Is Milburn’s triumph that his youth employment plan will upset everyone?
I first met Andy Burnham and Alan Milburn when they were political apprentices under Tony Blair and Gordon Brown. One is now prime minister and the other has written a report that he defines as the culmination of his life’s work. Milburn’s “From a Welfare State to a Working State” is big in its ambitions, broad in its scope and the length of a Leo Tolstoy novel. Ostensibly, it is about ending the scandal of one in eight young people who are not in education, training or work, the NEETS, of whom 60% have defined themselves as never likely to participate in work.
This is a waste of human capability of tragic scale. And as an indictment of how we run Britain, it is worse than in any other comparable rich country. In his words: “The NEET crisis is a moral problem with dire economic and fiscal consequences”. Milburn’s prescriptions are bold. And their implications go well beyond just the mandate he was set, by the last PM, Keir Starmer. He frequently points out that a welfare system and NHS that is failing young people isn’t much more satisfactory for older generations, and he can’t resist telling his former ministerial colleague Burnham to hurry up and reform all of it.
He has too many recommendations to list here. But here are some of the headlines. Schools are not vocational and work-oriented enough. The NHS is not preventative enough, especially when it comes to mental illness. And when young people are diagnosed with ADHD, or depression or milder forms of autistic spectrum disorder, they are too readily put on benefits and left to stew at home. No individual or institution has a responsibility to help them create a life of gainful employment.
They are abandoned. Fixing all this, in Milburn’s prescription, would not be cheap. Much of today’s fractious debate between the government and opposition parties is around the unaffordability of a welfare bill rising too fast against the constraining backdrop of the UK’s substantial government debt and sluggish growth. Peston: Why Milburn's NEET reforms will upset both left and right More than a third of Neets living in nine largest cities, research finds Under the Milburn plan, the near £6bn-a-year annual cost of supporting young people into work - through a new Youth Opportunity Service, substantial subsidies to employers who give unemployed young people a chance, plus health and education expenditures - will exceed benefit savings and incremental tax revenues till at least 2036.
And it is by no means certain these reforms would pay for themselves even in ten years, because they are dependent on inherently unreliable projections of future growth and future tax. So the argument in their favour is, as Milburn says, largely a moral one. But here, for the left of the Labour Party, the Greens and (probably) the Lib Dems are the painful rub. Milburn wants wholesale reform of the disability and incapacity system as it applies to young people, because he thinks it acts as a powerful disincentive to taking employment.
His proposed new youth allowance of roughly £80 a week could, in theory, see young people lose hundreds of pounds of weekly benefits payments. Most would lose much less than that. Also, Milburn promises to protect the most vulnerable for life, and those who get into work should be better off. But there are social risks. The most important is that the new benefits system, which will be legislated soon but won’t be implemented till after the next election, will make young people poorer before the new structures for facilitating employment are working effectively.
And there is another risk. Milburn is embracing Burnham’s devolution strategy. The new Youth Opportunity Service will not be a one-size-fits-all, but will be shaped by mayors and strategic authorities for the needs of their areas. Inevitably some of the new centres for stewarding young people into work will be shining lights, and some will be dismal jobsworths. Subscribe free to our weekly newsletter for exclusive and original coverage from ITV News.
Direct to your inbox every Friday morning. But local young people wherever they are will be subject to the same benefit cuts, including the potential loss of all benefits if they refuse to cooperate. To put it another way, Milburn is alienating the right by not being radical enough on benefit reforms and cuts, whereas he is upsetting the left by being too brutal. He also risks upsetting the soft left by asserting that some of their cherished workers’ rights reforms are a deterrent to youth employment.
Putting party politics to one side, the one big gap is the absence of any kind of prescription to reverse the potentially devastating impact of artificial intelligence on the availability of starter jobs. But in the round, and as I mentioned in an earlier note, it’s all as if Blair and Brown’s New Labour was only ever resting. It may have seemed a dead parrot during the Corbyn years, but its plumage is being flaunted, and it may well fly again.
From Westminster to Washington DC - our political experts are across all the latest key talking points. Listen to the latest episode below...
Read the original article on itv.com (opens in a new tab)