Published

Stone Gothic façade with arched entrance of a historic court building, Royal Courts of Justice

Businessupdated 26m ago3 min read

Archive photo · 15 June 2025

5 outlets compared

Court of Appeal Rules Activating Windows 11 Doesn’t Cancel Argos Laptop Refund Rights

3 Other1 Asian1 Western Mainstream

Photo: Tilman2007, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

Court of Appeal ruled activation of preinstalled Windows 11 does not cancel refund right. Case Adodo v Argos Limited [2026] EWCA Civ 1462 decided 13 November 2026.

Adodo wins refund

The Court of Appeal unanimously ruled in Adodo v Argos Limited that activating pre-installed Windows 11 does not remove a buyer's legal right to cancel an online purchase and receive a full refund. Lady Justice Andrews, Lady Justice King and Lord Justice Foxton delivered the judgment issued on 13 November 2026, and the court ordered Argos to return the full purchase price plus interest calculated from 14 days after Dr Ebenezer Adodo first tried to return the laptop in September 2024. Dr Ebenezer Adodo ordered a £379 Lenovo IdeaPad 1 laptop bundle from the Argos website on 31 August 2024 and paid £388.99 in total after also buying a mouse pad priced at £9.99.

Dr Adodo selected Argos's click-and-collect service, collected the items from an Argos desk inside his local Sainsbury's store, and switched on the laptop to check whether it met the IT requirements for his work at the University of Leicester. Dr Adodo returned the laptop and mouse pad to the Sainsbury's collection point on 5 September 2024 after finding compatibility problems and that the mouse pad was too large for his desk.

Reporting for this sectionThe Times of IndiaSolicitor News

Digital seal rejected

Argos refused to refund the laptop because staff said its terms and conditions did not allow returns once a box had been opened and a laptop had been switched on. Argos argued that switching on the laptop and activating Windows 11 had broken a "digital seal" and that an exemption under Regulation 28(3)(b) applied. Lady Justice Andrews rejected that interpretation, writing that "The contract was a contract for the supply of a computer which was preloaded with an operating system to make it functional."

The Court of Appeal warned that accepting Argos' interpretation would "deprive a consumer of the right to cancel almost any contract" for computers and other electronic gadgets with pre-installed operating software. The Court of Appeal also held that the exception must be read strictly and narrowly, covering sealed computer software where the recording or software itself is the item being bought and is physically sealed in packaging.

What changes next

The ruling ended a two-year legal dispute after Dr Adodo represented himself against Argos's legal team from Sainsbury's in the Court of Appeal in London on 4 November 2026. The Court of Appeal also confirmed that an online order collected in store is a distance contract covered by the Regulations, and it ordered Argos to refund the price of the laptop with interest from 14 days after the attempted return. The judgment clarified that retailers may recover a reduction in value where handling exceeds what is necessary to examine a product's condition and functionality, but the court found Argos had not established grounds for such a deduction in this case.

“Argos had not established grounds for such a deduction in this case.”
Lawyer Monthly

Solicitor News and Home of Direct Commerce said the decision confirms that click-and-collect purchases carry the same 14-day cancellation rights. Dr Adodo's earlier path through Leicester County Court included a district judge dismissal, followed by His Honour Judge Hedley overturning the distance-contract issue and awarding a refund for the £9.99 mouse pad while upholding Argos's refusal on the laptop.

Gothic court turrets and chimneys framed by surrounding brick buildings, Royal Courts of Justice
Gothic court turrets and chimneys framed by surrounding brick buildingsRoyal Courts of Justice · 15 June 2025 · Archive photoPhoto: Tilman2007, CC BY-SA 4.0
Reporting for this sectionLawyer MonthlyThe Times of India