Published

Ornate City Hall corridor with arched ceiling, hanging clock, a few people, Chicago City Hall

Financeupdated 27m ago3 min read

Archive photo · 18 October 2019

10 outlets compared

Chicago City Council Approves Independent Review After Ashlee Gabrysch CFO Resignation

ABC7 Chicago
“Some alderpersons stressed that the review was not an audit.”
WTTW News
“Chicago City Council voted 45-5 in a special meeting to give a leading alderperson the authority to hire an outside firm for an independent review of the city’s finances”
3 Local Western3 Other3 Western Mainstream1 Latin American

Photo: Kenneth C. Zirkel, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

Chicago City Council approved independent review of city finances after CFO Ashlee Gabrysch resignation Finance Committee Chair Ald. Pat Dowell to hire outside firm for the review

CFO Resignation Spurs Probe

Chicago City Council voted 45-5 to authorize an independent review of the city’s finances after the abrupt resignation of former Chief Financial Officer Ashlee Gabrysch, deepening a budget dispute between the Council and Mayor Brandon Johnson.

Finance Committee Chairwoman Ald. Pat Dowell received authority to hire an outside expert or firm to examine the city’s finances and review communications from the Johnson administration about what led to the CFO’s departure during a critical stage of the budget process.

Ald. Matt O’Shea said, "We have a clear lack of transparency, accountability and confidence in what's going on," as Budget Committee Chairman and 26th Ward Ald. Jason Ervin opposed the effort.

Ald. Brendan Reilly said the review would cover "review of emails, memos, conversations that were had, presentations that have been made," rather than being framed as an audit.

The dispute centered on competing assessments of structural balance, with Johnson saying his budget was 76% structurally sound and Gabrysch previously testifying it was 56% structurally sound because of borrowing.

Reporting for this sectionABC7 Chicago

CreditWatch and Competing Claims

Standard & Poor’s put Chicago on a credit watch amid uncertainty surrounding the budget, and Dowell later framed the Council’s vote as a response to the warning.

Dowell said, "Any further downgrade risks our ability to access the bond market at reasonable interest rates," while the mayor’s office said, "The administration welcomes an independent audit of the City's finances in accordance with professionally accepted standards for municipal finance."

Ald. Ray Lopez argued the Council needed an outside review, saying, "We need someone outside to come in and help us get the answers to the questions we have," as Ald. Matt O’Shea added, "We owe it to the taxpayers to lift up the hood and see what's going on."

CBS News reported that Johnson’s budget address said 76% of proposals to close the city’s $882 million budget shortfall were structural fixes, while Gabrysch told alders that only 56% were structural changes.

Matthew Brewer called Gabrysch’s claims "a serious allegation," and he said, "If a mayor is intentionally making material misstatements to an investor, that's unlawful," as Illinois Secretary of State Alexi Giannoulias said the review was "a fair request after seeing what happened over the last year."

Reporting for this sectionThe TRiiBECBS News

What the Review Must Find

The ordinance approved by City Council gives Dowell power to choose a professional firm to conduct an independent review that would look for whether anyone in the Johnson administration knowingly gave wrong financial information to investors, the City Council, or the public.

The review is set to determine whether any "material or intentional misstatements of the city's financial condition" were made in any "document, presentation, offering or financial reporting" within the prior three years.

The ordinance also contemplates timing pressure, with ProPublica and WTTW News reporting it was unclear whether an audit would be complete before the Dec. 29 deadline mandated by state law to pass a 2027 budget.

Crain’s Chicago Business described the vote as an independent investigation into the Johnson administration’s handling of city finances, escalating a bitter budget dispute sparked by Gabrysch’s abrupt resignation.

A professor at the University of Chicago Harris School of Public Policy, Justin Marlowe, said, "Investors don't like uncertainty, and this is creating a lot of uncertainty," as the review proceeds amid the Council’s effort to restore public trust in Chicago’s financial condition.

Reporting for this sectionProPublicaWTTW News