Published

modern judicial centre building, glass facade, columns, American flag, Ocala

Crimeupdated 24m ago3 min read

Archive photo · 7 June 2025

6 outlets compared

Dwain Hall Convicted of Kidnapping and Murdering Sonia Exelby in Florida

3 Western Mainstream2 Other1 Asian

Photo: Michael Rivera, CC0 · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

Dwain Hall convicted in Ocala, Florida of kidnapping and first-degree murder of Sonia Exelby. Hall groomed Exelby on a fetish website and lured her to the United States.

Guilty verdict in Ocala

A Florida jury found Dwain Hall guilty of kidnapping and first-degree murder for the death of Sonia Exelby, after Hall convinced the 32-year-old from Southsea, Hampshire, to travel to the United States where he stabbed her to death. The trial took place in Ocala, Florida, and Hall was then sentenced to life in prison after the unanimous verdict was read out on Friday. Prosecutors told the court that Exelby met Hall on a now-defunct fetish website and that Hall used the relationship to manipulate her over several years before stabbing her and burying her body in Marion County, Florida.

“He was then sentenced to life in prison.”
BBC

The Times of India said Hall was convicted on Friday of kidnapping and first-degree murder, and it placed Exelby’s body discovery in Marion County, Florida, on October 17 after she was reported missing from her home five days earlier. The Guardian reported that Hall had pleaded not guilty to charges of kidnap and first-degree murder, and it said his attorney argued that Exelby came to the United States with the intention of dying.

Reporting for this sectionBBCThe Times of India

Prosecution and defense clash

Assistant state attorney Amy Berndt told jurors that Hall targeted Exelby because of her mental illness and exploited her for his own sadistic pleasure, and she said, "And when he finally got her alone, thousands of miles away from home, completely incapable of making any rational decisions, he stabbed her to death and buried her body." Hall’s attorney, Junior Barrett, argued in closing that Exelby came to the US to die and said, "She came here with the intention of dying, she thought she was worthless, useless, a burden on other people," in the Guardian’s account of the closing statement. The court heard that Exelby had wanted to die and that Hall was the "executioner" of Sonia Exelby, while it also reported that the jury was instructed that consent could not be used as a defence against first-degree murder.

The Independent said Berndt showed the jury the knife she said Hall used to stab Exelby with four times, and it quoted Berndt’s argument that Hall could not be excused if Exelby wanted to die. The Times of India said prosecutors told the court that Hall demanded $4,000 (£3,000) from Exelby for carrying out her death, describing him as her "executioner," as per the outlet.

Reporting for this sectionBBCThe Guardian

Family reaction and next steps

After the verdict, Exelby’s brother Barry Wilton addressed Hall directly, saying, "You pretended to care for Sonia. You didn’t at all. You used her to fulfil your sick fantasies," in the Guardian’s account of the courtroom remarks.

“You pretended to care for Sonia. You didn’t at all. You used her to fulfil your sick fantasies.”
The Guardian

Gemma Isaj told the BBC that "A vulnerable person was preyed upon. A beautiful soul was taken," and she said the family would continue to campaign for greater awareness of mental health issues in Exelby’s memory.

Police established Exelby was reported missing from her home on 12 October and that police established she had left the country, before US investigators found her body buried in Marion County, Florida, on 17 October 2025.

The Times of India said prosecutors told the court that Hall used the online alias Alpha Sadist and that he manipulated Exelby after meeting her on a fetish website that is no longer operational.

The Guardian said the authorities described Exelby as boarding a flight to the US seemingly with an intention "to be possibly sexually abused, tortured and murdered by unknown individuals living in the United States".

Reporting for this sectionThe GuardianBBC