Published

Collapsed building and surrounding rubble in a refugee camp, Gaza Strip

Gaza Genocideupdated 18m ago3 min read

Archive photo · 5 December 2012

8 outlets compared

Aid Groups Grade Trump’s Gaza Plan Four Out of 26, Cite Zero Humanitarian Access

Egypt Today
“the target of 600 aid trucks entering the Gaza Strip daily still unmet due to Israeli evasiveness”
Al Jazeera
“This is displacement by design, and a ceasefire that allows it is a ceasefire in name only.”
3 West Asian2 Other2 Western Mainstream1 Israeli

Photo: diario fotográfico 'desde Palestina', photographer, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

Aid groups rate Trump's Gaza plan as failing to ensure humanitarian access and civilian protection. Ceasefire remains fragile; Israel and Hamas blamed for potential collapse amid fighting.

Scored

Al Jazeera was read line by line by the Watchdog: 3.0. See the score →

Peace plan, aid, and deaths

A coalition of five international aid organisations graded Donald Trump’s 20-point Comprehensive Plan to end the Gaza Conflict at just four out of 26 possible points, with the plan scoring a zero on humanitarian access and one point for civilian protection. OCHA data in the assessment said Israel’s “Yellow Line” moved westward, expanding control of Gaza territory from 58 percent at the start of the ceasefire 13 months ago to 65 percent today, while the assessment said Palestinians are confined to roughly 2.1 million people in 128sq km. The assessment said at least 1,650 Palestinians were killed and 5,975 wounded since the “ceasefire” was declared in October last year, and it quoted Shaun Hughes, World Food Programme country director for Palestine, saying, “When you’re in Gaza, it does not feel like a ceasefire.”

The assessment also quoted Lilu Thapa of the Danish Refugee Council saying, “Palestinians in Gaza are being confined as the “Yellow Line” expands.” The assessment said the peace plan’s explicit prohibition on territorial occupation in Gaza and its requirement that Israeli forces withdraw were violated as Israeli forces launched a new ground offensive in central Gaza this week, advancing with tanks west of the “Yellow Line.”

Reporting for this sectionAl Jazeera

Board of Peace warns collapse

The Peace Council, chaired by U.S. President Donald Trump, warned that the Gaza ceasefire is in danger of collapse because Israel and Hamas failed to honor their commitments, and it said the “gap between what was agreed and what is happening on the ground remains the main danger.”

The Peace Council’s report, described as a 12-page document submitted to the United Nations Security Council, said “any ceasefire that does not yield tangible results cannot last forever,” and it warned residents face “another winter in tents and ruins.”

Bashir Naim, a senior Hamas leader, rejected the Peace Council report and said it was “not only biased but complicit and gives the Israeli occupation cover to avoid honoring the agreement and continue the aggression.”

The report also said Israel’s “absence of decisions” on training and deploying a civil Palestinian police force hampers full implementation of the plan, while it accused Hamas of collecting taxes on goods entering Gaza.

The report described continued military activity as a driver of stagnation, saying “every day that Israel continues its strikes on Hamas targets, it delays testing Hamas’s commitment to the roadmap.”

Reporting for this sectionFrance 24

Winter conditions and aid access

DW reported that heavy rains and declining temperatures during autumn exacerbated humanitarian conditions in the Gaza Strip, and it said UNICEF stated that at least six people, including children, died due to heavy rain and floods over the weekend. DW said local authorities reported rainwater flooded at least 70,000 tents and caused serious damage to more than 200,000 people in the Strip, and it quoted Rowan Al-Amri saying, “During the past two days we tried to stabilise our tent with sand.” DW reported that relief teams began cleaning clogged sewage pipes and rainwater collection basins at 60 sites, and it said about 30,000 households benefit from the work according to OCHA.

DW quoted OCHA explaining that “Israeli authorities restrict Palestinian access to all areas behind what is known as the ‘Yellow Line.’” and it said this left the vast majority of Gaza’s area unavailable to residents. The Peace Council report described deteriorating conditions as evidence that the ceasefire failed to deliver tangible improvements, and it warned that “a ceasefire that delivers nothing visible cannot be sustained indefinitely.”

Reporting for this sectionDWUkrMedia News