Harvesting olives or headlines? Lander’s detention fuels West Bank dispute
Israeli forces detained US Democratic congressional nominee Brad Lander and dozens of other participants in a Palestinian olive harvest on Wednesday, prompting conflicting accounts over whether the group had entered an area requiring military authorization. Lander, a former New York City comptroller, was subsequently released. The gathering took place on agricultural land belonging to the Palestinian village of Nahalin, near the Israeli settlement of Beitar Illit in the West Bank.
American and Israeli rabbis and activists were accompanying Palestinian farmers. Israeli police said the harvesters and accompanying activists arrived near the settlement’s security fence without the required prior coordination. According to the police statement, soldiers, Border Police and local officers detained those involved and took them to a police station. Police said Lander was released after authorities learned he was a congressional candidate. https://x.com/i/web/status/2112853707784118403 This post can't be displayed because social networks cookies have been deactivated.
Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture
The article gives the reason for the detentions only through police, the Foreign Ministry and a military official. It leaves out that soldiers declared the area a closed military zone on the spot, and that the organisers said they had no prior notice and offered to leave peacefully. It also leaves out Lander's account that forces were apparently called by settlement security. Without this, a reader believes the volunteers knowingly defied a standing rule and refused to go.
How we know
- The Independent reported“despite organizers stating they received no prior notice and offered to leave peacefully”US congressional candidate Brad Lander detained in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
- The Guardian reported“Soldiers said the area had been declared a closed military zone”Israeli military detain US and UK volunteers in West Bank including Democratic NY politician Brad Lander (opens in a new tab)
- Al Jazeera English reported“after apparently being called to the area by settlement security personnel”US congressional candidate Brad Lander freed after West Bank detention (opens in a new tab)
You can activate them by clicking manage preferences . Israel’s Foreign Ministry accused Lander of deliberately seeking a confrontation, describing his participation as “harvesting headlines.” The ministry said his team had contacted Israeli representatives in the United States before the visit and had been told that coordination with the relevant authorities was necessary. https://x.com/i/web/status/2112932375105548489 This post can't be displayed because social networks cookies have been deactivated.
You can activate them by clicking manage preferences . A military official told i24NEWS that Palestinians did not submit a request to coordinate harvesting in the area in question. Therefore, it does not appear on the area’s coordination maps. The official also said the plot in question 'requires only a small number of harvesters to collect its produce. The security establishment views the arrival of dozens of activists as an act intended solely to provoke, which undermines the harvesting process.'
Rabbis for Human Rights told The Times of Israel that the grove did not require advance coordination. The newspaper reported that a map distributed by the Israeli Defense Ministry’s Civil Administration did not identify the location as an area subject to that requirement. The military maintained that coordination was necessary despite the plot’s absence from the map. OCHA documented 199 harvest-related settler attacks between September 1 and October 12, resulting in one Palestinian death, 124 injuries and damage to more than 2,500 trees and saplings.
These figures cover incidents across the West Bank, rather than the Nahalin detention itself. Ten arrested in West Bank settler attacks following assault on WAPO journalist, EU diplomats Israeli and international volunteers accompany farmers in an effort to deter attacks and document incidents. Several Palestinians in Nahalin told NPR that fears of settler violence had prevented them from harvesting their trees since October 2023. Suggested articles 'This could kill somebody,' Fleur Hassan-Nahoum tells i24NEWS after Palestinian stone-throwing attack | i24NEWS Ten arrested in West Bank raids after attacks on journalist and foreign diplomats | i24NEWS US officials condemn settler attacks in the West Bank that injured an unarmed American journalist | i24NEWS
Read the original article on i24news.tv (opens in a new tab)