ITV News, on UK Politics, 17 November 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

Raising revenue ‘not reasonable’ while Stormont underfunded says Finance Minister

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findingsSee it marked on itv.com

Stormont’s finance minister has said it is not “reasonable” for the UK Treasury to expect revenue-raising measures in Northern Ireland while the region “remains underfunded”. John O’Dowd also said there is a “fairness issue”, and argued for more tax-varying powers for the Northern Ireland Executive. Micheál Martin ‘not contemplating’ Omagh bomb inquiry in Republic Translink cut some late services and discounts Ministers have said they cannot strike a budget for 2026-27 without additional financial support from the Treasury.

The UK Government has offered about £1.5 billion in extra funding over the next three years, with £525 million delivered this year, in an effort to help balance the books, but Stormont’s leaders have said that is not enough. Last month’s UK Budget allocated a further £131 million of extra funding to Northern Ireland in the current financial year and a total of £270 million across three years. Mr O’Dowd, who released a draft multi-year budget in January, said he remains “determined” to get to a point where a multi-year settlement can be reached.

“The reality is that, following the Autumn Budget, we are expected to be underfunded, below 124%, in each and every year of this Spending Review period,” he told the assembly chamber. “The reality is that around one third of the financial package on offer would be required just to bring us back to the Westminster Government agreed level of funding. “It would mean the Executive continuing to be trapped in a cycle of drifting from one short-term cash injection to the next and continuing to be underfunded relative to other devolved regions.

“This is not a platform for fiscal stability. It is a continuation of the very instability that must be addressed.” The finance minister said the Executive “has a plan for the reform of public services” but they will “continue to be constrained in its ability to deliver these reforms for as long as the current pattern of underfunding persists”. “Not only is the Executive not fairly funded compared to Wales and Scotland, but we have also been denied the other fiscal tools these administrations have at their disposal which help them to achieve a balanced budget,” he said.

He added: “I am not sure how much more information the Treasury needs to verify the reality of the pressures we face, and indeed . “Further, the British Secretary of State, Chris Bryant has yet to explain, either privately or publicly, why we are not being afforded the same treatment as our colleagues in Scotland and Wales.” It is understood the extra funding coming from Westminster would be dependent on Stormont committing to raise about £200 million annually of its own revenues, with Sir Chris referring on previous occasions to water or prescription charges.

Left out here: Drops what it reported before

The Secretary of State's reply, reported by this outlet on 16 November, that the region is funded above its independently assessed level of need. Without it a reader takes the minister's claim about Treasury analysis as settled.

How we know

The finance minister said the suggestion that revenue raising would address Stormont’s pressures is to “oversimplify the challenge we face”. “If you were to listen to the Secretary of State, Chris Bryant, you would think that the Executive doesn’t raise any revenue,” he said. “As Members will be aware, as it stands the regional rate is the main lever available to us as an Executive to raise income. “So, for context, if we wanted to raise an additional £100m that would require raising the regional rate by 11%.

Closing the shortfall would therefore require an increase several times that size. “I don’t think that is realistic nor do I think it is fair to expect households or businesses to face rates rises of this scale while the executive remains underfunded. “The Secretary of State may well believe the answer is to put further pressure on families and businesses that are already struggling. But I do not.” Leader of the Stormont Opposition Matthew O’Toole described the minister’s statement as “a shambles and a disgrace”.

“You talk about reality – the reality is, you, not anybody else, published a draft budget in January this year and told Executive parties to sign up to it,” he said. He added: “If you refuse to set a budget, and we have always supported the Executive’s calls for more money, and we still do, but if this Executive refuses to set a budget, one of two things will happen – either the UK Government will set a punishment budget, or the Executive will run out of money.

“My suspicion is you want them to set a punishment budget so you can shift blame. Which is it?” Mr O’Dowd asked Mr O’Toole if he is a “spokesperson for Chris Bryant” and accused him of “defending the indefensible”. “You say: ‘Go ahead and set a budget’. What I am saying to you is this: everybody in this chamber and everybody around the executive table should be united in one call, that the British Government have a responsibility to fund this place properly,” he said.

“They are failing to do so, and you are a disgrace.” In the most recent autumn budget, the UK Government announced new fiscal powers for local councils, primarily through greater local control over business rates revenue. Mr O’Dowd said he wants to see a fiscal framework for Northern Ireland that should include “a number of tax-varying powers that should be devolved to the executive” and highlighted that the region is “not given equal access to national wealth fund”.

“As part of the budget a number of weeks ago, the British Government pumped billions of pounds of that national wealth fund,” he said. “We, as an executive, our businesses, our councils, do not have equal access to that funding. “The Housing Executive, in terms of borrowing, councils in England and Wales can access borrowing at a much lower rate for housing and improvements to the housing, than the housing executive can or the Executive can.

“The British Government is denying access to us as well. So this is a fairness issue. This is about getting fair and equal treatment for the people we represent.” Catch up with the latest UTV Live on ITVX Sign up for our free weekly newsletter here. Want a quick and expert briefing on the biggest news stories? Listen to our latest podcasts to find out What You Need To Know…

Read the original article on itv.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

ITV News reports finance minister John O'Dowd's claim that Stormont is underfunded and that revenue-raising would be unfair, and quotes the opposition at length. Its own earlier article of 16 November carried the Secretary of State's reply that the region is funded above its assessed level of need, but this article drops that reply and leaves the minister's claim about Treasury analysis unchallenged.

  1. Drops what it reported before

    Serious

    “it is their own analysis that is verifying that we are being underfunded”

    Why this matters
    The words present the minister's reading of Treasury figures as proof that Northern Ireland is underfunded. The article prints that reading and does not carry the Secretary of State's reply to it.
    The impression it gives
    That the Treasury's own analysis has settled that Northern Ireland is underfunded.
    The context
    The Secretary of State, Chris Bryant, hit back in this outlet's own report of 16 November that the region is funded above its independently assessed level of need. This article leaves that reply out, and the word independently appears nowhere in it.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    The finance minister says the Treasury's own analysis shows Northern Ireland is underfunded. The Secretary of State says the region is funded above its independently assessed level of need, and the article should report both positions.

  2. Drops what it reported before

    Serious

    What is missing

    The Secretary of State's reply, reported by this outlet on 16 November, that the region is funded above its independently assessed level of need. Without it a reader takes the minister's claim about Treasury analysis as settled.

    How we know

    Show where it belongs

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from ITV News

  1. 17 NovMilburn review urges 'radical' welfare reforms to tackle youth unemployment3.0
  2. 17 NovKing attends abbey service ahead of historic General Synod opening0.0
  3. 17 NovIs Milburn’s triumph that his youth employment plan will upset everyone? 0.0
  4. 17 NovGovernment plans to expel failed asylum seekers without notice6.0
  5. 17 NovBurnham urged by SNP to ‘stop dithering’ and rejoin the EU3.0

Everything we scored from ITV News