Gaza Genocide20 September, 20263 min read
Ed Sheeran Apologizes for Mistakes After Gaza Comments at Philadelphia Solo Concert
Ed Sheeran opened Philadelphia show addressing Gaza, calling the situation catastrophic and unjustifiable. He apologized for mistakes at the first concert since Macklemore's removal.
NBC News was read line by line by the Watchdog: 4.0. See the score →
Philadelphia apology and Gaza remarks
Ed Sheeran opened his solo concert in Philadelphia at Lincoln Financial Field by saying the situation in Gaza is "catastrophic and unjustifiable" and describing the October 7, 2023 Hamas-led attacks as "horrific." He told the crowd, "My heart has been broken by the scale of devastation and loss of civilians' lives, of children's lives," as he addressed the controversy that had engulfed his North America Loop Tour. Sheeran also apologized for his handling of the dispute, saying, "I've had to take and make difficult decisions, and I am making mistakes, and I'm so, so sorry," after supporting acts withdrew in solidarity with opener Macklemore.
The controversy began after Macklemore was dropped from the tour following pro-Palestinian comments onstage, and Sheeran said he was not responsible for the decision, blaming his promoters. In the same remarks, Sheeran said he wants his music and shows to be about unity and humanity, not politics, while he framed his comments as part of a debate about freedom of speech.
Protesters, fans, and the split
Outside the stadium before the show, about 50 pro-Palestinian demonstrators gathered, and protest organiser Adi Chattopadhyay said, "there is a right and wrong side of history and [Sheeran's] on the wrong one."
Hillary Steinberg, 34, of Philadelphia, said she got tickets a year ago but wound up getting a refund and attending the demonstration instead, telling the Associated Press, "I think all art is political, and all music is political, and so this choice".
Not all attendees agreed with the protesters, and Diane Savitz, a 53-year-old concertgoer from Stroudsburg, said, "A concert should be for people enjoying the music. Music should bring people together."
Sheeran’s remarks came after a week in which Macklemore was dropped following a Sept. 5 show in New Jersey where he exclaiming "Free Palestine," and after Sheeran said he had "spoke with the venues at length all week to try to build a bridge" before Macklemore was removed.
The dispute also triggered boycott calls, including a statement from the Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel urging a boycott of Ed Sheeran's entire world tour.
What the Gaza war means next
Sheeran’s Gaza comments and apology landed as the wider conflict remained central to the entertainment-industry debate, with the ABC reporting that the massive Israeli offensive in Gaza has killed more than 73,800 people, according to the Gaza Health Ministry. The same reporting said Gaza authorities stated that the latest Israeli fire had killed at least four people, including a 10-year-old girl, on Saturday. In his Philadelphia remarks, Sheeran said he was "deeply worried" about venues pre-approving content or performers, and he told the crowd that his concert was "still a place where everyone is welcome" even with opposing views.
The BBC reported that the row had seen ticket prices drop and sales decline for the remaining US leg of his Loop Tour, while Sheeran said he had returned to the stage because he was committed to his fans. As the controversy continued to shape his tour, the BBC noted that Sheeran’s remaining tour dates are scheduled with shows set throughout North and South America.