Published

Portrait of a smiling woman with an American flag in background

USAupdated 16m ago3 min read

Archive photo · 17 November 2022

17 outlets compared

Trump Administration Asks 9th Circuit To Declare Alaska Senate Lawsuit Moot After Mary Peltola Win

Newsweek
“The civil suit is collapsing, but the criminal investigation it traveled alongside remains open.”
The New York Times
“Thursday’s filings did not address the status of that inquiry, which prosecutors acknowledged might never yield criminal charges.”
9 Western Mainstream5 West Asian2 Other1 Western Alternative

Photo: Leah Herman, House Creative Services / US federal government, Public domain · Cropped for layout

This article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.

DOJ asks 9th Circuit to dismiss Alaska Senate lawsuit as moot after Peltola win Mary Peltola defeated Dan Sullivan, securing a Democratic Senate seat and expanding party's majority

DOJ backs off Alaska suit

The Trump administration moved Thursday to effectively drop its lawsuit seeking to block the certification of Democrat Mary Peltola’s victory in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race, and the Department of Justice asked the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to declare the case moot.

Justice Department attorneys urged the appeals court to “hold that this case is moot, vacate the underlying order, and remand for dismissal on that ground,” while the Alaska Supreme Court had already ruled that the second Sullivan’s candidacy was legal and could remain on the ballot.

The lawsuit centered on the presence on the ballot of a second candidate with the same name as the incumbent, Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan, and the administration argued before Election Day that Alaska should not certify a narrow Peltola win until an investigation could determine if voters were confused.

The Department of Justice later acknowledged in a new filing that “there no longer exists any means” of determining whether votes cast for Daniel J. Sullivan were meant for Senator Sullivan, and it asked the court to vacate the district court’s dismissal because the case had become moot.

Peltola responded to the filing by saying, “Now that the election is over and the voters sent a very clear message about the direction they want our state to go in, I’m eager to move forward and get to work on behalf of all Alaskans.”

Reporting for this sectionAP NewsDemocracy Docket

Court fight and ballot secrecy

U.S. District Court Judge Sharon Gleason had dismissed the DOJ’s bid to force Alaska to segregate ballots, and Gleason wrote that the court could not grant the United States the relief it sought because it would likely violate Alaskans’ right to a secret ballot.

The DOJ argued to the appeals court that the district court could have crafted protective measures to allow an investigation, and the filing said it “reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means” of examining whether votes were intended for the incumbent.

NBC News reported that the lawsuit followed President Donald Trump’s repeated claims that the inclusion of candidate Dan J. Sullivan on the ballot was a stunt to “defraud” voters, and the Justice Department asked the appeals court to toss the civil suit after Peltola won.

In a separate statement, Associate Attorney General Stanley E. Woodward wrote in the filing that the United States brought the lawsuit to ensure Alaska fulfilled its obligation to protect the integrity of its election, and he added that the government “therefore reluctantly acknowledges that there no longer exists any means” of examining whether votes cast for Dan J. Sullivan were intended for the incumbent.

The New York Times said the DOJ maintained it had merit but conceded it would be impossible to interrogate voters after ballots had been de-identified, and it quoted the DOJ’s “reluctantly” acknowledgment that “there no longer exists any means” to figure out whether voters meant to pick the incumbent.

Reporting for this sectionDemocracy DocketNBC News

What remains after surrender

The DOJ’s retreat left the underlying dispute over the Alaska Senate race effectively over for certification, but the criminal investigation into the candidacy of Daniel J. Sullivan Jr., the retired Petersburg schoolteacher, continued, and Attorney General Todd Blanche said it was still ongoing.

Newsweek reported that federal prosecutors were investigating whether Democrats recruited Sullivan Jr. to siphon votes from the incumbent, and it quoted Attorney General Todd Blanche’s statement that the investigation was continuing.

The New York Times reported that the Justice Department’s filings did not address the status of that inquiry, and it said prosecutors acknowledged it might never yield criminal charges.

The AP News account said the administration never explained how such an investigation could take place given the secrecy of the ballot, and it noted that Trump had demanded that Peltola be prosecuted over the scheme.

Peltola’s campaign and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee were represented by the Elias Law Group, and Marc Elias said the department was “targeting me and my law firm on Election Day,” while the DOJ’s civil case was being dropped as moot.

Reporting for this sectionNewsweekThe New York Times