The Scotsman, on UK Politics, 26 October 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

as Swinney urged to allow public ownership

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.3 findings

after new figures revealed . The revelation of fewer bus journeys comes after First Minister John Swinney set out plans to bring Scotland’s bus network back under public control amid a backlash from some operators. Statistics show that passenger journeys for local bus services have fallen from 484 million in 2008-2009 to 334 million in 2024-2025.

This means there are approximately 410,000 fewer bus journeys made every day in Scotland than in 2009, when Scotland’s Climate Act was passed. Monday marks 40 years since Margaret Thatcher’s government began the privatisation and deregulation of buses in the UK. But campaigners believe the 31 per cent decline in bus passenger numbers should mean the Scottish government should instead pursue a strategy of public ownership. Climate pollution from transport has barely fallen since 1990, and it has been Scotland’s most polluting sector for more than a decade.

In the most recent climate statistics from 2024, pollution from transport increased and accounted for 28 per cent of Scotland’s total climate emissions. Last year, the SNP government scrapped its flagship pledge to cut care use in Scotland by 20 per cent by the end of the decade with then transport secretary, Fiona Hyslop, admitting it was “not realistic”. Friends of the Earth Scotland senior transport campaigner, Emily Donnelly, said: “Decades of fare hikes, and routes cut by private companies have literally driven away tens of millions of passenger journeys.

“It’s time to end Thatcher’s failed experiment of privatisation and put public transport back in public hands.” She added: “Franchising is a great move forward to set better routes, but the taxpayer will still be footing the very large bill. We need to address the question of ownership too and take private profit out of our lifeline public services. “Public ownership alongside franchising is fundamental to building a system that works for our communities, not returns for distant corporations and shareholders.”

The appeal comes as new research from the Centre for Local Economies (CLES) and commissioned by the Just Transition Partnership outlined recommendations, including for the Scottish government to establish a dedicated public ownership and delivery unit, fund a public bus transition programme and mandate public or not-for-profit delivery for heat networks. STUC general secretary. Roz Foyer, said that it was “the scandal of our age” that for decades, local authorities have not been able to take services under public ownership.

She added: ““The evidence from this report is clear: public ownership works. Whether it is Lothian Buses, council-run bus routes in the Borders and Highlands, or Aberdeen's municipal heat network, public enterprise is the best path to reduced emissions, good jobs, and community wealth.” Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn said: “We are investing almost £3 billion this year to support public transport and make our transport system available, affordable and accessible for all, with over 300 million free bus journeys made by children and young people across Scotland since the Scottish Government introduced free travel for under-22s.

“The £2 Bus Fare Cap is already helping people in the Highlands and Islands and across Strathclyde and we will extend those benefits to people in Aberdeen City and Aberdeenshire from April 2027, alongside delivering a nationwide fare cap by the end of this Parliament. “We will set out further detail on our bus Better Buses legislation in the coming months and will work with all stakeholders to ensure this benefits passengers."

Read the original article on scotsman.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (3)

The Scotsman opens by saying SNP ministers were accused of driving away tens of millions of bus journeys, but the only quote with those words blames fare hikes and route cuts by private companies. The article also calls 150 million fewer journeys 150 million fewer passengers and dates the fall from 2007, when its own figures start in 2008-09. Its headline ties the decline to the SNP's time in office, while the campaigners it quotes blame bus privatisation.

  1. Makes a false claim

    Serious

    “SNP ministers have been accused of having “driven away tens of millions” of public transport journeys”

    Why this matters
    The words "SNP ministers have been accused of having" attach the quoted phrase "driven away tens of millions" to an accusation against SNP ministers.
    The impression it gives
    A campaigner directly blamed SNP ministers for driving tens of millions of journeys off the buses.
    The context
    The only place the phrase appears is Emily Donnelly's quote in S10, which blames "fare hikes, and routes cut by private companies". In S11 she calls privatisation "Thatcher's failed experiment". No one in the article accuses SNP ministers of driving journeys away.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“routes cut by private companies have literally driven away tens of millions of passenger journeys”
    • Elsewhere in the article“end Thatcher’s failed experiment of privatisation”

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    Campaigners say decades of fare rises and route cuts by private bus companies have driven away tens of millions of journeys, as new figures show 150 million fewer bus journeys a year than in 2008-09.

  2. Uses figures that mislead

    Minor

    “150 million fewer bus passengers since 2007”

    Why this matters
    The phrase "150 million fewer bus passengers since 2007" counts the fall as passengers, not journeys, and dates it from 2007.
    The impression it gives
    150 million fewer people use buses, and the fall is measured from 2007, the year the SNP took office.
    The context
    The article's own statistics in S3 count passenger journeys, not passengers, and run from 2008-2009 to 2024-2025. The figure is 150 million fewer journeys a year, and the period does not start in 2007.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“passenger journeys for local bus services have fallen from 484 million in 2008-2009 to 334 million in 2024-2025”

    Show it in the article

  3. Headline goes beyond the article

    Minor

    “Bus passenger numbers plummet since SNP took power”

    Why this matters
    The headline ties the fall in bus use to the SNP's time in office, in the outlet's own voice.
    The impression it gives
    The article shows the decline is down to SNP government.
    The context
    The body gives figures from 2008-09, not from when the SNP took power. The campaigners quoted blame fare hikes, private route cuts and Thatcher-era deregulation, and nobody in the body attributes the fall to SNP rule.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“Margaret Thatcher’s government began the privatisation and deregulation of buses”
    • Elsewhere in the article“Decades of fare hikes, and routes cut by private companies”

    Show it in the article

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Scotsman

  1. 26 OctSNP ministers were warned oil and gas slump driving renewables investment out of Scotland3.0
  2. 26 OctMairi McAllan: Providing P1 children with free school bags will cost £2.7m0.0
  3. 26 OctLet's hope for a Budget which delivers real help - and no pasty tax please0.0
  4. 26 Oct‘Show intent’ to end homelessness by scrapping benefits cap, charities urge0.0
  5. 26 OctBudget 2026: What will be in John Healey’s first Budget as Chancellor0.0

Everything we scored from The Scotsman