How we did this
How to read the numbers
Each entry carries two numbers.
Logged by N people. This is the number of people who pasted that BBC reply into their NewsCord account. It counts only people who came back to NewsCord and logged it. Most complainants never do. It includes people who have since gone on to Stage 1b, the BBC's second reply stage.
Complaints filed. This is the number of complaints filed to the BBC through NewsCord about that report or programme, from our own counter.
The BBC says in several of these replies that it sent "the same response to everyone". So the first number is a floor, and the second number is the better guide to how many times the BBC has said each thing. Where the BBC says nothing about sending one reply to all, that is noted.
In total, about 500 entries are logged against 20 BBC campaigns. Those campaigns drew about 11,800 complaints through NewsCord.
Wall links go to the public summary of each reply at newscord.org/action/responses.
Logged replies against complaints filed
1. "Israel remains a functioning democracy."
- Logged by 20 people. Campaign: the al-Masri family report, 427 complaints filed. The reply is a circular addressed "Dear Audience Member".
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. Each complainant raised one of four points. One asked the BBC to "name the actor in the sentences reporting the al-Masri family's deaths, as it does in the sentence reporting Israeli soldiers' deaths". Another asked the BBC to "attribute the Israeli casualty figure to its source, as the Palestinian figure is attributed, or attribute neither".
What the BBC said. Complainants asked why Palestinian deaths always carry a source and Israeli soldiers' deaths are stated as fact. The BBC replied:
“The idea it is possible to establish a “like-for-like” standard of language ignores the enormous differences of what is an asymmetric conflict – not least the fact it is taking place in Gaza, where civilian infrastructure has entirely crumbled, whereas Israel remains a functioning democracy.”
BBC Complaints Team, 7 August 2026
Why it fails. How a country is governed tells you nothing about whether its army's statements during a war are true. The Israeli military is a party to the killing. Its figures and its claims about who it killed come from that party. A parliament does not verify them.
"Civilian infrastructure has entirely crumbled" is written as if it happened by itself. Israel destroyed it. The BBC is using the result of Israel's bombing as a reason to trust Israel's numbers more than the numbers from the people being bombed.
The BBC says there is "an asymmetry in the information coming out of Gaza". In another reply it says "the BBC and international media are not allowed to enter Gaza". It does not say who stops them. Israel does. The gap in information that the BBC uses to justify doubting Palestinian figures is a gap Israel made.
In the same reply, the BBC says "Hamas-run" matters because Hamas is "a proscribed terrorist group in several countries". So the label is about Hamas's reputation, which is a different reason from the one it gives elsewhere (entry 5).
A month later the BBC gave a different reason again for the same double standard: "We have been able to verify the number of Israeli soldiers' deaths in Gaza." It does not say how. The source of those figures is the Israeli military.
What it reveals. This is the plainest statement of the BBC's position in the whole file. Complainants said there was a double standard. The BBC did not deny it. It said the two sides deserve different treatment because one is a democracy.
2. "After three years of warfare in Gaza, we consider readers would be well aware which armed forces are carrying out strikes on the territory."
- Logged by 69 people. Campaign: the Gaza floods report, 806 complaints filed. The BBC's reply opens by saying it received "a number of virtually identical complaints" and answers them as one.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked the BBC to write one sentence: "Israel has killed 74,594 people in Gaza since October 2023, according to the territory's health ministry." It also asked the BBC to say what damaged the buildings whose walls and roofs fell, to say in its own voice that Israel restricts what enters Gaza, and to add a note saying what was changed.
What the BBC said. The article names "the Hamas-led attack on Israel" for the dead in Israel and names nobody for the 74,594 dead in Gaza. The BBC's answer is that readers already know.
Why it fails. The BBC is saying it left out who killed 74,594 people because the public knows it was Israel. That is an admission that the BBC knows too, and chose not to write it.
It does not leave 7 October to readers' memory in the same article. After three years, readers know who attacked on 7 October as well. The BBC still writes it.
