LBC, on UK Politics, 4 November 2026

0.0out of 10Nothing found

All trains in northern England 'clapped out' and need replacing, rail minister warns

No framing issues found.

All trains in the north of England are “clapped out” and need replacing, the rail minister has said. Lord Peter Hendy said replacing such trains would be one of the benefits passengers would see as a result of the Government’s rail reforms. The creation of Great British Railways (GBR), which will bring responsibility for tracks and trains under a single organisation for the first time since privatisation in the mid-1990s, will help get all parts of the rail network “on the same page”, the minister said as he spoke at the Railway Industry Association’s annual conference in central London.

Lord Hendy said the country’s railways have previously been operating in “silos” for years and there was a “culture of blame” within the industry. Asked how the changes will impact passengers, Lord Hendy told Wednesday’s event: “I think one of the things that the railway urgently needs to fix, rather than just putting it in a long wish list, you know, every train in the north of England’s clapped out. “We need to replace them all. Read more: Spain's transport minister says he won't resign over deadly rail disaster - insisting he has 'nothing to hide' Read more: Delay fears for East West Rail launch as staff to strike over door row “That’s a really serious investment choice and actually GBR and the Government will have to face it head on.

“I think looking at those things and understanding how that plays out over a number of years, looking at the present rolling stock park and how they might best be used is actually something that will affect customers. “There’s nothing more stupid than watching some trains halfway through their lives that have been parked in a field, when they’re put back into service miserably failing on a daily basis because the industry wasn’t coherent enough to send them from the place they weren’t needed anymore overnight to the next place that they were.

“You can’t believe how stupid that is. “The Great Western has been devastated in Devon and Cornwall by trains that have been sitting in the open air for three years. “They don’t work properly. We can do better at that.” Great Western Railway, which operates mainline services from the capital to the west of England, will be the next train operator to pass into public ownership in December. During the event, Lord Hendy was also asked about cyber security concerns within the British rail network.

He said: “Yes, of course we’re alive to it. “You look at the threats in the modern world and cyber security and invasion of people’s systems is a principal threat. “The Government has a sophisticated view across the whole piece about what needs to be done in cyber security. “The railway is very much part of that.” He added: “We are very much on it. “I don’t worry about it but I am concerned about it but I know that the Government, together with the principal actors, Network Rail and GBR, as it comes, will be very much alive to it.”

Great Western Railway (GWR) has been contacted for comment.

Read the original article on lbc.co.uk (opens in a new tab)
About this analysis

LBC reports the rail minister Lord Peter Hendy telling an industry conference that every train in the north of England is clapped out and needs replacing, and that Great British Railways will bring tracks and trains under one body. Every claim is attributed to the minister and backed by his own quoted words. Nothing in the article misleads its reader.

What it gets right

  • “rail minister warns”

    The headline keeps the attribution and puts the minister's own words, clapped out, in quotation marks, so a reader knows this is his claim and not LBC's finding.

  • “every train in the north of England’s clapped out”

    LBC prints the minister's exact words, so the reader can check that the headline and opening line match what he actually said.

  • “which will bring responsibility for tracks and trains under a single organisation for the first time since privatisation in the mid-1990s”

    LBC explains plainly what Great British Railways is, which gives the reader the context needed to follow the minister's remarks.

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from LBC

  1. 4 NovLouise Haigh refuses to rule out tax rises to pay for soaring £353bn welfare bill as she stands in for Burnham at PMQs0.0
  2. 4 NovAnti-migrant activist Danny Tommo to stand trial next year over alleged Dover migrant centre breach0.0
  3. 4 NovUK taxpayers will not pay penny more for PM's new approach to Commonwealth, Miliband insists0.0
  4. 4 NovBurnham refuses to commit to greater Commonwealth funding as PM dodges reparations questions3.0
  5. 3 NovShabana Mahmood U-turns on toughening immigration rules6.0

Everything we scored from LBC