UnHerd opinion piece, on UK Politics, 20 November 2026

7.3out of 10Serious

Why is Britain ?

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.3 findingsSee them marked on unherd.com

On Wednesday, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood vowed to release data on crimes committed by foreign nationals in the UK, albeit at an unspecified future date. This is a promising step, but there is still cause for concern. The Government has long been reluctant to publish these statistics, presumably due to concerns around “community cohesion”. Freedom of Information requests made by the Centre for Migration Control , aiming to acquire a breakdown of the number of convictions by nationality, have been stubbornly resisted by the Ministry of Justice.

In June, the Information Commissioner’s Office upheld a complaint from the CMC, rejecting official arguments that collating the relevant data would be disproportionately expensive. The Government is currently appealing the ICO’s decision. And, over the weekend, the MoJ dug its heels in yet again after further appeals, arguing: “On balance the interests of the data subjects to safeguard personal information outweigh the legitimate interest in this case.”

Why are officials so concerned? In other countries, such as Denmark, offender nationality statistics are routinely published . In the UK, though, the subject is consistently skirted by civil servants and the political establishment. I served in the Metropolitan Police’s central intelligence unit for three years. I left the Service shortly before the 2020s “Boriswave”, but have a working knowledge of foreign offending ratios. I, along with most police officers and intelligence staff, know full well that the answers to these questions broadly reflect what the average person might imagine: that different cultural groups, living under different socioeconomic conditions, are more likely to commit certain types of crime.

Could such data be misused by those with an agenda? Yes, fairly easily. Does that mean the data should be withheld? Certainly not. After all, in a mature democracy, shouldn’t public debate be informed by the available evidence? There are certainly difficulties in publishing such information. Police data is often incomplete, while nationality data is occasionally reliant on an offender’s say-so. Then there are statistical anomalies concerning crime recording.

For example, the MoJ figures turn on the number of people convicted of a crime, rather than those charged or found not guilty. Those figures could be even more alarming for the Government. Nonetheless, why shouldn’t the figures that are available be released, along with suitable caveats around accuracy? The excuse of cost is clearly a red herring. Police IT systems are notoriously inefficient, but any competent police analyst is capable of providing eye-wateringly detailed performance figures around any conceivable type of crime.

I remember that when a swathe of cashpoint robberies were committed by Slovakian criminals, the network was forensically dissected by colleagues from a regional organised crime unit. In many such cases, the material has already been collated. So what would the figures, should they be released, reveal? There are already clues. Successful FOI requests point to the disproportionality of foreign nationals in the prison population, for example highlighting the number of Albanians residing at His Majesty’s pleasure.

They also reveal that between 2021 and 2023. Statisticians will argue the salience of these figures, which is part of a wider problem inside the police and Civil Service mindset — one convinced the public simply isn’t sophisticated enough to understand the subtleties of data collection and collation. The public, though, have eyes. They read the news. They see the cash-only, money-laundering businesses on their high streets.

They aren’t surprised that . The most revealing statistic, perhaps, might be one never collected: how many politicians and senior civil servants take the British public for fools? Dominic Adler is a writer and former detective in the Metropolitan Police. He worked in counterterrorism, anticorruption and criminal intelligence, and now discusses policing on his Substack .

Read the original article on unherd.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (3)

This opinion column by a former Metropolitan Police detective says the public is not surprised that foreigners may be overrepresented in people trafficking, modern slavery and prostitution, but gives no prosecution figures by nationality for those offences. It presents a 15% share of sexual offences as showing disproportion without any population base to compare it with.

Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.

  1. Vilifies a community

    Serious

    “foreigners may be overrepresented in people trafficking, modern slavery and prostitution”

    Why this matters
    Tells the reader that foreigners may be overrepresented in trafficking, modern slavery and prostitution, and says the public is not surprised by this.
    The impression it gives
    That foreign nationals as a group are over-represented in serious exploitation crimes.
    The context
    The article gives no prosecutions figure for these offences broken down by nationality. The only offence figure it offers is the 15% for sexual offences in S31, which has no population base.

    How we know

    • Checked against the whole articleIt never uses the words “prosecutions”.

    Show it in the article

  2. Uses figures that mislead

    Serious

    “15% of sexual offences, including rape, were committed by foreign nationals”

    Why this matters
    Presents a share of sexual offences as proof of disproportion, right after S30 claims that FOI requests point to the disproportionality of foreign nationals.
    The impression it gives
    That foreign nationals commit a disproportionate share of sexual offences, including rape.
    The context
    A share of offences only shows disproportion when set against the group's share of the population. The article gives no population figure for foreign nationals, so the 15% cannot be read as disproportionate.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“point to the disproportionality of foreign nationals in the prison population”

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    The article offers shares and headcounts of foreign national offenders without giving the population figures needed to say whether they are over-represented.

  3. Headline goes beyond the article

    Minor

    “hiding migrant crime figures”

    Why this matters
    The headline states in the outlet's own voice that Britain is hiding migrant crime figures, with no attribution to the critics who make that charge.
    The impression it gives
    That the Government is deliberately concealing crime figures it already holds.
    The context
    The body reports that the Home Secretary vowed to release the data, that the ICO upheld a complaint, that the Government is appealing that ruling, and that the MoJ cited the personal information of data subjects as its reason.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“vowed to release data on crimes committed by foreign nationals”
    • Elsewhere in the article“the interests of the data subjects to safeguard personal information”

    Show it in the article

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from UnHerd

  1. 19 NovShabana Mahmood is in denial about two-tier policing0.0
  2. 18 NovLabour’s conversion therapy bill embraces the worst of trans activism0.0
  3. 18 NovMilburn has buried Starmerism0.0
  4. 17 NovReform UK’s security strategy is stuck in the past0.0
  5. 17 NovMilburn review won’t rescue Britain from its welfare trap0.0

Everything we scored from UnHerd