The BBC does not accept "the audience already knows" anywhere else. On 22 September 2026 it corrected two Radio 4 bulletins because they left out Ed Sheeran's condemnation of the 7 October attacks, which its own correction says was reported "extensively across BBC News". Listeners knew, and the BBC still ruled it had to be said.
Now set this beside "Hamas-run". The BBC says it adds that label because readers "may be unaware" that Hamas governs Gaza (entry 5). So after "nearly three years" of the BBC writing "Hamas-run" in every report, readers still may not know who runs Gaza. But after three years they are "well aware" who is bombing it.
What it reveals. What the BBC assumes readers know depends on which side the fact hurts. Facts about Hamas must be repeated every time. Facts about Israel can be left out because everybody knows.
3. "If we did not state that evidence had been produced, it was implicit that none had been."
- Logged by 4 people, in four separate Stage 1b replies across three campaigns: the al-Masri family report (427 complaints), the kites report (575) and the collapsed building report (436).
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. On the al-Masri report, the complaint asked the BBC to "attach a clear evidential caveat to the military's description of its target, making plain that the classification is an unverified assertion by an interested party". On the kites report, it asked for a note that "the BBC was unable to independently verify the military's account, including the claim that evacuation warnings were issued".
What the BBC said. Complainants asked the BBC to say when the Israeli military gives no evidence for a claim, such as "its target was a Hamas operative". The BBC replied that silence about evidence means there was none.
Why it fails. No reader knows this rule. The BBC has never published it. A reader who sees "The Israeli military said its target was a Hamas operative" takes it as a reported fact about the target. The BBC is asking the public to decode its silence.
The BBC also breaks its own rule. In another reply (entry 4) it says that when Israel releases photographs or documents, "we report on the evidence provided, or point out that no evidence has been provided". If silence already meant "no evidence", the BBC would never need to point it out. It does point it out, when it chooses to.
The BBC then adds that it "also did not state that the medical authorities in Gaza had provided no evidence to support the casualty figures". This treats the two sides as equal when the BBC's own practice does not. Gaza's figures carry "Hamas-run" every time, which the BBC says is there "so they can make an informed judgement about the figures". Israel's claims carry nothing.
What it reveals. The rule was written after the complaint, to fit the article. It appears at Stage 1b only, and the BBC cites no guideline for it.
4. "Israel was never likely to have shared... the evidence. Therefore, it would have been superfluous to state that Israel did not provide evidence."
- Logged by 1 person (plus 1 more for the same argument in different words: it "would be redundant"). Campaign: the Jabalia police post report, 536 complaints filed.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked the BBC to add to each Israeli military claim about the dead "the same plain qualifier the BBC applies to Palestinian institutions: that no evidence was provided and that the claim cannot be independently verified". It also asked for a headline that counted all nine dead: "Israeli fire kills nine in Gaza, including 10-year-old boy, officials say".
What the BBC said. The Israeli military said the dead at the police post were a Hamas commander and "three other terrorists". The BBC printed it with no note. Its defence: Israel would never publish military intelligence, so there is no point saying it gave none.
Why it fails. Follow the rule through. When Israel offers evidence, the BBC examines it. When Israel offers nothing and never will, the BBC stays silent. The claims a reader can least check reach the reader with the least warning. A secret reason for killing someone gets easier treatment than a public one.
The reason a reader needs to hear "no evidence was given" is exactly that none ever will be. That is the information.
What it reveals. The BBC has accepted that the Israeli military's word about who it killed is the best anyone will get, and has built its reporting practice around that. The Palestinian side gets a label on every figure. The side doing the killing gets its account of the dead passed on as given.
5. "Hamas-run", and its five different reasons
- "May be unaware": logged by 13 people. "Proscribed terrorist group": 20 people. "Well-established": 10 people. "Reuters, AP and others": 3 people. "Not obliged, purely for the sake of arithmetical balance": 12 people. Campaigns: al-Masri (427 complaints), Jabalia (536), kites (575), collapsed building (436), floods (806).
