Reuters reports the Australian sanctions largely in attributed terms, and S9 names the settlers as the people who shot dead a 72-year-old Palestinian woman, citing witnesses and Palestinian officials. In S10, however, the article presents the illegality of the settlements as what UN bodies and most countries deem, followed by 'a position Israel disputes'. A reader comes away thinking the settlements' legal status is an open question, when the International Court of Justice has already ruled on it.
Hedges the documented record
Serious
“UN bodies and most countries deem the settlements illegal, a position Israel disputes”
Why this matters
The words 'deem the settlements illegal, a position Israel disputes' frame the illegality of the settlements as one side's view, attributed to UN bodies and most countries, and set against Israel's dispute of it.
The impression it gives
The illegality of the settlements is a contested position on which the UN, most countries and Israel hold opposing views.
The context
The International Court of Justice's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem illegal under international law (R2). The article never names that ruling; the word Court appears nowhere in it.
How we know
On the recordThe International Court of Justice's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem illegal under international law.icj-cij.org (opens in a new tab)
Written straight
The International Court of Justice found in July 2024 that Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem are illegal under international law, and Israel disputes that finding.