Green Party zionism vote sparks tensions at party conference

Findings are available in the analysis below.1 finding

Green Party leader Zack Polanski has been barred from entering Israel, in response to the party’s conference in Brighton voting to define Zionism as racism. On Sunday, the Green Party of England and Wales passed a motion that declared the Greens to be an “anti-Zionist party” and said that Zionism will be “treated as any other form of racism”. A total of 1,022 Green Party members voted in favour of the motion, with 813 voting against it.

Left out here: Leaves out who was behind it

The article never says that Greens for Palestine campaigned for the motion, and it never mentions Palestinians, Gaza or the occupation. A reader learns the motion's label but not who brought it or what it was about.

How we know

The Independent reported“the campaigners behind the motion, Greens for Palestine”Zack Polanski banned from Israel after Green Party ‘Zionism is racism’ policy (opens in a new tab)
On the recordA review of 15 reports on the Green Party's Zionism vote found opponents of the motion were given 5,632 words against 620 for supporters, 13 of the 15 quoted no Palestinian, and none of 22 headlines named Palestinians, Gaza or genocide.newscord.org (opens in a new tab)

It has highlighted a deep division within the party, as one of its deputy leaders backed it while the other opposed it, as did four of the party’s five MPs. Polanski, who is Jewish, wasn’t present for the vote. He had voiced concerns about the motion’s wording, but also recently said he was an “anti-Zionist”. Share on Facebook Share Share on Twitter Tweet Share on WhatsApp Send Send with Facebook Messenger Send Share via email Email Load more share options Topics Green Party , Politics , Rabbi , UK , Zack Polanski , Zionism

Read the original article on channel4.com

What we found (1)

Channel 4 News reports that Israel barred Green Party leader Zack Polanski after the party voted 1,022 to 813 to define Zionism as racism, and that the vote split the party's leadership and MPs. It quotes the motion's own words, gives the full vote count and does not adopt Israel's charge of antisemitism. Nothing in it misleads; its one gap is that it never names the campaigners behind the motion or the Palestinians it concerns.

Leaves out who was behind it
Minor
What is missing
The article never says that Greens for Palestine campaigned for the motion, and it never mentions Palestinians, Gaza or the occupation. A reader learns the motion's label but not who brought it or what it was about.
How we know
- The Independent reported“the campaigners behind the motion, Greens for Palestine”Zack Polanski banned from Israel after Green Party ‘Zionism is racism’ policy (opens in a new tab)
- On the recordA review of 15 reports on the Green Party's Zionism vote found opponents of the motion were given 5,632 words against 620 for supporters, 13 of the 15 quoted no Palestinian, and none of 22 headlines named Palestinians, Gaza or genocide.newscord.org (opens in a new tab)
Show where it belongs

What it gets right

“declared the Greens to be an “anti-Zionist party” and said that Zionism will be “treated as any other form of racism””
It reports the motion in its own quoted words rather than in the words of its critics.
“has been barred from entering Israel, in response to the party’s conference in Brighton voting to define Zionism as racism”
It states the ban as Israel's response to the vote without repeating Israel's antisemitism charge as the outlet's own description.

How other outlets reported it

The IndependentZack Polanski banned from Israel after Green Party ‘Zionism is racism’ policy (opens in a new tab)

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Channel 4 News

Everything we scored from Channel 4 News