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaints asked for one standard. On the floods report: remove "Hamas-run". On the collapsed building: "either removing the faction label from the rescuers' count or qualifying the military's account in the same terms". On the kites report: apply the label "consistently to all institutional sources cited in the article", or review why it goes on Palestinian sources alone.
What the BBC said. Across these replies the BBC gives five reasons for the label:
- Readers "may be unaware" that Hamas governs Gaza.
- The guidelines require "important caveats" on unverified figures.
- Hamas is "a proscribed terrorist group in several countries".
- "Reuters, AP and others regularly use the phrase."
- The BBC's position is "well-established".
On why the Israeli military gets no label: "We do not describe the Israeli Defense Forces as the 'Israeli government-run Israeli Defense Forces' since readers would already be aware", and "those are such obvious facts. No one needs to be told them."
Why it fails. Five reasons for one practice means there is no settled reason. Take them in turn.
Reason 1 cannot survive three years of the BBC saying it in every report. Reason 4 is that other outlets do it. Reason 5 is that the BBC has always done it. Neither is a reason.
Reason 2 is the serious one, and the BBC undoes it. In one reply it says the label lets readers "make an informed judgement about the figures". In another, defending itself against the charge of treating the sides differently, it says: "We did not apply any verification warning to the Palestinian casualty figure." It is a caveat when the BBC needs to justify it and not a warning when the BBC needs to look even-handed.
In the floods reply the BBC writes "Hamas-run health ministry, whose figures are considered reliable by the UN". If the UN considers them reliable and the BBC says so, the caveat is doing something other than warning about reliability.
The label is also attached to things that are not statistics: the police who were killed, the civil defence, and a statement about flooded tents. Reason 2 does not cover any of those.
The "Israeli government-run IDF" line answers a request nobody made. Complainants did not ask for that phrase. They asked for the same caution about claims: a note that the Israeli military's account of who it killed is unverified and unevidenced.
What it reveals. The label does one job the BBC will only half admit, in reason 3. It tells the reader, every time Palestinian dead are counted, that the people counting are terrorists. That is why it survives every argument made against it.
6. "A concept which is not recognised in the guidelines."
- Logged by 1 person. It is the only Executive Complaints Unit ruling in the file. Campaign: the baby shot in the West Bank, 276 complaints filed.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked for "a revised headline naming Israeli forces as the actor, for example 'Israeli forces kill seven-month-old Palestinian baby in occupied West Bank'".
What the BBC said. The headline was "Palestinian baby killed by Israeli gunfire in West Bank, health ministry says". The complaint asked the BBC to say Israeli soldiers shot him. The Executive Complaints Unit, the BBC's final stage, ruled: "There is no requirement for a headline to focus on what you call the 'actor', a concept which is not recognised in the guidelines." It added that the wording "might have been improved upon but that does not show it was inaccurate", and that "the purpose of the complaints process is to assess whether material published by the BBC met its standards, rather than to answer questions about the rationale behind editorial decisions".
Why it fails. Who did it is the first fact of any news report. The BBC's guidelines require accuracy and say output must not mislead. Gunfire does not kill by itself. The ECU ruled the question out of bounds because the word "actor" is not in the guidelines.
The ECU then wrote the accurate sentence itself: "This story was about a baby who was shot and killed by armed forces." It could say it. It ruled the headline need not.
It also said readers "would entirely understand why the Israelis were being held responsible". If readers understand that anyway, there is no reason left to avoid writing it.
What it reveals. The BBC's highest complaints body will not explain editorial decisions and will not test them against anything but "materially misled", a test almost any headline passes if the article fills in the gap. The stage that exists to hold the BBC to its standards has defined its job so that the question complainants ask most cannot be asked.
