Daily Mail, on Climate, 5 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

Finally, Swinney breaks with Sturgeon... and

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findings

John Swinney has confirmed that his government is opposed to Labour ’s ban on all new North Sea drilling as he finally confirmed a U-turn on its previous ‘presumption against’ new licences. The First Minister yesterday said he opposes the new law proposed by the UK Government which would prevent further drilling. His spokesman also confirmed that the SNP will seek to get the proposal removed from the Energy Independence Bill and if they fail to do so the party will vote against the legislation at Westminster.

Mr Swinney’s comments at First Minister’s Questions are the first official confirmation that the Scottish Government has formally moved away from the ‘presumption against’ all new licences introduced by Nicola Sturgeon , which was set out in a previous draft energy strategy. It comes after he last week repeatedly refused to say whether he supports the Rosebank development getting the go-ahead despite being asked the question on seven separate occasions.

Reform UK’s Scottish leader Lord Malcolm Offord pressed the First Minister on the issue of new drilling yesterday as he questioned why Mr Swinney’s SNP has ‘given up on Scotland’s oil’. He said that the proposed Bill bringing a statutory end to any new North Sea licences ‘is a seismic moment for the UK economy which sounds a death knell for Aberdeen’. The Jackdaw field was finally given the green light last month The First Minister said on Thursday that he opposes the new law proposed by the UK Government which would prevent further drilling Lord Offord, Reform's leader in Scotland, said he was 'delighted' to hear the First Minister had done another U-turn on his position on the North Sea Mr Swinney said he supports some measures in the Bill, but said: ‘We do not support the provisions of that Bill in relation to the position on the granting of new licences for the exploration of new oil and gas fields for the simple reason… that any particular applications need to be considered in relation to their impact on our carbon reduction targets, given the fact that we are going to be using oil and gas for some years to come.’

Lord Offord said: ‘I’m delighted to hear the First Minister do yet another U-turn on his position. So much for the presumption against new licences in oil and gas. Delighted to hear that.’ During later exchanges yesterday, Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay asked the First Minister whether he would tell Nationalist MPs to vote against Labour’s ban on new drilling. The First Minister failed to directly respond, saying only that Reform and the Conservatives have asked him the same questions and he has set out the government position.

Left out here: One side gets the space

The article quotes Reform UK and the Scottish Conservatives welcoming or pressing for more drilling. It leaves out that the Scottish Greens called Swinney's position a "shocking U-turn". A reader is left thinking the only response to the shift came from parties that want more drilling.

How we know

Following his exchanges, Mr Findlay said: ‘Andy Burnham’s attack on North Sea oil and gas will be catastrophic for Scottish jobs, energy security and Scotland’s economy. Swinney is culpable through his silence. ‘All he has to offer is increasingly shrill and desperate deflection. ‘My party will always back Scotland’s oil and gas industry.’ A spokesman for the First Minister later said: ‘We will seek to get those provisions removed from the Bill as it goes through parliament. ‘If those provisions are in the Bill when it goes to its final vote we can’t support the Bill.’

Read the original article on dailymail.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

The Daily Mail reports accurately that John Swinney opposes the UK government's proposed ban on new North Sea licences and that the SNP will try to remove it from the Energy Independence Bill. Its headline says he "backs drilling in the North Sea", which goes a little further than the body: there he says each application must be weighed against carbon reduction targets, and he would not say whether he supports Rosebank. The article also quotes only parties pressing for more drilling and leaves out the Scottish Greens' criticism of the shift.

  1. Headline goes beyond the article

    Minor

    “backs drilling in the North Sea”

    Why this matters
    The words "backs drilling in the North Sea" present Swinney as positively endorsing new drilling.
    The impression it gives
    A reader comes away believing the First Minister now supports new North Sea drilling outright.
    The context
    The body shows only that Swinney opposes a blanket ban on new licences. He says each application must be judged on its impact on carbon reduction targets, and he repeatedly refused to say whether he backs Rosebank. Other coverage reports the same conditional test, and Russell Findlay complained that Swinney refuses to back new drilling.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

  2. One side gets the space

    Minor

    What is missing

    The article quotes Reform UK and the Scottish Conservatives welcoming or pressing for more drilling. It leaves out that the Scottish Greens called Swinney's position a "shocking U-turn". A reader is left thinking the only response to the shift came from parties that want more drilling.

    How we know

    Show where it belongs

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Daily Mail

  1. 6 NovRotting algae blights Mick's beach bolthole on Mustique: ALISON BOSHOFF0.0
  2. 6 NovSuper El Niño could push CO2 levels to record highs in 2027 - with devastating consequences, Met Office warns0.0
  3. 5 NovLabour MP savages Burnham's 'hypocritical and pointless' ban on North Sea oil drilling6.0
  4. 5 NovSobbing dad, 34, FaceTimed wife and said: 'I don't know what to do,' as floodwaters surrounded his car moments before he drowned3.0
  5. 5 NovMonster storm sweeps toward East Coast with 120 million Americans in its path as flash floods swallow homes and force immediate evacuations6.0

Everything we scored from Daily Mail