The Scotsman opinion piece, on UK Politics, 4 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found

SNP's reaction to Labour's Budget just exposed how foolish they really are – Jackie Baillie

No framing issues found.

Politics is a theatrical line of work. It doesn’t matter where you are – a council chamber, the Scottish Parliament or the House of Commons – tradition and flair play a huge role. Take Budget day for example, one of the dramatic high points of the political year. For sheer theatre, it’s up there with the opening of parliament and it’s wonderful combination of ancient tradition and lively backbench commentary – originally from Dennis Skinner and now continued by our own Torcuil Crichton.

Crucially, however, Budget day is also a day of huge significance to our country. The decisions taken have a profound impact on our country and its economy. READ MORE: Kicking cans down the road is an improvement on scoring own goals Gordon Brown’s Budgets of the late 1990s and early 2000s slashed poverty, raised wages and supported small businesses. George Osborne’s Budgets during the coalition years took a sledgehammer to the welfare state and ushered in austerity.

And the less said about the Kwartang/Truss mini-Budget catastrophe the better. Political careers are made and broken by Budgets. One minute you are at the helm of the UK’s economy, the next you have been outlasted by a burger topping. So it was no surprise that the SNP, Tories and Reform had all laid the groundwork to attack John Healey’s first Budget. Unfortunately for them, the reality was quite different. It was forward thinking, responsible, progressive and rooted in Labour values.

READ MORE: Why Labour Budget will be met with a shrug by rural Scotland The Chancellor promised breathing space and that is what he delivered. He abolished standing charges on energy bills – putting cash into family pockets. He delivered £100 of cost-of-living support for homes in council bands A-D, which will benefit millions in Scotland if the SNP follow suit. Mr Healey followed Michael Marra’s suggestion and raised taxes on our big banks to ease the pressure on working people.

We came to the rescue of the banks during the financial crash, and it is right that they should come to the aid of people struggling with the cost of living today. And he committed to re-industrialising the UK to face the threats of a dangerous world. This could be a gamechanger for Scotland. READ MORE: UK Budget 2026: Households in Scotland to benefit from £100 energy payment But it seemed the SNP had failed to read the Budget or listen to the Chancellor.

They had no welcome for the additional £18 billion for Scotland since Labour took office. Instead they reacted with the same lines they had been using before the Budget – despite the fact that they no longer made any sense. Betrayal! Cried John Swinney and Stephen Flynn, claiming that funding for the Acorn project was being scrapped. Only it wasn’t. I wonder why Mr Flynn would be happy for Mr Swinney to make a fool of himself in public?

READ MORE: Another general election! Why Labour is preparing to go to the polls early Not to be outdone, Mr Flynn was quick to post a video attacking the Chancellor for failing ‘Scottland’ – wherever that is. It’s a funny kind of nationalist who can’t spell the name of their own country. However, the coup de grace came from the ever-enjoyable SNP Westminster leader Dave Doogan. He attacked the Chancellor savagely for scrapping the standing gas charge for households.

Only to be reminded that he called for that very same thing to happen just a short while ago. Oh dear. It seems there is no budgeting for foolishness. Jackie Baillie is MSP for Dumbarton, Scottish Labour’s deputy leader and her party’s spokesperson for health

Read the original article on scotsman.com (opens in a new tab)
About this analysis

This is a column by Scottish Labour's deputy leader. It praises John Healey's Budget and mocks SNP figures for their reactions to it. Its partisan argument and its ridicule of named politicians are opinion, not grave allegations, and nothing in the material shows its figures or claims to be false, so there are no findings.

Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.

What it gets right

  • “Jackie Baillie is MSP for Dumbarton, Scottish Labour’s deputy leader and her party’s spokesperson for health”

    The Scotsman tells the reader the columnist is a senior Labour politician. A reader can then weigh her praise of a Labour Budget and her attacks on the SNP as a party figure's argument.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Scotsman

  1. 4 NovReparations for slavery? Why Britain has already paid its dues in blood and treasure – Murdo Fraser0.0
  2. 4 NovPublic service reform will not ease delayed discharge, social workers warn0.0
  3. 3 NovReform UK to force MSPs to vote on burqa ban in Scotland3.0
  4. 3 NovScottish police officers call for more powers to tackle e-bikes after 1,000 seized this year0.0
  5. 3 NovAnother general election! Why Labour is preparing to go to the polls early – Brian Monteith0.0

Everything we scored from The Scotsman