7. "This word was not used in the long version of Mr Polanski's interview we quoted."
- Logged by 19 people. Campaign: the Green Party "Zionism is racism" vote report, 606 complaints filed. The BBC says: "This response... is being sent to everyone."
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked the BBC to do three things: "Add the words Polanski used in his interview with the BBC. Add the joint statement's sentence on genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation. Add a Palestinian voice, starting with the motion's proposer."
What the BBC said. Complainants said the article never used the word genocide, though the party leader had used it to the BBC. The BBC replied that the word was not in the version of the interview it quoted.
Why it fails. That is because the BBC cut it. The Independent reported the same BBC interview: Polanski said the motion defines Zionism as "the displacement and genocide of the Palestinian people" and that this is "clearly racism". The BBC published his answer without that word and then pointed to its own published version as proof he had not said it. (This rests on The Independent's report. We have not seen the BBC's recording.)
The same reply defends the article by quoting a sentence from it: "Debate about the motion, as well as the conflict in Gaza, has featured heavily." That sentence had been deleted from the article before any complaint was sent. In its second reply the BBC admitted the sentence was gone, and said rewriting "does not constitute a breach of our editorial standards". It defended the article with a line it had removed, and when caught, defended removing it.
The BBC says the complaint that no Palestinian was quoted "is incorrect", because it quoted Lubna Speitan, "who describes herself as British-Palestinian". The article does not tell readers she is Palestinian. The lines it chose from her are about "all forms of racism" and say nothing about Palestine.
On why it quoted the party leaders' statement about being "an anti-racist party" and cut their sentence opposing "genocide, ethnic cleansing, apartheid and the illegal occupation": the motion "hinged on whether Zionism is racism". Apartheid is racism written into law. On the BBC's own reasoning, the cut sentence was the relevant one.
What it reveals. Each cut is defended as a separate "matter of editorial judgement". Every one of them removes the same word. Polanski said genocide, the party leadership wrote it, the deputy leader said it to Sky, and no version of the BBC's article contains it. An editorial judgement that always lands the same way is a policy.
8. "The Israeli government would deny that they are extremist."
- Logged by 81 people. Campaign: Newsnight's Bernie Sanders interview, 954 complaints filed. Circular reply.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked how the denial was "tested against documented statements by Israeli officials", why that evidence was not raised, and which other coverage the BBC relies on for due impartiality. It asked whether Newsnight will "review whether presenters apply consistent scrutiny when putting Israeli denials to guests".
What the BBC said. Sanders called for no more military aid for "the extremist government in Israel". Victoria Derbyshire replied on air: "Okay. The Israeli government would deny that they are extremist." The BBC's whole defence is one sentence: "We reject the suggestion that highlighting the fact that the Israeli government would dispute Mr Sanders' description was inappropriate."
Why it fails. Nobody made that suggestion. The complaint accepted that Israel's view can be reported. It asked why the BBC supplied Israel's denial and not the words of Israel's own ministers, which are what a viewer needs to judge the word "extremist". Yoav Gallant announced a complete siege of Gaza and said "We are fighting human animals". Bezalel Smotrich said it might be "justified and moral" to let two million civilians die of hunger. The reply mentions neither.
"Would deny" is a prediction. The BBC calls it "the fact". Complainants asked whether the BBC held any statement from the Israeli government or whether the presenter supplied the denial herself. The BBC did not answer.
The BBC answered none of the questions put to it and then said the comments had been "recorded... in our complaints report". Recording a complaint is not answering it.
What it reveals. A BBC presenter acted as the Israeli government's spokesperson, unprompted, and the BBC's complaints team sees nothing to explain. Speaking up for Israel when it is criticised is so normal inside the BBC that it does not register as a choice.
9. "It may have given readers the false impression that the strike had only just happened."
