The Independent, on Climate, 6 November 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

Desert icons collapse as southwestern US gets pummeled with rain and flooding

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 finding

Become an Independent member to bookmark this article Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today. Join today Already a member? Log in There are stretches of high desert in northwestern New Mexico where Mother Nature has sculpted otherworldly forms using wind, rain and the passage of time. Hefty planks of rock defy gravity as they balance atop spindly pedestals of clay, while some columns of sandstone take on the appearance of lace, elaborately eroded by the seasons.

Tour guide Kialo Winters shares this piece of his homeland on the edge of the Ah-Shi-Sle-Pah Wilderness with visitors regularly. On a recent Friday afternoon, the founder of Navajo Tours USA rounded a bend and found one of the area's most famous features had collapsed. The Alien Throne — or Tsé Bináká Níyol as it's known in his language — was no more. His heart dropped. “It was surreal,” he told The Associated Press. “I had to sort of just pause.

A lot of things ran through my head.” The Alien Throne and the nearby King of Wings formation collapsed within weeks of each other, toppled by the very forces of nature that created them. Back-to-back storms destroy homes and hoodoos The southwestern U.S. has endured major rounds of storms over recent weeks, with rain falling on ground already soaked from an especially wet fall. Parts of New Mexico, Colorado, Utah and Arizona .

The water is receding and cleanup is underway, but officials estimate the damage could stretch into the hundreds of millions of dollars. Winters still is concerned for relatives on the Navajo Nation , where many dirt roads became impassable or were washed away altogether by what he described as a series of massive storm fronts. Experts have estimated that .

Condolences shared after the features collapse In early October, the demise of the King of Wings began circulating on social media. Visitors documented the large slab of rock on the ground near the mound of clay on which it once stood. It's not entirely clear when the Alien Throne came down, as poor road conditions kept Winters from visiting for a couple weeks. He had not seen any other posts about the feature's status until he rounded that corner Oct. 30 and saw it in pieces.

Social media posts ranged from those who were thankful they were able to see the formations and immortalize them with photographs to those lamenting that they never had the chance. Condolences also were sprinkled in with debates about physics and the fragility of natural wonders. “Gravity. It’s not just a good idea … it’s the law,” one joked. These waypoints won't be forgotten For Winters and other Native Americans from the region, they’re more than just rock formations.

They have served as waypoints, guiding ancestors along trade routes for thousands of years, and as connecting threads in stories handed down through generations. “They are culturally relevant to our identity and our stories,” he said, adding that their legacies will be carried on through photographs, illustrations and in the stories people share about their time spent in this stretch of desert. He called on people to let the sites “rest.”

So no climbing on what remains, and certainly don't take any pieces home. It's far off the beaten path down a rutted, washboard dirt road. But it's worth it, said Alan Studt of Parma, Ohio, who made his first visit in 2019 and then again last April as part of a 50-day road trip. In looking back through his earlier photographs, he could see the formations were weathering. There were new holes forming in the throne and cracks along the wing's base, making it no surprise they would not last forever.

Studt spent hours exploring and photographing the hills and washes during this last trip. He described being drawn in each time he saw a new set of spires in the distance, marveling at the petrified wood along the way and the rainbow of colors in the soils. “It is really so magical to be out there,” he said.

Read the original article on independent.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The Independent reports weeks of heavy storms and flooding across the US Southwest that destroyed homes, washed out roads on the Navajo Nation and could cost hundreds of millions of dollars, officials estimate. It explains the rain only by tropical moisture funnelled into the region. It never tells the reader that warming makes heavy rainfall like this more frequent and more severe.

  1. Leaves out the climate link

    Serious

    “have watched rivers crest and floodwaters course through usually dry washes, destroying homes, further saturating the soil and eroding the landscape”

    Why this matters
    These words report flooding that destroyed homes across four states. The Independent says nothing anywhere about the warming that makes such rain heavier.
    The impression it gives
    A reader comes away thinking these floods are a run of bad weather with no link to a changing climate.
    The context
    Human-caused warming has made heavy rainfall more frequent and more intense. The article never says so, not even in one line.

    How we know

    • On the recordThat warming has made hot extremes, heavy rainfall, agricultural and ecological drought, fire weather and intense tropical cyclones more frequent or more severe.ipcc.ch (opens in a new tab)
    • Checked against the whole articleIt never uses the words “warming”.

    Show it in the article

    “more than 20 trillion gallons (75.7 trillion liters) of rain fell across the Four Corners states and Nevada during late October and early November as tropical moisture was funneled into the region”

    Why this matters
    These words give an enormous rainfall total and explain it only by tropical moisture being funnelled into the region.
    The impression it gives
    A reader takes the scale of the rain as a matter of weather patterns alone.
    The context
    A warmer atmosphere holds more moisture and loads the dice towards extreme downpours like this one. The article gives the record figure but leaves out that warming is making such rain more likely.

    How we know

    • On the recordThat warming has made hot extremes, heavy rainfall, agricultural and ecological drought, fire weather and intense tropical cyclones more frequent or more severe.ipcc.ch (opens in a new tab)
    • On the recordIt is unequivocal that human influence, chiefly the burning of fossil fuels, has warmed the atmosphere, ocean and land.ipcc.ch (opens in a new tab)

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    More than 20 trillion gallons of rain fell across the Four Corners states and Nevada as tropical moisture was funnelled into the region. Climate change is making heavy rainfall like this more frequent and more intense.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Independent

  1. 6 NovTurkey outlines plans for 'paradigm shift' in energy use ahead of climate summit3.0
  2. 6 NovUninsured and flooded out, a Colorado man worries if life will be normal again6.0
  3. 6 NovUN climate talks start in the year of disasters, energy price shocks and fast rising temperatures0.0
  4. 5 Nov65% of Labour voters want Government to approve Rosebank oil field – survey6.0
  5. 5 NovNew oil and gas drilling in North Sea set to be banned – what we know0.0

Everything we scored from The Independent