Published

Earlier on this story11 Nov: Tuchel Sparks England Goalkeeper Debate With Jordan Pickford and James Trafford Rotation

Sportsupdated 10m ago2 min read

5 outlets compared

James Trafford’s Double Save Sparks Debate Over England’s No 1 Goalkeeper

LiveScore
“Which is why it’s now time for him to be anointed as England’s No 1”
Sky Sports
“‘There's no No 1,’ he said.”
3 Western Mainstream1 Local Western1 Other

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

James Trafford produced decisive late double save securing a 3-2 win over Spain. The win reignited debate whether Trafford is England's No.1, potentially replacing Pickford.

Trafford’s Spain double save

James Trafford’s late double save helped England beat world champions Spain 3-2 in Madrid, reviving debate over whether he has replaced Jordan Pickford as England’s No 1. Thomas Tuchel told ITV Sport, "there's no number one" after full-time, while the BBC described Trafford’s performance as a decisive moment in the Nations League goalkeeper race. Trafford made four key saves in the final 12 minutes, including an “incredible double stop” to deny Lamine Yamal and then keep out Fermin Lopez from close range.

Declan Rice praised Trafford’s speed, saying, "Everything happened so quick so for him to make two in the space of two seconds is massive," and Luis de la Fuente said England’s goalkeeper "produced a fantastic performance". The match also marked a milestone for England, with the BBC saying it was their first loss for Spain in the city in 39 years and their first away victory over a team ranked No 1 in the world.

Reporting for this sectionBBCSky Sports

Pickford’s case and Tuchel’s rotation

Paul Robinson told BBC Sport that "Jordan Pickford very much remains number one" and that the conversation about a change would take place "down the road, but not now." Tuchel’s approach kept both keepers in play, with the BBC saying Trafford had rotated with Pickford across the Three Lions' five matches since the World Cup. Pickford started against Czech Republic and Croatia twice, while Trafford played against Czech Republic and started both England’s matches with Spain, home and away.

Trafford had been picked ahead of Pickford at the Metropolitano Stadium, and Roy Keane called the decision "smart management" before kick-off in Madrid. Trafford’s workload changed after Elliot Anderson’s sending-off in the 63rd minute, as Spain’s pressure increased and Trafford produced his double save in stoppage time.

Reporting for this sectionBBCSky Sports

What the Nations League means

England’s Nations League quarter-finals could determine whether Trafford gets to consolidate the No 1 role, with the BBC asking whether Tuchel could now start him for the next stage. Tuchel highlighted competition in all positions after the 3-2 win, quoting him: "We want competition in all positions." The BBC framed Trafford’s rise through his club record, noting that he returned to his boyhood Manchester City from Burnley for a £31m fee in 2025 and then moved to Leeds for £45m this summer.

Opta data had Trafford ranking top among Premier League goalkeepers for goals prevented this season, with only eight conceded times for Leeds from shots worth 12.40 expected goals. Pickford’s long tenure remained part of the stakes, with the BBC saying he has won 94 caps since making his debut in a 0-0 draw with Germany in 2017 and that he has started England’s Nations League campaign alongside Trafford’s rotation.

Reporting for this sectionBBCSky Sports