- Logged by 10 people. Campaign: the collapsed building report, 436 complaints filed.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked the BBC to "amend the headline to attribute the damage as the body does", and gave the Guardian's headline on the same story as the example: "At least 21 killed after Israeli-hit building in Gaza City collapses". It also asked the BBC to add that there has been no reconstruction since the ceasefire, and that Israel has said it will not permit rebuilding until Hamas disarms.
What the BBC said. Eight children were among 21 people killed when a building in Tal al-Hawa collapsed. The BBC's report says the building "had been left tilting dangerously to one side after an Israeli strike more than a year ago". The headline said "war-damaged". The BBC said that writing "Israeli-hit" might have made readers think the strike was recent.
Why it fails. "War-damaged" does not say when either. It also does not say who. The BBC removed the actor to fix a problem with the date, and the fix left the date exactly as unclear.
If the worry was timing, the headline could have said "building hit by Israel last year". The BBC had the words. It names the strike in its second paragraph.
At Stage 1b the BBC went further: "No one who simply reads a headline can claim familiarity with the story it introduces." A complainant said the report left out that Israel has said it will not permit rebuilding until Hamas disarms. The BBC replied that this was "not necessary for explaining how 21 people had sadly come to die from the collapse of a building which Israel had damaged previously in the war".
Read that last sentence again. The BBC, in its own voice, says Israel damaged the building. It will write that to a complainant. It would not write it in the headline.
What it reveals. The BBC treats naming Israel as the risk to be managed. It imagines a reader misled about timing and removes Israel to protect them. It does not imagine the reader who sees "war-damaged", reads no further, and never learns who did it. And Israel's policy on rebuilding is ruled irrelevant to why families were living in a tilting building when it fell.
10. The kite headline
- Logged by 10 people. Campaign: the kites report, 575 complaints filed.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked for the headline to be "amended to reflect the most significant verifiable fact in the article, namely that people were killed in Israeli strikes". Its example: "Two killed in Israeli strikes as Israel warns of 'forceful' response to Gaza kites."
What the BBC said. The headline was "Israel warns of 'forceful' response to kites flown from Gaza". The same report said two people had been killed in Israeli strikes on Nuseirat and al-Zawayda. The BBC replied that its journalists judged the kite warning "the most newsworthy development and one which would interest readers the most".
At Stage 1b, to show the dead were in the article, the BBC quoted its own report: "On the same day that Fida was killed, 14-year-old Ismail al-Bardawil was also shot dead."
Why it fails. The BBC quoted the shooting of a 14-year-old to defend a headline about kites. It said what to put in a headline "is not a matter which is subject to our Editorial Guidelines". The guidelines on impartiality and due weight apply to all BBC output. Headlines are output.
A complainant said the article used the active voice for the Israeli minister and the passive for the Palestinians he killed. The BBC replied that writing Katz's quote in the passive "would have been absurd", and "We cannot see what purpose this would achieve". Nobody asked for that. The complaint asked the BBC to write the deaths in the active voice.
What it reveals. An Israeli minister's threat is news. The deaths are "other related news". The BBC wrote that distinction down as its judgement of what interests readers.
11. The qualifier is for "competing accounts", except these competing accounts
- Logged by 42 people across three campaigns: Dr Abu Safiya (996 complaints on the broadcast and 995 on the article), Jabalia (536) and al-Masri (427). All three replies are circulars.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked for one clause: "the Israel Prison Service did not provide evidence for its rejection, which the BBC cannot independently verify." It asked for a note recording the change, "matching the transparency the BBC applies to claims attributed to the Gaza health ministry".
What the BBC said. Dr Hussam Abu Safiya's lawyer said he had been beaten so badly he could not be recognised. The Israeli Prison Service denied it. Complainants asked the BBC to say the denial came with no evidence and could not be verified. The BBC replied that such wording "is often used when reporting competing accounts of a specific event", but this was "the position taken by prison authorities, in response to allegations made about their treatment of a detainee".
Why it fails. A lawyer says a man was beaten. The prison says he was not. That is two competing accounts of a specific event.
