Arutz Sheva / Israel National News, on West Bank, 20 November 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

Young children, a doorless building and Shabbats in darkness: Efrat's life on a hilltop

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findingsSee them marked on israelnationalnews.com

Efrat Quinn, 23, a mother of two young children, lives with her family part-time at Or Binyamin, . In an interview with Dr. Chana Katan at the Arutz Sheva studio, she describes life on the isolated hilltop without proper water and electricity infrastructure, the challenges of raising children in difficult conditions, and the reasons she chose this particular location. Efrat and her husband, Yiftach, have known each other since childhood on the kibbutz where they grew up.

They married at 18, lived in Safed for a time and later returned to the kibbutz. She says they already knew then that they wanted to help establish new farms and settlement sites. They initially helped establish a site near Nahliel, where they lived for about a year and a half. Once it was established and more families had joined, Yiftach began looking for their next destination. That brought them to Or Binyamin, a new settlement site in Wadi Zarqa, between Neve Tzuf and Nahliel.

Efrat describes an area rich in springs, natural seeps and ancient caves. She says the settlers have so far located about seven or eight water sources and continue to discover more. According to Efrat, the presence in the area has also changed since the settlers arrived. She said , , and that many Jewish hikers now visit the area.

Life on the hilltop itself is far removed from ordinary living conditions. Seven teenage boys aged 16 to 18, most from the Talmonim bloc, stay in a single building that is neither rainproof nor insulated against heat and cold. When Efrat and Yiftach arrive with their children, the boys move into a tent to sleep, and the family uses a room in the building. Reaching the site is also difficult. The access road is mainly suitable for off-road vehicles, and Efrat estimates that making it more accessible would cost hundreds of thousands of shekels.

For now, there are far more urgent needs: waterproofing the building ahead of winter, additional sleeping quarters, winter gear, coats, shoes and heating equipment. Efrat said, "Electricity for heating would be a bonus", explaining that even basic water and electricity supplies are not yet properly arranged. Nevertheless, she speaks of these needs as part of the work required to maintain a presence at the site. The challenges become particularly complex on Shabbat, when the family arrives with both children.

Efrat says that before each Shabbat, she assesses whether conditions are suitable, whether the children are healthy and whether they can cope with the weather and the distance from other communities. There is no synagogue or regular prayer quorum at the site, nor are there neighbors available to help. Asked why she continues to live in such conditions, Efrat returns to her encounters with hikers. She describes older visitors arriving at the springs with their children and grandchildren, moved to return to places they knew in the past and eager to show the younger generation the landscapes of their childhood.

She said, "People in their forties and fifties talk about how much they have missed this place, and how moving it is to be able to return with their children and grandchildren and show them the places they grew up in".

Read the original article on israelnationalnews.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

This interview-style feature relays settler Efrat Quinn's account of life at Or Binyamin, and the article presents her account without other sources. The article never says the site is in the occupied West Bank, where the ICJ found Israel's settlements illegal, so readers get no legal context for the hilltop.

  1. Writes Palestinians out of their own story

    Serious

    “Arab families who had lived near the springs and used them gradually left”

    Why this matters
    The article never names these families as Palestinian. It calls them Arab families and puts their departure in the passive: gradually left.
    The impression it gives
    That Arab families who once used the springs quietly drifted away, and that nothing else about their leaving matters.
    The context
    The article gives only Efrat's account of why these families left. S12 ties the change in the area to the settlers' arrival, and record R8 says West Bank settlers operate armed and accompanied by the Israeli army.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“the presence in the area has also changed since the settlers arrived”
    • On the recordWest Bank settlers operate armed by the Israeli state and accompanied by the Israeli army.newscord.org (opens in a new tab)

    Show it in the article

    “she maintains without direct confrontation”

    Why this matters
    Repeats the settler's claim that the families left without direct confrontation, and carries it as the only account of how they left.
    The impression it gives
    That the families left without any coercion, because the settler says so.
    The context
    The claim is hers alone in the article. Record R8 says West Bank settlers operate armed and accompanied by the Israeli army, and the article never says the settlers are armed.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    According to settler Efrat Quinn, Arab families who had used the springs gradually left. Her account is the article's only account of their leaving, and the article does not test it against any other source.

  2. Leaves out what changes the picture

    Minor

    “a new settlement site in Wadi Zarqa in the Talmonim bloc”

    Why this matters
    The article never calls the land occupied or the settlement illegal. It presents the hilltop as a new settlement site in a named valley and bloc.
    The impression it gives
    That the hilltop is an ordinary new community, with no question over its legal status.
    The context
    The ICJ's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem illegal under international law (R2), and found Israel's occupation of the West Bank unlawful (R1). This is the frame the brief applies to a site like this one, and the article gives its reader none of it.

    How we know

    • On the recordThe International Court of Justice's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem illegal under international law.icj-cij.org (opens in a new tab)
    • On the recordThe International Court of Justice's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem unlawful.icj-cij.org (opens in a new tab)

    Show it in the article

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Arutz Sheva / Israel National News

  1. 20 NovNew city in Samaria: 60,000 homes for 200,000 residents6.0
  2. 19 NovJewish families move into homes near Jericho despite terrorist attack8.2
  3. 19 NovArik Ascherman fined ILS 60,000 for harassing family6.0
  4. 18 NovLeft-wing activists confront Jewish residents near Jericho8.7
  5. 18 NovProject to widen Route 505 in Samaria moves forward at cost of over NIS 500 million6.0

Everything we scored from Arutz Sheva / Israel National News