Israel has almost wiped out Gaza’s ancient olive trees
Findings are available in the analysis below.2 findings
We do not republish articles from The Independent. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The article is mostly sourced: its tree, yield and access figures are attributed to the Ministry of Agriculture, the FAO or satellite data, and the Israeli army's justifications are named and quoted. Its worst passage is S10, where The Independent writes that the war has claimed the lives of 150 members of the Kashko family, with no killer named. A smaller passage puts the destruction in Abasan al-Kabira in the passive, although the army's role in destroying infrastructure there is given later in the article.
Writes the death out
Severe
“The war has claimed the lives of 150 members of the Kashko family”
Why this matters
Writes the death out. The phrase 'claimed the lives of' turns the killing of 150 people into a loss the war suffered, and the subject of the sentence is the war, not the forces that fired.
The impression it gives
That 150 members of the Kashko family died in a war as a general misfortune, with no act by anyone set against them.
The context
Gaza's Ministry of Health recorded the Israeli occupation as having killed 74,392 Palestinians (R8), and the UN Commission of Inquiry found that Israel has committed genocide in the Gaza Strip (R1). The death of these 150 people should be written as killing, in the same plain terms the article uses for the fires Israeli forces set (S44).
How we know
On the recordGaza's Ministry of Health recorded the Israeli occupation as having killed 74,392 Palestinians, a cumulative toll that NewsCord's reading of BBC coverage cites as of October 2026.newscord.org (opens in a new tab)
On the recordThe UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry found, on 16 September 2025, that Israel has committed genocide in the Gaza Strip.ohchr.org (opens in a new tab)
Elsewhere in the article“Israeli forces setting fire to fields”
Written straight
150 members of the Kashko family were killed in the war, and the report should say what it knows about who killed them.
Hides who did it
Minor
“have been destroyed”
Why this matters
The passive 'have been destroyed' removes the actor from the destruction of 93 per cent of the buildings and orchards in Abasan al-Kabira. The only source named for the 93 per cent is satellite images, which show damage but not who caused it.
The impression it gives
That the buildings and orchards in Abasan al-Kabira were destroyed by nothing in particular, as if by weather or time.
The context
In S74 the article itself says the Israeli army framed the destruction of this area as a security necessity, and that its forces had destroyed more than 100 pieces of infrastructure there. The destruction should be written with the army named as the party that carried it out.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“its forces had destroyed more than 100 pieces”