The Independent, on West Bank, 27 October 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

MPs and MSP claim they were denied access to West Bank

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 finding

Become an Independent member to bookmark this article Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today. Join today Already a member? Log in Two MPs and an MSP have claimed they were detained for eight hours by Israeli authorities and denied access to the West Bank . Labour’s Clive Lewis and the SNP’s Lara Bird, along with Kate Nevens of the Scottish Greens, sought to access the territory on Monday as part of a delegation organised by political group Progressive International.

According to Progressive International, the group – which also included former MP Sam Tarry and Spanish Senator Josu Estarrona Elizondo – was stopped while making the crossing from Jordan and had planned to undertake “a programme of meetings with Palestinian academics, students and civil society organisations” as well as join the olive harvest following what it claims are “mounting attacks” against farmers in the territory. In a post on X, Mr Lewis said: “For more than eight hours, we were held, interrogated and made to feel as though we had done something wrong simply by attempting to enter.

“The simple truth is we had done nothing wrong. “We went to show our support for the Palestinian people and highlight the terrible injustice and violence being perpetrated against them. “We want to ensure that people back home do not look away from the reality of what is happening. “Ultimately, we went to show solidarity. But we left with an even greater determination to speak out. “We will not be silenced, and we will not look away. None of us should.”

While Ms Bird – who was elected earlier this year to the Arbroath and Broughty Ferry seat on Scotland’s east coast – posted: “I came to stand alongside Palestinians being attacked for harvesting olives on their own land. Instead, we were turned away, with no reason given. “More than ever, Palestinians are being subject to terror and violence by the IDF and illegal settlers. “Increased blockades, demolitions and unthinkable violence have become the norm for Palestinians in the West Bank.

“It is more important now than ever that we bear witness and show our solidarity.” Green MSP Ms Nevens added: “We had travelled to the West Bank to stand in solidarity with Palestinians facing escalating violence, and to join the olive harvesters. “We went to bear witness, to listen to Palestinian communities and to help shine a light on the abuses taking place.

“The Israeli forces didn’t want us to see the demolished homes, or the settlers inflicting so much misery or the day to day indignities that are so central to the occupation.” The Foreign Office and Israeli embassy has been contacted for comment.

Read the original article on independent.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The Independent reports the detention and refusal of two MPs and an MSP at the Jordan crossing and quotes them at length. It also inserts a suggestion, credited only to unnamed reports, that the MPs could have asked Israel for permission. It names no source and gives no reply from the MPs, which leans the story towards their own fault.

  1. Unsourced suggestion of fault

    Minor

    “Reports suggest the two MPs could have sought permission to access the West Bank from the Israeli Government.”

    Why this matters
    The outlet credits this to unnamed "reports" with no source, no detail and no response from the MPs. It places it straight after Bird says no reason was given.
    The impression it gives
    A reader concludes the MPs brought the refusal on themselves by failing to follow a proper process.
    The context
    The article names no source for this. The delegation says no reason was given. Neither the Israeli embassy nor the Foreign Office had commented, so nothing in the article supports the suggestion.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“we were turned away, with no reason given”
    • Elsewhere in the article“has been contacted for comment”

    Show it in the article

What it gets right

  • “detained for eight hours by Israeli authorities”

    It names who detained the delegation rather than leaving the actor out.

  • “The Foreign Office and Israeli embassy has been contacted for comment.”

    It tells the reader that neither government had yet answered, rather than filling the gap with an official line.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Independent

  1. 27 OctMPs 'detained by Israeli officials and refused entry to the West Bank'6.0
  2. 27 OctEd Miliband ‘deeply concerned’ after MPs detained by Israel and barred from entering West Bank3.0
  3. 24 OctIsrael imposes closures across a West Bank city after attacks, and other Mideast news7.3
  4. 23 OctBulletin world briefing: Israeli army braces for West Bank closure and tsunami alert in Italy6.0
  5. 23 OctNetanyahu says Israel will demolish homes after 'soldiers killed in West Bank attack'6.0

Everything we scored from The Independent