The BBC says so itself two paragraphs later: "We also aim to provide enough detail so that our audiences are then able to assess those competing accounts for themselves." The reply uses the phrase "competing accounts" to say the rule does not apply and then uses it again to describe the case.
The BBC also says the denial was "clearly attributed... rather than presented as an established fact". Gaza's casualty figures are clearly attributed too. They still get the extra warning.
What it reveals. "Cannot be independently verified" is a phrase the BBC keeps for Palestinian sources. When asked to apply it to an Israeli prison denying it beat a doctor held 18 months without charge, the BBC invented a category, "the position taken by authorities", in which it does not apply.
12. UN figures: fact when it is displacement, an estimate when it is the dead
- "We state as fact because we regard the figure as accurate": logged by 67 people (floods, 806 complaints). "An estimate, which the BBC has not verified": logged by 4 people (BBC Sport, 529 complaints).
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The Sport complaint asked: "Why the 1,200 Israeli deaths are stated by the BBC as fact, while more than 70,000 Palestinian deaths are attributed to what the United Nations 'believes'." The floods complaint objected to "the Israeli war against Hamas" in the BBC's own voice, and asked the BBC to write "displaced by what Israel calls its war against Hamas".
What the BBC said. On the 90% displacement figure: "This is a claim by the UN which we state as fact because we regard the figure as accurate." On the death toll in the BBC Sport feature: "The United Nations believes the retaliation has killed more than 70,000 Palestinians... The UN's figure is an estimate, which the BBC has not verified, and it is important therefore that we attribute it clearly."
In the same Sport article the Israeli toll, "about 1,200", has no source. The BBC's reason, from the floods reply: 7 October is "a single historical event where the victims have been extensively documented".
Why it fails. The BBC cannot enter Gaza to verify displacement any more than it can verify deaths. It accepts one UN figure as fact and holds the other at arm's length with "believes". The difference between the two figures is that one counts people Israel moved and the other counts people Israel killed.
The first reply on the Sport article called them "those believed killed in Gaza". "Believed" is the BBC's word.
What it reveals. The BBC's rule about verification bends by subject. The number that most directly measures what Israel has done is the number the BBC keeps at a distance.
13. "Reshape"
- Logged by 47 people. Campaign: the E1 settlement headlines, 493 complaints filed on this headline and 488 on the second.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaints said the articles were accurate and asked only for the headlines to be changed. For the first: "How Israel is expanding illegal settlements in drive to isolate West Bank". For the second: "Israel invites bids to build illegal settlement that would split West Bank". Each is the same length as the BBC's headline.
What the BBC said. The headline was "How Israel is expanding settlements in drive to reshape West Bank". The BBC wrote: "It is an established fact that settlement building in the West Bank is against international law." It said the plan "would divide the north and the south of the West Bank and would split the West Bank from occupied East Jerusalem", and that this "was adequately described in the headline with the term 'reshape'". The loss of Palestinian land "was also implicit in the term 'reshape'". It added: "We also added maps and photo sliders to make this clear to readers."
On the second headline, "highly sensitive West Bank settlement project", it explained that it wrote "highly sensitive" because the plan "would split the northern and southern parts of the West Bank, and isolate East Jerusalem".
Why it fails. The BBC lists four things it knows: the settlement is illegal, it cuts the West Bank in two, it cuts off East Jerusalem, and Palestinians lose land. It then says one verb carries all four. "Implicit" means the headline does not say it. You add maps and sliders to make something clear when the headline has not.
On "highly sensitive", the BBC's explanation is the complaint. It knows exactly what the phrase stands for and chose a phrase that points at the facts without stating them. Complainants offered a headline of the same length with the facts in it. The BBC did not mention it.
No euphemism could fail this test. If a fact is "established", is in the article, and can be called "implicit" in a soft word, any soft word passes.
