We do not republish articles from The Guardian. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The article reports a Republican bill that would shield fossil fuel companies from climate lawsuits, drawing mainly on opponents' quotes and the sponsors' own statements, with sourced facts about the lawsuits and state laws. One sentence states the lawsuits' deception allegation in the outlet's own voice, and the headline loosely calls two named advocacy staff 'experts'.
States one side's claim as fact
Serious
“increasing evidence that the companies deceived the public about their own internal science”
Why this matters
The sentence states the deception allegation in the outlet's own voice as an accepted finding.
The impression it gives
Oil companies have been shown to have deceived the public about climate science.
The context
The lawsuits described in S11 are claims against the companies, so deception is an allegation the cases seek to prove, and the sentence presents it as already established.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“have filed lawsuits against big oil companies to hold them accountable”
Written straight
The lawsuits allege that the companies deceived the public about their own internal science, and the article should attribute that allegation to the plaintiffs.
Headline goes beyond the article
Minor
“warn experts”
Why this matters
The words 'warn experts' in the headline present the two quoted speakers as independent experts.
The impression it gives
Independent specialists have examined the bill and judged it dangerous.
The context
The two people quoted against the bill are introduced only by organisation and job title: a political director for the Center for Climate Integrity and a program director at the Union of Concerned Scientists. Both speak against the bill.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“political director for the Center for Climate Integrity”
Elsewhere in the article“program director for fossil fuel accountability at the Union of Concerned Scientists”