Published Updated

Wide reservoir and dam seen through trees, dam structure at right

USAupdated 20m ago3 min read

Archive photo · 31 October 2019

4 outlets compared

Researchers Link Iran’s Dams to Secret Missile Sites, Citing New York Times Hypothesis

cwibc.co.id
“There is an unknown connection issue between Cloudflare and the origin web server.”
Ynetnews
“A geographic comparison has revealed a striking overlap”
3 Other1 Israeli

Photo: TELLURIDE 749, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

Iran built hundreds of dams and major water-transfer networks. Overlaps exist between dam sites and Iran's underground missile facilities hit by airstrikes.

Scored

Ynetnews was read line by line by the Watchdog: 3.0. See the score →

Dams and missile overlap

Researchers and commentators in the sources linked U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iran's underground missile facilities to a renewed question about why Tehran built hundreds of dams and extensive water-transfer systems, including in remote areas where their economic value was difficult to explain. The Ynetnews account said a geographic comparison found an overlap between some dam projects and Iran's secret military installations, and it framed the New York Times theory as a hypothesis rather than a proven fact. Nima Shokri, described as a water security researcher at Hamburg University of Technology in Germany, told the story that his research team documented at least 533 dams across the country.

Danny Citrinowicz, described as a former senior official in Israeli military intelligence now at the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), told the New York Times that underground weapons facilities require reliable electricity and water supplies, making alternative infrastructure including dams a plausible component of military planning. The Ynetnews account also said Farzin Nadimi, an Iran military specialist at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy, estimated Iran has at least 30 underground sites described as “missile cities.”

Reservoir with rocky shores and distant hills, calm water surface, Iran
Reservoir with rocky shores and distant hills, calm water surfaceIran · 7 May 2021 · Archive photoPhoto: Mardetanha, CC BY-SA 4.0
Reporting for this sectionYnetnews

U.S. claims and Iranian response

The Urgente24 account said the U.S. government assured that it was attacking military infrastructure and coastal defenses after American bombings hit the Tarom protected area on July 14 and killed members of a ranger's family. Urgente24 also said analysts believed there might be a subterranean missile base nearby, and it added that the area was known to environmentalists for projects to conserve a wild sheep species. The same source said Iran put USA and Israel installations under its radar and that it would apply, while it described one detainee, Kavous Seyed-Emami, as dying in state custody.

Urgente24 further said another member, Morad Tahbaz, remained in prison for more than five years and told the newspaper that interrogators were particularly interested in his research in Hormozgan Province. Nima Shokri, as quoted in Urgente24, said many dams in Iran perform essential civil functions such as water supply, irrigation, and hydroelectric power generation, and he added that possible military use should not eclipse those functions.

Reporting for this sectionUrgente24

A challenge to the New York Times

The خبرآنلاین accounts said a map prepared by the National Dam Foundation and the National Seismological Center of the United States, or by the National Dam Database and the National Sealed/Salbulld Base of the United States, displayed infrastructures related to water resources management and flood control across large parts of the United States.

“The war may solve the long-standing riddle of Iran’s dams, which had no clear reason for their construction.”
خبرآنلاین

The خبرآنلاین text said the map publication raised a question for the argument in a New York Times report titled “The war may solve the long-standing riddle of Iran’s dams, which had no clear reason for their construction.”

Dr. Moatq (Motaqq) in one خبرآنلاین account criticized certain dam projects in Iran and system-oriented approaches to water and soil management, emphasizing that criticizing these projects should not mean accepting baseless claims about their aims.

The other خبرآنلاین account said Dr. Motaqq (Mortaq) criticized dam projects in Iran and emphasized that criticism should not be taken as an acceptance of baseless claims about their aims.

The خبرآنلاین accounts said the New York Times report claimed some of Iran’s water projects may have been developed to support underground missile facilities, presenting a direct link between dam construction and the missile program as a hypothesis, not a proven fact.

Wide reservoir view through trees, small dam and road at right
Wide reservoir view through trees, small dam and road at right31 October 2019 · Archive photoPhoto: TELLURIDE 749, CC BY-SA 4.0
Reporting for this sectionخبرآنلاین