Published

stone façade lit at night, 'Organization of American States' inscription, Organization of American States

Crimeupdated 25m ago3 min read

Archive photo · 17 October 2013

5 outlets compared

OAS Approves TIAR Consultative Body to Assess Measures Against Drug Trafficking Threats

4 Other1 Latin American

Photo: Don-vip, CC BY-SA 3.0 · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

OAS approves TIAR Consultative Body to discuss joint actions against drug trafficking and organized crime. Brazil and Uruguay opposed; Bahamas abstained in the 14–2–1 vote.

Sources

5 outlets in this story. Read their headlines below.

OAS backs TIAR forum

The Organization of American States approved this Friday, November 20, the convening of the Inter-American Treaty of Reciprocal Assistance (TIAR) Consultative Body to assess joint measures against drug trafficking and other transnational threats. The resolution obtained 14 votes in favor, two against (Brazil and Uruguay), and one abstention from the Bahamas, and it required the foreign ministers of TIAR member countries to meet within the next 75 days. The resolution expressly excluded the use of armed force, and it framed organizations linked to transnational drug trafficking and terrorism as threats to democratic governance, state sovereignty, and regional stability.

“The proposal obtained 14 votes in favor, two against (Brazil and Uruguay), and one abstention from the Bahamas.”
Nuevo Poder

Ambassador José Miguel Castro, leading the permanent mission to the OAS, defended the proposal and said, "The project expressly excludes the use of armed force and refers only to potential diplomatic, legal, or other non-military actions." Alejandro Encinas, Mexico’s permanent representative at the OAS Permanent Council, urged against establishing "an automatic link" between organized crime and terrorism, arguing that they are distinct phenomena with their own legal frameworks.

Reporting for this sectionNuevo PoderMexico Solidarity Media

Mexico, Brazil, Uruguay split

Alejandro Encinas warned that prioritizing a collective defense mechanism that emerged from the Cold War "could create a scenario of greater violence in which we all lose." Edison Lanza, Uruguay’s ambassador to the OAS, said, "We do not understand that it is necessary, nor do we understand that it is appropriate, to address the phenomenon of transnational organized crime through a mechanism like TIAR," and he argued that TIAR was created for different threats. The Uruguayan ambassador also insisted that the approach would not allow equating crime with terrorism, saying, "This does not allow equating crime with terrorism, nor activating collective mechanisms to intervene in the internal affairs of one country or another," while he pointed to differentiated legal frameworks.

Michael Kozak, the United States representative at the OAS, criticized the opposition and said, "Each state of the Americas, especially those that fight with all their might against drug cartels that control vast stretches of territory, should applaud our action today, not condemn it or undermine it." The OAS Permanent Council meeting left Mexico unable to vote because Mexico withdrew from TIAR in 2002, and the dispute centered on whether the treaty should be used as the main tool against transnational organized crime.

Reporting for this sectionCR HoyEl Observador

What the decision changes

The resolution established only the convening of a meeting of foreign ministers, at which possible cooperation measures must be examined, and it did not authorize military operations or establish concrete measures. The TIAR meeting is scheduled within up to 75 days, and it is meant to analyze possible diplomatic, legal, and other coordinated actions against criminal organizations involved in international drug trafficking and terrorism. The resolution’s backers framed the initiative as part of the so-called Hemisphere Shield, and it was promoted by Chile, the United States, and ten other countries within that framework.

Arturo Sánchez Jiménez’s account of Mexico’s position emphasized that the unilateral designation of a criminal group as terrorist "does not change international rules on the use of force or authorize military operations in the territory of other states," and he argued that only the United Nations Security Council can make that determination. Alex Main, Director of International Policy at the Center for Economic and Policy Research (CEPR), said the approval represents a step toward institutionalizing the Trump administration’s military strategy to combat drug trafficking in Latin America, while he noted that not all countries that supported convening the meeting necessarily share the American government’s interpretation.

Reporting for this sectionFolha de S.PauloMexico Solidarity Media