The Independent, on UK Politics, 7 November 2026

3.0out of 10Minor

D-Day veteran dies aged 100 just days before Remembrance Sunday

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.1 finding

Become an Independent member to bookmark this article Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Start your Independent Membership today. Join today Already a member? Log in Charlie Horne, one of Scotland ’s last surviving D-Day veterans, has died aged 100. Aged just 18, Mr Horne served on a small wooden minesweeper which came under fire on June 6, 1944. Mr Horne, who was from Prestonpans in East Lothian , said the scenes of devastation he saw as the Allied forces landed in France stayed with him for the rest of his life.

Mr Horne died on November 3 at Erskine Veterans Charity’s Edinburgh Home, where he had been living since the summer. His death came just a week before Remembrance Sunday . Mr Horne, who returned home to marry his sweetheart Jenny after the war and continue life as a seafarer, recently reflected on his wartime experience ahead of Remembrance Sunday. He said: “I will never forget what I saw. I don’t think you could live through something like that and ever really leave it behind, no matter how many years pass.

“I was only 18 and there were ships being blown apart, men in the water and shells coming towards us from the shore.” open image in gallery Charlie Horne ( East Lothian Lieutenancy ) He continued: “There were mines underneath us and you knew that one explosion in the wrong place could be the end of you and everyone around you. “You were frightened, of course you were, but there wasn’t time to sit and think about it. “We had a job to do, the men beside you were relying on you, and you were relying on them, so you carried on.”

He said: “I’ve had another 82 years. I came home, fell in love, got married, had children and watched my family grow – thousands of young men never had the opportunity to experience any of those things, and that is tragic.” He continued: “I will never forget the men who didn’t come home. “All I ask is that, when we are no longer here to tell you ourselves, you don’t forget them either.” open image in gallery His death took place just a week before Remembrance Sunday ( AFP via Getty ) Born into a fishing family, Mr Horne was already an experienced seaman by the time he served on minesweeper MMS 291, part of the Royal Naval Patrol Service.

He kept a handwritten diary of his experience, describing bombs, shells and flares lighting up the sky. German guns fired upon the minesweeping vessels as they sought to clear the sea for the approaching invasion force. In his diary, Mr Horne recorded seeing “lots of wreckage” and dead servicemen in the water, while bullets fired from the shore landed within around 50 feet of his vessel. His vessel destroyed a total of eight mines after leaving Plymouth, but the danger did not stop after D-Day.

His diary also recalls how another minesweeper, MM299, struck a mine and its explosion “blew her bows clean off”. The young sailor eventually gave up trying to count the ships which had been lost, seeing the waters strewn with wreckage. His service during the Normandy landings was later recognised with the Legion d’honneur, France’s highest order of merit. He and Jenny, who died in 2009, went on to have three daughters. Wing Commander Ian Cumming, chief executive of Erskine Veterans Charity, said: “We are deeply saddened by Charlie’s passing, and our thoughts are with his family, friends and everyone who knew and loved him.

“His passing is particularly poignant as we approach Remembrance. “We are losing the last of a generation who experienced the Second World War firsthand, and with each passing, another irreplaceable connection to that period of our history is lost. “It was a privilege to care for Charlie in the final months of his life.”

Read the original article on independent.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
What we found (1)

The Independent reports the death of Charlie Horne, one of Scotland's last D-Day veterans, aged 100. It quotes his own memories and a tribute from the charity that cared for him, and names who fired on his ship. The only flaw is a slip that credits his words to an unexplained "Mr Young". Nothing in the article misleads.

  1. Credits a quote to the wrong name

    Minor

    “Mr Young spoke of the importance of remembering those who never returned from the war.”

    Why this matters
    The words "Mr Young" credit the closing reflections to a man the article never introduces. Every other passage is about Mr Horne.
    The impression it gives
    A reader may think a second veteran or speaker is quoted in the passage that follows.
    The context
    The surrounding passage is plainly Mr Horne's own account. The article names him throughout, for example "Mr Horne, who was from Prestonpans". The name looks like a slip, and it blurs who is speaking.

    How we know

    • Elsewhere in the article“Mr Horne, who was from Prestonpans in East Lothian”
    • Elsewhere in the article“recently reflected on his wartime experience ahead of Remembrance Sunday”

    Show it in the article

What it gets right

  • “German guns fired upon the minesweeping vessels as they sought to clear the sea for the approaching invasion force.”

    It says plainly who fired on the minesweepers instead of leaving the attack without an actor.

  • “dead servicemen in the water”

    It names the dead directly from the veteran's diary rather than softening what he saw.

  • “said the scenes of devastation he saw as the Allied forces landed in France stayed with him for the rest of his life”

    It attributes the account to Mr Horne himself and lets him describe his own experience.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Independent

  1. 7 NovReform has lost more councillors in five months than any other party. They explain why0.0
  2. 7 NovKemi Badenoch denounces Trump's 'dirty' style of politics0.0
  3. 7 NovFears of rent rise disaster as majority of landlords plan to sell up 7.3
  4. 7 NovWhy can’t King Charles simply say sorry for slavery? 3.0
  5. 7 NovFarage has been dealt a devastating blow – the love affair with Trump is over0.0

Everything we scored from The Independent