. The body, established and chaired by Trump, is expected to present its findings to the council in New York at the end of November.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office and a spokesperson for Hamas' political office did not immediately respond to Reuters requests for comment. Gaza peace plan stalled over Hamas disarmament Although the ceasefire has largely halted major fighting, the broader peace plan has made little progress since its initial implementation. Its central provisions include Hamas surrendering its weapons, Israeli forces withdrawing from Gaza and reconstruction of the devastated territory getting underway.
Hamas agreed in July to a Board of Peace roadmap under which it would relinquish its weapons and transfer control of Gaza to a civilian transitional administration. Israel rejected the proposal, insisting that its forces would not withdraw until Hamas was dismantled. The disagreement has left the plan effectively frozen, with Israeli forces continuing to conduct near-daily strikes against targets in Gaza while Hamas terrorists have carried out further attacks against Israeli troops, according to the report.
"Every day that Israel continues strikes against Hamas targets, it delays putting Hamas' agreement to the roadmap to the test," the board said. It also criticized Hamas for continuing military activity despite its commitment to halt hostilities. "Meanwhile, Hamas militant activity continues, the commitment to cease all military activities has not been met in full by the parties, and the population faces another winter in tents and rubble," the report said.
On Wednesday, Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz reiterated that Israel would not withdraw from Gaza until Hamas had been dismantled and the territory demilitarized. Board criticizes Israel over delays in civilian policing The report also singled out the Israeli government for failing to make decisions necessary to establish a civilian Palestinian police force that would replace Hamas as Gaza's law enforcement authority. The board said an "absence of decisions" on arrangements for training and deploying the force was obstructing implementation of the broader peace plan and delaying a transition to civilian administration.
More than 2 million Palestinians remain confined to approximately one-third of Gaza, mostly in makeshift tents and damaged buildings in areas under Hamas control. Israeli forces occupy the remaining two-thirds of the territory, much of which has been heavily damaged and depopulated. The report also accused Hamas of collecting taxes on goods entering Gaza, saying the practice was affecting the availability of essential commodities. The board warned that restrictions imposed by Israel on the entry of supplies and equipment, combined with funding shortages, had undermined efforts to prepare for seasonal flooding and respond to worsening humanitarian conditions.
Heavy rainfall inundated displacement camps across Gaza last week, leaving Palestinians living in temporary shelters exposed to further hardship. Additional rainfall is forecast later this month. The report described the deteriorating conditions as another indication that the ceasefire has failed to deliver tangible improvements for Gaza's civilian population.
Read the original article on ynetnews.com (opens in a new tab)