Daily Star, on UK Politics, 1 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

Andy Burnham's Government cause '£49bn black hole in UK finances'

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findings

Kemi Badenoch has claimed that John Healey has left the UK facing that will demand significant tax hikes to plug. The Conservative party leader warned that Labour would need to raise taxes by £1,700 per household every year by the 2030/31 financial year to fund its unfunded spending commitments. Badenoch took particular aim at the Chancellor, accusing him of failing to explain how he would meet his defence spending target of three per cent of GDP, arguing there would be an £11bn shortfall in the 2030/31 tax year.

"Rather than setting out how we will find the funding...which the Chancellor once said he was certain Britain needed for our own security, we just had vague commitments," Badenoch wrote in The Telegraph. Beyond the Budget, Burnham has also pledged to establish a National Care Service, which economists predict could cost up to £18bn annually, as reported by City AM . The prime minister unveiled plans to tweak the triple lock from 2030, effectively creating a double lock, using the savings to bankroll the new service, though this is not expected to fully cover Burnham's ambitions.

Combined with plans for council housing, Badenoch has accused Healey of creating a "£49bn black hole at the heart of the public finances". Badenoch said: "Who's going to pay for it? The prime minister gave the game away on Friday when he said he would have written the 2024 manifesto differently. Let me translate that. He wishes he had more room to raise taxes even further." She went on to accuse prime minister Andy Burnham of failing to make "tough decisions in the national interest", instead "putting them off".

She said: "After 100 days in office, all Burnham has got is a plan to publish a plan at some point...either they'll have to do another Budget, perhaps before an early election, or families are in for a nasty shock." Badenoch also took aim at Labour's tax hikes, with Healey's predecessor raising taxes on homes, pensions and farms, while Healey himself pushed up taxes on savings, rental properties and banks. The Conservative leader linked Labour's tax rises to the party's inability to shake its "welfare addiction".

"The country is living well beyond its means, but Andy Burnham and John Healey are making it worse," Badenoch said. ", pretending that the same Labour MPs who blocked Keir Starmer's tiny welfare savings are going to allow spending cuts right before a general election ."

Read the original article on dailystar.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

The Daily Star calls Kemi Badenoch's estimate of a £49bn shortfall 'staggering' in its own narration, before the reader learns it is one politician's projection. The article is built almost entirely on Badenoch's attack and ends on her words. It carries no response from the government, the Treasury or Labour.

  1. Uses a loaded word

    Minor

    “a staggering £49bn black hole”

    Why this matters
    The Star adds "staggering" in its own narration to an opposition leader's disputed estimate.
    The impression it gives
    A reader is told how shocking the figure is before learning it is one politician's projection.
    The context
    The figure is Badenoch's estimate of a possible future shortfall. The article gives nothing from any independent source to support the weight "staggering" puts on it.

    Show it in the article

  2. One side gets the space

    Minor

    “This Government is kicking the can down the road to the end of Parliament”

    Why this matters
    The article closes on another Badenoch attack, after sixteen sentences built almost wholly on her claims and quotes.
    The impression it gives
    A reader comes away with only the opposition's account of the Budget and the government's plans, as if no answer exists.
    The context
    No Treasury, Downing Street or Labour response appears anywhere in the article, and no economist assesses the £49bn figure. The only outside source cited is City AM on care costs.

    How we know

    • Checked against the whole articleIt never uses the words “Treasury”.

    Show it in the article

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Daily Star

  1. 1 NovOver one million Brits face Universal Credit and PIP uncertainty after John Healey update6.0
  2. 1 NovAndy Burnham's government suffer major embarrassment as mega-wave of migrants cross channel6.0
  3. 31 OctLaura Kuenssberg claims she found MP 'waiting in bed with partner' who 'wanted threesome'3.0
  4. 31 OctBritain 'not prepared' for WW3 as army chief warns 'Russia is serious, we are not'6.0
  5. 31 OctAndy Burnham 'open' to calls for Britain to offer slavery apology but rules out reparations0.0

Everything we scored from Daily Star