LBC previews the Supreme Court appeal against the ban on Palestine Action. It sets out the arguments of Huda Ammori's counsel, the Home Office, Amnesty UK and Liberty, and the CST and JLC, and attributes each one clearly. Its one weakness is small: the CST and JLC's charge of violent antisemitism closes the arguments with no answer from Ms Ammori's side.
Gives a contested claim the last word
Minor
“lifting the proscription would “re-arm and revitalise a sinister and dangerous movement” and could serve as a “green light” for perpetrators of “violent antisemitism more broadly””
Why this matters
LBC closes the arguments on the CST and JLC submission that calls Palestine Action a "sinister and dangerous movement" tied to "violent antisemitism". It reports no response from Ms Ammori's counsel.
The impression it gives
A reader leaves with the antisemitism charge as the final unanswered word on what the group is.
The context
Earlier in the same article Ms Ammori's counsel says the group was banned only for property damage, with no suggestion that it advocated violence against people. LBC does not set that against the intervention, and it reports no reply to the charge that the group targeted Jewish people.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“with no suggestion that it advocated serious violence against the person”
Elsewhere in the article“to crack the nut of a direct-action protest group”
What it gets right
“the Supreme Court is preparing to be told”
The lead attributes the under 1% figure to a submission the court will hear, and the headline keeps that attribution with "court to hear".
“Expressing support for the group is an offence under the Terrorism Act after it was proscribed, with the court told more than 3,000 people have been arrested since the ban”
It tells the reader plainly what the ban criminalises and how many people have been arrested under it.
“Human rights groups Amnesty UK and Liberty said the courts have not provided any “real check” on the Government’s use of the proscription power”
It gives space to the civil liberties interveners, not only to the two parties and the CST and JLC.