What it reveals. The BBC will state that the settlements are illegal in a private reply to a complainant and will not state it where the public sees it. It closes with "We are sorry if you did not appreciate our coverage". The complaints had said the article was accurate and objected to the headline.
14. Headlines "are not meant to be read in isolation"
- Logged by 33 people across six campaigns: the baby shot in the West Bank (276 complaints), Jabalia (536), the two E1 settlement headlines (493 and 488), the kites report (575), the collapsed building (436) and the Cosham hotel crowd (396).
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. Each complaint offered a headline of the same length that names who did it, and they are quoted in the other entries. The headline complaints from September onwards also asked one question in advance: "what proportion of the audience who see a BBC News headline go on to read the article?" They added: "If the BBC holds no such figure, it should say so, because the defence then has no evidence behind it."
What the BBC said. Every headline complaint gets a version of this: headlines "should not be read in isolation but in conjunction with the text".
Why it fails. Headlines are read in isolation. They appear alone in push alerts, app cards, search results and social feeds. The defence only works if most people who see a headline read the article. So complainants asked one question: what proportion do?
The BBC would not say. Its Stage 1b answer: "the issue is not how many people read it but whether the headline itself is duly accurate."
That sentence ends the defence. If the test is whether "the headline itself" is accurate, then the headline is being judged in isolation, which is what the BBC said must not be done. If the test is the headline plus the article, the number of people who read the article is the whole question. The BBC uses the first test to avoid giving the number and the second to avoid looking at the headline.
When complainants pointed out in advance that "read it with the article" concedes the headline cannot stand alone, the BBC replied that this was "a straightforward statement of fact". It agreed with the complaint and rejected it.
What it reveals. The BBC has no figure, or has one it will not share. A defence it uses in reply after reply rests on an assumption about its own readers that it has either never checked or does not want known.
15. "Due impartiality doesn't necessarily mean that we need to feature guests from opposing sides within one programme."
- Logged by 65 people. Campaign: Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg, 1,084 complaints filed. The BBC says: "we're sending the same response to everyone."
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked the BBC to say "whether the programme invited any Palestinian to discuss the motion and, if not, set out the reasoned decision guideline 2.4.4 requires for leaving that perspective out". It asked the BBC to "give a Palestinian contributor a fair chance to make the case for the motion", on the programme or in linked output.
What the BBC said. The programme discussed a motion about Palestinians and interviewed no Palestinian. The BBC replied that the three panellists "represented a good range of views with regard to UK politics", quoted Zack Polanski and Dale Vince criticising Israel, and said a "nuanced range of voices" had been heard "across the... series as a whole".
Why it fails. The complaint was that no Palestinian was heard and nobody made the case for the motion. A range of views on UK politics is a range on a different question. The BBC itself says Polanski "had not backed" the motion. On the motion, the panel ran from against to against.
The BBC answers a complaint about leaving out Palestinians by listing British people who talked about them.
Its own guidelines say that when a programme does not carry a significant view, it must be in "clearly linked and timely" output. Complainants asked which programme, which date, which contributor. The BBC named none. They asked whether any Palestinian was invited. No answer.
What it reveals. The BBC considers Palestinians a subject, to be discussed by others, and does not consider them a side that must be heard. It did not notice that its answer makes that point for the complainants.
16. "We can find no report on the programme that day matching this description."
- Logged by 9 people. Campaign: Jeremy Bowen on BBC News at One, 318 participants (this campaign has no page counter).
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked for a published correction giving the Palestinian Central Bureau of Statistics estimate of about 2.13 million. It asked the BBC to "either state both outcomes of the 1948 war as events (Israeli independence and the Nakba, the displacement of approximately 750,000 Palestinians) or attribute both". It asked for a list of dated BBC items that carried the legal context left out, and an answer to each point.
What the BBC said. It told nine people it could not find the broadcast and asked them for the programme name and date, both of which the reply itself restates. Over the same days it sent eight other people, who had filed the same complaint, a point-by-point defence of the same broadcast.
