Ynet News (English), on Gaza, 19 May 2026

3.7

out of 10, scored on 8 of 11 checks.

Trump sticks with the plan

Select an underlined passage to see the reasoning.

View all 7 checksSee them marked on ynetnews.com

In September 2025, Trump’s envoys presented Israel with the U.S. president’s plan to end the war in Gaza. Its first stage required the release of all living hostages and the return of the bodies of those killed. In the frantic discussions between the countries that followed, Israel made clear that its latest intelligence indicated that the head of Hamas’ military wing in Gaza, Izz al-Din Haddad, intended to evade full implementation of this fundamental condition. The American response was unequivocal: “We understand your assessment. It may certainly be justified. Our request of you is simple: Do not read intelligence reports in the coming days. Our intelligence is more reliable. It is ‘human intelligence.’ These are the leaders of the mediating countries, Egypt and Qatar, and they are convinced that Hamas will not torpedo the agreement.” Given Washington’s confidence, Israel agreed to put Hamas to the test. It was a welcome move. In October, all the living hostages were indeed released, and the last body was returned to Israel at the end of January 2026. President Trump’s 20-point plan for rebuilding the Gaza Strip gave Haddad and his fellow leaders of the murderous terrorist organization an unexpected lifeline. After thousands of Hamas terrorists had already been eliminated, including its most senior leaders — Ismail Haniyeh, Yahya and Mohammed Sinwar, Mohammed Deif, Salah Arouri and many others — the message was clear: Israel would not allow those responsible for the largest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust to escape its reach, however long it took. Then came Article 6 of Trump’s plan, which paved a surprising new escape route for the terrorists. It stated: “After all hostages are released, Hamas members who commit to peaceful coexistence and to decommission their weapons will be granted amnesty. Hamas members who wish to leave Gaza will be provided safe passage to receiving countries.” But Haddad decided to gamble everything. His willingness to give up the hostage card in exchange for the parallel release of hundreds of Palestinian murderers, the resumption of massive humanitarian aid and a halt to the fighting turned out to be a one-time show of flexibility. In the months since, it became clear not only to Israel but also to the United States that Hamas remained determined to preserve its jihadist identity. This time, even the authentic “human intelligence” Trump received from the mediating countries left no room for doubt: Hamas was not even considering transforming itself, as the PLO once did, into a political movement. Its leaders, headed by Haddad, were clinging to the areas still under their control — about half the Strip — and focusing on deepening their grip over the population and rebuilding the military capabilities and formations severely damaged during the war. Fortunately, Trump’s ambitious vision succeeded in freeing the hostages. But it was not enough to free 2 million Gazans from the chains of Hamas tyranny. Once again, it became clear that fanatics willing to sacrifice their own lives for the goal of destroying Israel have no intention of considering the fate of the millions of miserable people in the Gaza Strip. The fact that many countries, including Muslim and Arab states, enlisted to help implement the American initiative for rebuilding Gaza changed nothing. Hamas dragged out the talks meant to reach understandings on disarming the Strip, effectively casting doubt on the ability of the “Peace Council,” launched by President Trump with great fanfare, to implement its groundbreaking vision. Long overdue Haddad should have been made to answer for his crimes long before October 7. The attacks he led over decades of unrestrained terrorist activity reflected his violent, fanatical and brutal nature. He carried out diverse missions skillfully and earned the esteem of Hamas leaders. Over time, Haddad was brought into the innermost circle of secrecy and, as documents found during the war showed, was a full partner in preparing the massacre. After October 7, Haddad regularly kept several hostages near his hiding places to make it harder for the IDF to kill him, and that is how he survived nearly two years of fighting. His successful elimination delivers justice for generations of Israeli victims. Where do we go from here? Trump’s “Gaza peace plan” is very dear to him. He believes its implementation will change the fate of this battered and tormented region for the better. Hamas’ veto challenges him, but does not diminish his determination to bring his vision to life. This is how his approval of the deadly Israeli strike on the hideout of Hamas Gaza’s No. 1 leader should be understood, even though the ceasefire Trump moved heaven and earth to advance remains in effect. It is an unequivocal American statement: We will continue implementing the 20-point plan, but we will change the order of operations. Since the plan’s central anchor, the disarmament of Hamas, cannot now be carried out, Gaza’s initial reconstruction will begin in areas under IDF control. This will be “the new Gaza.” Large areas will be cleared of ruins and infrastructure will be built for Gazans who move to live there, free from the terror of Hamas’ brutal regime. Israel will be given a free hand to renew its military activity in the territory still controlled by the terrorist organization, in coordination with the United States. In the first stage, intensified strikes against Hamas will likely be carried out from the air. Later, as IDF resources are shifted away from the Iran and Lebanon fronts, ground operations may also become possible. Of course, the way the confrontation with Iran ends will also affect Hamas’ ability to withstand pressure, though question marks remain over the steps the U.S. president will take. Still, the experience accumulated over long years of fighting requires avoiding overestimating the significance of eliminating Haddad. Over decades in which its senior figures were targeted, Hamas has proven its resilience. Preselected successors immediately stepped into the shoes of commanders and leaders who were eliminated, and the same happened during the Swords of Iron war. The conclusion is not to avoid eliminating mass murderers and their operatives, but to internalize that this action alone does not guarantee victory in the campaign. First published: 09:01, 05.19.26

