GB News's own earlier report gives the question Ms Reynolds was answering. Camilla Tominey put it to her that raising National Insurance on employers meant increasing tax on working people. This article leaves that exchange out. Without it, a reader takes her distinction as a general remark that employers do not work, rather than an answer about who pays which tax under the manifesto pledge.
GB News puts 'not working people' in quotation marks in its headline and standfirst and says the minister 'branded' employers. Its own body only quotes her using 'working people' and reports a distinction she drew between employers and employees. The article also leaves out the exact question Camilla Tominey put to her about National Insurance on employers, which GB News reported the day before.
Headline goes beyond the article
Minor
“minister who branded employers 'not working people'”
Why this matters
The headline puts 'not working people' in quotation marks and pairs it with the verb 'branded', presenting the phrase as Emma Reynolds's own words and a verdict on employers.
The impression it gives
That the minister said, in those words, that employers are not working people, and so that small business owners do not work.
The context
The body never quotes her saying this. In its own account she 'insisted there was a difference between employers and employees', and other coverage says she argued employers did not count because they were companies. That was an answer about which taxes fall on whom under Labour's manifesto pledge, not a claim that business owners do not work.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“insisted there was a difference between employers and employees”
“Labour minister who branded employers 'not working people'”
Why this matters
The standfirst repeats the quoted phrase directly above Paul Bowen's line that the minister 'insulted all small business owners across Britain'.
The impression it gives
That the insult Mr Bowen describes rests on words the minister actually spoke about business owners.
The context
The phrase is GB News's paraphrase in quotation marks. The minister's quoted words in the article concern targeted tax rises and income tax bands. None of her quoted words say that employers or business owners are not working people.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“we made a very conscious decision for the tax increases to be targeted and fair”
GB News's own earlier report gives the question Ms Reynolds was answering. Camilla Tominey put it to her that raising National Insurance on employers meant increasing tax on working people. This article leaves that exchange out. Without it, a reader takes her distinction as a general remark that employers do not work, rather than an answer about who pays which tax under the manifesto pledge.