The Scotsman opinion piece, on Climate, 8 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found

Help the countries who have done the least to cause the climate crisis but are suffering the most

No framing issues found.

“The earth is the Lord’s, and everything in it, the world, and all who live in it.” Psalm 24:1 Floods, hunger and pestilence aren’t just stories from the Old Testament. Today, climate change is making the world a living hell for those at the frontline of climactic events around the world – from the thousands who faced devastating floods in Nepal and Tibet to South Sudan where over half the population face extreme hunger as a result of failed crops and conflict.

Even here in Scotland, our beautiful Cairngorms were engulfed by fire this summer. As the Scottish Catholic International Aid Fund (SCIAF), our solidarity is driven by our faith and with those most impacted by climate change, now and for generations to come. An unprecedented El Niño event is happening this year and next and will make the situation far worse, but scientists say by making deep emissions cuts, we can bring the world back from the brink.

Our planet cannot take care of us if we fail to take care of it. This year’s COP climate conference takes place this week in Türkiye from Monday and Scotland will be represented by Gillian Martin MSP, our Cabinet Secretary for Climate Action. We urge the Scottish Government, as well as the UK Government, to be good global citizens and ensure that we don’t abandon those at the frontline of the climate crisis to greater disasters. That means we must cut our emissions .

And it means we have to help those countries who have done the least to cause the climate crisis but are suffering the most. Scotland is to be commended for having a Climate Justice Fund (CJF) that helps communities in countries like Rwanda, Malawi and Zambia. We’d like to see that CJF increase as the International Development Fund has done. This vital move helped pave the way for the establishment of the global Loss and Damage fund which was set up in October 2026, this Fund specially convened for an emergency meeting for the first time in response to the Nepal floods and agreed to give the country $20 million to support its response.

The climate emergency is costing millions of lives and burdening countries with more global debt. What the world needs now is visionary leadership, especially when there are some who seem intent on bullying the world. In 1987, the world stopped using chemicals that depleted the ozone layer. It is on course for healing almost completely by the middle of this century. History will also tell us that the UK Government’s decision to approve the Jackdaw gas field is wrong as it will lead to more emissions and send the wrong signal.

Neither will it cut bills or ensure security of supply. The Scottish Government’s welcome of the Jackdaw decision is deeply disappointing. As is the decision to approve the Peterhead gas-fired power station by the Scottish Government. The looming Rosebank oil field approval decision must be rejected. This field is twenty times the size of Jackdaw’s emissions and would be the equivalent of nearly 70 per cent of the UK’s entire annual emissions in 2025.

Addressing worries at home about jobs and bills demands action away from a reliance on fossil fuels. The future of our common home needs a fossil-free future. I ask that leaders think about the long-term impact of their actions and not to prioritise short term profits over the long-term flourishing of our planet.

Read the original article on scotsman.com (opens in a new tab)
About this analysis

An opinion piece by SCIAF urges the Scottish and UK governments to cut emissions, expand the Climate Justice Fund and reject the Rosebank oil field. Its factual claims about the floods in Nepal and Tibet, the role of emissions cuts and the effect of new gas fields on bills are consistent with the record and the coverage. Nothing in it misleads the reader on the grounds an opinion piece is judged by.

Opinion piece: read for false claims of fact and for fairness to the people it names, not for its opinions.

What it gets right

  • “scientists say by making deep emissions cuts, we can bring the world back from the brink”

    The piece states plainly that cutting emissions is what limits further harm, in line with the documented science, and attributes the specific finding to scientists.

  • “Neither will it cut bills or ensure security of supply”

    The piece rejects the claim that a new North Sea gas field will lower household bills, a policy claim the record does not support, rather than repeating it.

  • “from the thousands who faced devastating floods in Nepal and Tibet”

    The piece names the people hit by the floods and where, and ties their suffering to climate change, matching other reporting of catastrophic floods that wiped away whole villages.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The Scotsman

  1. 7 NovHow the tide is finally turning against climate absolutism about oil and renewables – John McLellan0.0
  2. 5 NovJohn Swinney confirms SNP U-turn on new North Sea oil and gas6.0
  3. 5 Nov'Absolutely horrified': SNP says it has no plans for a dedicated wildfire helicopter3.0
  4. 4 NovSNP putting 'thousands of jobs at risk' with failure to triple Scotland's onshore wind capacity6.0
  5. 3 NovSNP’s climate targets thrown into doubt over Acorn carbon capture ‘fairy tale’3.0

Everything we scored from The Scotsman