Read the original article on ynetnews.com (opens in a new tab)
Watchdog assessment and method

The headline editorialises, the dead are labelled, the other side is not, and the ceasefire blame is one-sided.

The double standard

The article applies named, morally charged, unqualified description to Palestinian deaths and actors while Israeli deaths and Israeli military actions are framed in terms of justice, victims, and legitimate elimination, with no equivalent moral scrutiny applied to Israeli conduct.

How it builds, in Haddad elimination and hostage release passage

  1. Israeli dead named as bodies returned to Israel

    all the living hostages were indeed released, and the last body was returned to Israel at the end of January 2026

    Israeli dead are individualised and their return is treated as a moral resolution

  2. Palestinian dead labelled terrorists, no count given

    After thousands of Hamas terrorists had already been eliminated, including its most senior leaders

    Palestinian dead are counted only as a category of terrorists eliminated, with no individualisation

  3. Palestinian killing framed as justice for Israelis

    His successful elimination delivers justice for generations of Israeli victims.

    The killing of a Palestinian is assessed solely by its benefit to Israeli victims, with no independent moral weight

  4. Israeli military action described as coordinated, not scrutinised

    Israel will be given a free hand to renew its military activity in the territory still controlled by the terrorist organization, in coordination with the United States.

    Israeli military operations are described in neutral procedural terms with no moral qualification

  5. Hamas labelled murderous; no equivalent label for Israel

    the murderous terrorist organization

    Hamas receives a standing moral epithet; Israeli forces receive none despite ongoing military operations

  6. Palestinian leaders called fanatics; Israeli leaders not scrutinised

    fanatics willing to sacrifice their own lives for the goal of destroying Israel have no intention of considering the fate of the millions of miserable people in the Gaza Strip

    Palestinian leadership is characterised by psychological and moral defect; Israeli leadership is not subjected to equivalent characterisation

The same decision, both sides

Moral labelling of the dead

Israeli dead are described as victims whose bodies are returned, framing their deaths as a wrong requiring resolution.

the last body was returned to Israel at the end of January 2026

Palestinian dead are described as terrorists who were eliminated, framing their deaths as achievements.

thousands of Hamas terrorists had already been eliminated, including its most senior leaders

Attribution of civilian suffering

Israeli civilian suffering is attributed to named Palestinian perpetrators and described as a massacre and the largest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust.

those responsible for the largest massacre of Jews since the Holocaust

Palestinian civilian suffering is attributed solely to Hamas tyranny, with no attribution to Israeli military operations that killed and displaced those same civilians.

it was not enough to free 2 million Gazans from the chains of Hamas tyranny

Moral qualification of military killing

The killing of a Palestinian leader is described as delivering justice, with no qualification or scrutiny.

His successful elimination delivers justice for generations of Israeli victims.

Israeli military operations are described in neutral, procedural language as a free hand granted in coordination with the United States.

Israel will be given a free hand to renew its military activity in the territory still controlled by the terrorist organization, in coordination with the United States.

What a reader is left with. A reader is left believing that Palestinian deaths are achievements of justice, Palestinian civilian suffering is caused solely by Hamas, and Israeli military conduct requires no moral scrutiny, while Israeli deaths are wrongs demanding resolution and their perpetrators are defined by murderous fanaticism.

How the Watchdog checks articles

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from Ynet News (English)

  1. 26 Oct'It's costing us a lot of money to drop bombs on Gaza': US Senate ad blasts Israel aid0.0
  2. 25 OctIsrael names former chief military prosecutor to lead October 7 massacre trials6.0
  3. 25 OctIDF kills two terrorists who funneled millions from Iran and Turkey to Hamas9.1
  4. 25 OctALL CAPS: 'College is too late' – JNF-USA chief on Jewish pride ...0.0
  5. 3 OctIsrael targets senior Hamas official seen as Yahya Sinwar’s successor in Gaza City strike9.4

Everything we scored from Ynet News (English)