The Sun's headline presents a £1.5 billion figure from Reform UK's own figures as a hidden cost of the deal that has been revealed, dropping the party attribution that the body gives. The body also credits the words 'all options are on the table' to Andy Burnham in one place, while its own text attributes them to Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband.
Headline goes beyond the article
Serious
“as hidden cost of Burnham’s Brexit ‘reset’ deal revealed”
Why this matters
The headline presents the £1.5 billion as a hidden cost of the deal, revealed as fact. The body credits that figure to Reform UK's own analysis.
The impression it gives
That the Burnham deal has been shown to leave the UK with £1.5 billion of unpaid fees.
The context
S11 says new figures from Reform UK suggest the sum, and S1 calls it new research. It is one party's estimate of a worst case, not a revealed cost.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“new figures from Reform UK suggest”
The headline could say that new figures from Reform UK suggest the deal could leave the UK with up to £1.5 billion in unpaid fees.
Uses figures that mislead
Minor
“they will end up owing £1.5 billion of debt owed to UK universities”
Why this matters
The sentence gives £1.5 billion as the worst-case debt, and no calculation is shown for it.
The impression it gives
That £1.5 billion is a sum worked out from the £6.2 billion owed by 172,000 students, so it can be relied on as a measure of unpaid fees.
The context
S15 gives £6.2 billion as the total the same students owe, and S11 calls the £1.5 billion unpaid student loans while the headline calls it unpaid fees. A reader cannot tell what the figure measures or how it was reached.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“owe a total of £6.2 billion”
Elsewhere in the article“£1.5 billion in unpaid student loans”
Checked against the whole articleIt never uses the words “calculation”.
Makes a false claim
Minor
“the PM has reignited the Brexit wars and said all options are on the table”
Why this matters
The sentence gives the words all options are on the table to the PM. The article's own text gives those words to Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband.
The impression it gives
That Andy Burnham himself said all options are on the table, including rejoining the EU.
The context
S32 says Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband told the BBC that all options will be on the table, and the S30 caption attributes the same phrase to Ed Miliband. The article's own material attributes the words to Miliband, not to Burnham.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband told the BBC that”