Al-Monitor, on Gaza, 22 October 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

UN expert urges Indonesia to reconsider involvement in Trump's Gaza board

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 finding

By Stanley Widianto and Gibran Naiyyar Peshimam JAKARTA, Oct 22 (Reuters) - Indonesia should reconsider its involvement in US President Donald Trump's Gaza peace plan because it is being shaped by Israel and the US and lacks a Palestinian voice, the United Nations special rapporteur on human rights in the occupied Palestinian territories told Reuters on Thursday. The "Board of Peace," of which Indonesia is a key troop-contributing ​member, was unveiled by Trump in January to address global conflicts ​typically handled by the United Nations.

The world's largest Muslim-majority nation has also pledged troops to be deployed to Gaza as part of an international stabilisation force. Francesca Albanese, a prominent human rights lawyer known for her vocal criticism of Israel, said in an interview in Jakarta that Indonesia has historically supported the Palestinian cause, but joining the board was dangerous. Indonesia's Foreign Ministry said on Thursday that Board of Peace discussions remained on hold, reiterating its earlier position.

Albanese has drawn the ire of a number of Western capitals. The US has imposed sanctions on her, and others, including her own native Italy, have called for herresignation. "I understand (Indonesia's) good intentions. I still think that it's very dangerous, because it risks to normalise a very abnormal mechanism," she said. Albanese said that, legally, Israel could not have a role in determining the future of Palestinians. Rights experts have criticised the board for not including a ​Palestinian representative even though it is meant to supervise the ​temporary governance of a Palestinian territory.

The Board of Peace did not immediately respond to a request for comment outside US business hours. Indonesia, which backs a two-state solution and has repeatedly condemned Israeli violence, has drawn criticism from domestic Muslim groups for agreeing to join the board, which also counts Israel as a member. PresidentPrabowo Subiantohas vowed to quit if it does not bring benefits to Palestinians, his office has previously said, adding thatjoining the board would allow Indonesia to push for cessation of violence.

Albanese said Indonesia risked compromising its close ties with Palestinians. "It's very risky to do so when the rules are set by Israel," she said. Albanese recommended Jakarta join the Hague Group of countries, which includes South Africa and Indonesia's neighbour Malaysia and seeks to upholdinternational law and processes, including in the International Criminal Court over Israel's actions. Trump's Gaza plan has stalled.A 2025 ceasefire secured the release of the remaining hostages held by Hamas and hundreds of Palestinian prisoners and detainees, but efforts to disarm Hamas and secure an Israeli withdrawal have faltered, while Israeli forces continue near-daily attacks in Gaza.

(Reporting by Stanley Widianto and Gibran Naiyyar Peshimam; Editing by Xevi Fontdegloria)

Read the original article on al-monitor.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

Al-Monitor runs a Reuters report on Francesca Albanese urging Indonesia to reconsider joining Trump's Board of Peace, and it names Israeli forces as the ones carrying out near-daily attacks in Gaza. It closes, though, by calling the UN Commission of Inquiry's finding of genocide an accusation that Israel denies, so Israel's denial has the last word.

  1. Hedges the documented record

    Serious

    “Israel's government has denied accusations, including by a UN commission and international and Israeli rights groups, that it is committing genocide against Palestinians in Gaza.”

    Why this matters
    The article files the UN commission's finding under "accusations" and builds the sentence around "Israel's government has denied". It is the article's last sentence, so Israel's denial has the last word.
    The impression it gives
    A reader comes away thinking the genocide is an open charge that Israel's denial answers, and not a documented finding.
    The context
    The UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry found on 16 September 2025 that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, and the ICJ has issued provisional measures in the genocide case. These are findings, not accusations awaiting a verdict.

    How we know

    • On the recordThe UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry found, on 16 September 2025, that Israel has committed genocide in the Gaza Strip.ohchr.org (opens in a new tab)
    • On the recordThe International Court of Justice has issued provisional measures in the genocide case against Israel; this is a documented finding, not an allegation awaiting a reporter's verdict.icj-cij.org (opens in a new tab)

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    A UN commission of inquiry found in September 2025 that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza, a finding Israel's government rejects.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Al-Monitor

  1. 22 OctIsraeli fire kills four people in Gaza, medics say6.0
  2. 22 OctIsraeli fire kills three people in Gaza, medics say6.0
  3. 20 OctIsraeli fire kills four people in Gaza, medics say6.0
  4. 19 OctIsrael to resume commercial shipments to Gaza after Hamas fee dispute3.0
  5. 19 OctWorld Food Programme cuts aid to 500,000 Palestinians in Gaza, cites funding shortages0.0

Everything we scored from Al-Monitor