Has Burnham opened a can of worms by wanting ‘honest discussion’ over Brexit? VOTE NOW

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.3 findings

Comment now Next ANDY Burnham has opened the door to bringing back freedom of movement – a major plank of the Brexit vote. The Prime Minister said he wants to have an “honest discussion” on free movement and closer ties to the EU. His starting point will be holding a summit with the EU where he looks for a better deal since leaving the bloc. He is committed Labour’s 2024 manifesto which said there would be no return to the single market, customs union and freedom of movement.

Advertisement Sign up for the Politics newsletter Thank you! Email address Please provide a valid email. Your info will be used in accordance with our Privacy Policy You'll now receive top stories, breaking news, and more, straight to your email. However, this could all change if Mr Burnham wins an election and returns to Downing Street with his own mandate Nigel Farage said the move could pave the way for 450 million people coming here and undercutting British labour.

Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture

The Sun says the manifesto pledge "could all change" if Burnham wins an election with his own mandate. It never reports that in the same interviews he suggested a referendum would be needed to revive free movement and said he would never move ahead of the public on Brexit. Without this a reader may think an election win alone is his route back to free movement.

How we know

Daily Mail reported“He suggested a referendum would be needed to revive free movement”Labour revolt at Burnham bringing back Brexit wars as MPs warn over free movement talks with EU… and Cabinet splits deepen (opens in a new tab)

Read more on politics DAVID WOODING We had an 'honest discussion' about the EU, Andy… it was called a referendum TONY PARSONS Burnham is conning the nation with his Brexit pitch…EU will NEVER take us back Kemi Badenoch added that this was another example of Burnham’s “foot in mouth syndrome” of speaking before engaging brain. Having told voters in Makerfield he that he didn’t want to re-run the Brexit arguments, has this call for discussions opened a can of worms?

Have your say in our exclusive poll and fill out the form below for a chance to win a £100 voucher. Love to debate? Join Sun Club for just £1.99 a month for the boldest opinion on the issues shaping Britain. Most read in The Sun JAIL MOVE Brit ‘drug mule’ moved from hellhole jail after riots leave 30 dead in Sri Lanka ‘AM I DYING’ Influencer ‘bled to death’ at home as doula ‘groomed her to fear hospitals’ POPPY ROW Veteran barred entry from Wetherspoons for wearing poppy as it's 'too political' SAVAGE MAULING Moment woman attacked by neighbour's dog before man suffers horror injuries POLL OF THE DAY - WIN A £100 VOUCHER What are your thoughts?

Tell us the reasons why you voted the way you did * Name * Name * First Name Last Name Email * Your information will be used in accordance with our Privacy Policy . The best comment of the month will win a £100 Amazon voucher. Full competition terms and conditions can be found here . Do you want News Group Newspapers Limited to keep you informed about special offers, promotions and information that may be of interest to you? * Do you want News Group Newspapers Limited to keep you informed about special offers, promotions and information that may be of interest to you?

Required field Yes No Would you like to receive The Sun's daily round-up of news in your inbox each day? You can opt-out at any time. * Would you like to receive The Sun's daily round-up of news in your inbox each day? You can opt-out at any time. Required field Yes No Enter Comment now

Read the original article on thesun.co.uk

What we found (3)

The Sun turns Andy Burnham's call for an "honest discussion" on free movement into a reader poll framed only by his opponents. Nigel Farage's claim that free movement could bring 450 million people here to undercut British labour stands with nothing against it. The article also leaves out Burnham's own reasons and his reported pledge not to move ahead of the public.

Gives a contested claim the last word
Minor
“Nigel Farage said the move could pave the way for 450 million people coming here and undercutting British labour”
Why this matters
The Sun prints Farage's figure of "450 million people coming here" and his claim of "undercutting British labour" and moves straight on to more criticism. Nothing in the article tests either claim.
The impression it gives
A reader comes away thinking free movement would bring a large share of the EU's population to Britain and would push down British workers' pay.
The context
The 450 million figure is the population of the bloc, not a forecast of arrivals. The government's Migration Advisory Committee found migration is not a major factor in UK-born workers' wages. Burnham himself described earlier EU migration as people who came and then went back. The article gives the reader none of this.
How we know
- Our analysis“found that migration is not a major factor in the wages of UK-born workers”Love Without Substance
- Euronews reported“Revolving door migration where people would come and then go back is different.”UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham wants 'honest discussion' on return to EU free movement (opens in a new tab)
Show it in the article
One side gets the space
Minor
“Kemi Badenoch added that this was another example of Burnham’s “foot in mouth syndrome” of speaking before engaging brain.”
Why this matters
After Farage, The Sun gives the next quoted reaction to Kemi Badenoch's personal jibe. Burnham's case appears only as the two words "honest discussion".
The impression it gives
A reader learns what Burnham's opponents think of him but not what he actually said about immigration or why.
The context
Burnham explained that immigration had changed since Brexit and that earlier EU migration was people who came and then went back. The article quotes none of his reasoning before asking readers to vote.
How we know
- Euronews reported“The balance of migration has changed, hasn't it, since then? I think we've just got to have an honest discussion about those things.”UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham wants 'honest discussion' on return to EU free movement (opens in a new tab)
Show it in the article
Leaves out what changes the picture
Minor
What is missing
The Sun says the manifesto pledge "could all change" if Burnham wins an election with his own mandate. It never reports that in the same interviews he suggested a referendum would be needed to revive free movement and said he would never move ahead of the public on Brexit. Without this a reader may think an election win alone is his route back to free movement.
How we know
- Daily Mail reported“He suggested a referendum would be needed to revive free movement”Labour revolt at Burnham bringing back Brexit wars as MPs warn over free movement talks with EU… and Cabinet splits deepen (opens in a new tab)
Show where it belongs

Has Burnham opened a can of worms by wanting ‘honest discussion’ over Brexit? VOTE NOW

Gives a contested claim the last word

One side gets the space

Leaves out what changes the picture

How other outlets reported it

More from The Sun