‘We are tired from all this suffering’: displaced families in Gaza brace for another winter of misery
Findings are available in the analysis below.2 findings
We do not republish articles from The Guardian. Our findings are below, each quoting the words it is about. Read the full article on the outlet's own site.
The Guardian describes winter conditions in Gaza in detail and quotes displaced people and aid officials, including a UN statement blaming Israeli restrictions on supplies. Its toll sentence says the Palestinian death toll 'has now reached 74,000', with no killing verb or actor, while the Israeli dead are 'killed 1,200' by Hamas. A smaller flaw is a farmland sentence that goes beyond the UN's figure.
Writes the death out
Serious
“has now reached 74,000, mostly civilians”
Why this matters
The Palestinian dead are written as a count that has now reached a number. The Israeli dead in the same sentence are 'killed 1,200' and attributed to Hamas, so the killing verb is used only for one side.
The impression it gives
That the Palestinian dead are a number that rose on its own, not people killed by a named force.
The context
Gaza's Ministry of Health recorded the Israeli occupation as having killed 74,392 Palestinians (R8), and the article's own S27 says Palestinians 'have been killed by Israel'. The toll is a count of killings by Israel, and this sentence should say so.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“have been killed by Israel”
On the recordGaza's Ministry of Health recorded the Israeli occupation as having killed 74,392 Palestinians, a cumulative toll that NewsCord's reading of BBC coverage cites as of October 2026.newscord.org (opens in a new tab)
Uses figures that mislead
Minor
“The rest is in the Israeli-occupied zone”
Why this matters
The sentence turns the UN's 3% figure for accessible, undamaged farmland into a claim that all the rest is under Israeli occupation.
The impression it gives
That 97% of Gaza's farming land sits under Israeli occupation.
The context
The UN measure in S50 counts land that is accessible and undamaged, not occupied land. S29 puts Israeli military control of Gaza at about 70%, so the share of farmland under occupation is not established by the article's own figures.
How we know
Elsewhere in the article“Israeli military forces control about 70% of Gaza”