In that defence, asked where Bowen's Gaza population figure came from: "The circumstances in Gaza mean it isn't possible to gather precise information as to the current population; Jeremy reflected the approximate estimate."
Why it fails. The BBC found the item for half the complainants and told the other half it did not exist. One person was told so twice under the same case number.
On the population figure, two weeks earlier the same team had written that its guidelines "require us to name our sources when citing figures which we are unable to verify". That is the rule behind "Hamas-run". For a Gaza figure broadcast in the BBC's own voice, it named no source.
The BBC said the item "wasn't intended to be a detailed examination of the Israel-Gaza war". It was too narrow for the arrest warrant against Israel's prime minister and had room for the events of 1948.
What it reveals. The sourcing rule binds when the number is Palestinian dead and lapses when the number is the BBC's own. "Scope" is the defence whenever the missing fact is one that counts against Israel. The BBC Sport reply uses it too: the feature "didn't intend to discuss the Israel-Gaza war", under a headline that turns on "Hamas attacked Israel".
17. "No inference should be drawn from slightly different wording which is done for style reasons."
- Logged by 10 people. Campaign: the collapsed building report, 436 complaints filed.
- Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
What the complaint asked for. The complaint asked the BBC to "apply one standard to verification cues", and to "set out the standard applied to source labelling in this coverage and how it is applied to both parties".
What the BBC said. The report said five Palestinians including two children were killed "according to health officials and Hamas sources". After the Israeli military's version, the children had "reportedly" been killed. Asked why, the BBC said it was style.
Why it fails. The BBC's defence of "Hamas-run", of "health ministry says" and of every attribution label is that wording is chosen with care and carries meaning for the reader. Here it says readers should take no meaning from its wording. It cannot hold both.
What it reveals. Wording matters when the BBC is asked to justify a label on Palestinians and stops mattering when the BBC is asked to explain a shift in certainty about dead children.
What the BBC changed, and how fast
- Golders Green and Iran (498 complaints, 8 people logged the reply). The BBC amended the article in eight days and added a note. No wall entry yet.
- Gosport protest (340 complaints, 5 logged). Amended, with a clarification note. No wall entry yet.
- Prince Harry (1,434 complaints). Amended, with a note. Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
- Al-Aqsa "in Israel" (537 complaints, 9 logged). The error was cut from BBC Sounds. Nothing was published on the corrections page. Read our summary of this reply on the responses wall
Across the reports on Israel and Palestine in this file, that last one is the only change the BBC made, and it made it without a public note.
Habits that run through every reply
- It answers complaints nobody made. The 90% figure nobody disputed. "Israel says" that nobody called unattributed. The "suggestion" about Sanders nobody made. "Israeli government-run IDF" that nobody asked for. Katz in the passive voice.
- It objects to templates in a template. The BBC notes complaints of "virtually identical wording" in replies logged by 79 people. Those replies are circulars addressed "Dear Audience Member", sent to everyone "to ensure we use our licence fee resources as efficiently as possible".
- "We are sorry if you did not appreciate our coverage." Logged by 79 people. It turns a complaint about accuracy into a matter of taste.
- "A matter in which our journalists are free to exercise their editorial judgement." This is offered as an answer. Whether the judgement met the guidelines is the question being asked.
The pattern
Put the replies side by side and one rule explains all of them.
- A fact that counts against Israel can be left out, because readers know it, or it is implicit, or it is in the article, or the item was not about that.
- A fact that counts against Hamas has to be written in every time, because readers may not know it.
- An Israeli claim with no evidence is passed on, because readers can judge for themselves.
- A Palestinian figure gets a label, because readers need help to judge.
The BBC gave different reasons to different people at different stages, and some of those reasons contradict each other. The outcome was the same every time.
Conversation
Be specific, respectful and constructive. Comments are public to readers who can access this article. Publishers can hold or remove comments.
Loading the conversation…
