The Jerusalem Post, on West Bank, 18 October 2026

The Jerusalem Post reports a settler attack on Washington Post photographer Heidi Levine almost entirely through Israeli and American officials' statements, and calls the attack an "altercation between extremist settlers and Palestinians" and "West Bank clashes" when the same day's coverage records masked settlers knocking Levine down and kicking her while assaulting olive harvesters. It drops the Palestinians wounded in the same assault, drops its own earlier line that the army did not intervene, never calls the West Bank occupied or the settlements illegal, and closes with President Herzog's claim that the attackers do not represent Israel, unchallenged by the 486 documented incidents of settler and soldier violence reported in three weeks.

Serious

out of 10

What we found

Softens settler violence
Serious
“was wounded on Friday during an altercation between extremist settlers and Palestinians in the West Bank”
What the words do
The words "altercation between extremist settlers and Palestinians" turn a one-sided assault into a two-sided scuffle, and "was wounded" removes the people who beat her from the sentence.
What a reader comes away believing
That Levine was caught in a mutual confrontation between two groups.
What is actually the case
Coverage of the same event records masked settlers knocking Levine to the ground and kicking her while attacking Palestinian villagers gathering for the olive harvest.
How we know
- Al-Monitor reported“masked settlers knocked her to the ground and repeatedly kicked her”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
- CNN reported“attacked her and a group of Palestinians during the annual olive harvest”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack on Palestinian olive harvest in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
Show it in the article
“an IDF report of the West Bank clashes”
What the words do
The phrase "West Bank clashes" labels the assault, in the paper's own voice, as a clash, borrowing the army's account of the day.
What a reader comes away believing
That two sides collided and police are examining a disturbance.
What is actually the case
The Foreign Press Association called the attackers "violent mobs", and Yesh Din documented 486 incidents of settler and soldier violence in under three weeks, including 234 tied to the harvest.
How we know
- CNN reported“stop making excuses and do its job of protecting civilians from these violent mobs”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack on Palestinian olive harvest in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
- Al-Monitor reported“it had documented 486 incidents of settler and soldier violence on the West Bank”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
Show it in the article
Written straight
Levine was beaten by masked Israeli settlers on Friday as they attacked Palestinian families harvesting olives near Abu Falah; police say they opened an investigation after an army report.
Gives a contested claim the last word
Serious
“The despicable behavior of the perpetrators of this attack does not represent the citizens or the values of the State of Israel.”
What the words do
The article closes on President Herzog's claim that the attackers are unrepresentative, with nothing set against it.
What a reader comes away believing
That this was an isolated act by outliers.
What is actually the case
Yesh Din documented 486 incidents of settler and soldier violence in the occupied West Bank between 27 September and 14 October, and settlers beat an AFP photojournalist ten days before this attack.
How we know
- Al-Monitor reported“The recent assaults are part of a surge in settler violence across the West Bank”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
- Elsewhere in the article“photojournalists in the West Bank by Israeli settlers”
Show it in the article
Written straight
Herzog said the attackers do not represent Israel's values. Israeli monitoring group Yesh Din documented 486 incidents of settler and soldier violence in the occupied West Bank between 27 September and 14 October, 234 of them linked to the olive harvest.
Writes Palestinians out of their own story
Serious
What is missing
The article never says that the settlers were attacking Palestinian olive harvesters, that at least 12 Palestinians were wounded in the same attacks, or that a Palestinian bystander was shot. A reader comes away believing a photographer was attacked on her own, rather than caught in an assault whose main victims were Palestinian farmers.
How we know
- Anadolu Agency (English) reported“at least 12 Palestinians wounded”Washington Post ‘outraged’ after its photographer attacked by Israeli occupiers in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
- Al-Monitor reported“Israeli settlers attacked Palestinian villagers gathering for the annual olive harvest”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
Show where it belongs
Leaves out what changes the picture
Serious
What is missing
The article does not say that Israeli soldiers were at the scene. Journalists present said the military provided cover with tear gas and machine guns and shot a Palestinian bystander, and the military itself said its forces acted to disperse the confrontation. Without this a reader believes the army had no involvement and that only civilians were responsible.
How we know
- Al-Monitor reported“provided cover, with tear gas and machine guns”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
- Anadolu Agency (English) reported“assaulted by the occupiers in the presence of Israeli troops”Washington Post ‘outraged’ after its photographer attacked by Israeli occupiers in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
Show where it belongs
Uses the occupation's words
Minor
“West Bank”
What the words do
The headline names the territory without the word occupied.
What a reader comes away believing
That the West Bank is ordinary territory where settlers live lawfully alongside Palestinians.
What is actually the case
The ICJ found in July 2024 that Israel's occupation of the West Bank is unlawful and its settlements illegal; other outlets covering this same attack wrote "occupied West Bank".
How we know
- On the recordThe International Court of Justice's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem unlawful.icj-cij.org (opens in a new tab)
- On the recordThe International Court of Justice's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem illegal under international law.icj-cij.org (opens in a new tab)
- Anadolu Agency (English) reported“in the occupied West Bank”UN calls for investigation into Israeli occupier attack on Washington Post photographer in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
Show it in the article
“photojournalists in the West Bank by Israeli settlers”
What the words do
In the body the paper repeatedly places settlers in "the West Bank" and never once says the land is occupied or the settlements illegal, in an article whose whole subject is settler violence there.
What a reader comes away believing
That the attackers are residents of a contested area, not settlers in territory the world's highest court has ruled illegally settled.
What is actually the case
The ICJ found Israel's settlements in the West Bank illegal under international law, and settlers there operate armed by the Israeli state and accompanied by the army.
How we know
- On the recordThe International Court of Justice's July 2024 advisory opinion found Israel's settlements in the West Bank and East Jerusalem illegal under international law.icj-cij.org (opens in a new tab)
- On the recordWest Bank settlers operate armed by the Israeli state and accompanied by the Israeli army.newscord.org (opens in a new tab)
Show it in the article
One side gets the space
Minor
“thanked US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee and President Isaac Herzog for their words of condemnation of the attack”
What the words do
The article is built from the statements of a US ambassador, Israel's president and the Post's chief executive; no Palestinian from the attacked village speaks anywhere in it.
What a reader comes away believing
That the people with something to say about this attack are officials in Washington and Jerusalem.
What is actually the case
Palestinian villagers at Abu Falah were the main target of the same assault, and Palestinian groups and figures spoke publicly about it on the day.
How we know
- CNN reported“launched an attack on the village of Abu Falah”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack on Palestinian olive harvest in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
- On the recordReporting on Israel's assault on Gaza and on the Greens' Zionism motion has given Israeli, pro-Israel and Israeli-government sources far more space than Palestinian voices, who are quoted least when the story concerns them.newscord.org (opens in a new tab)
Show it in the article
Leaves out what changes the picture
Minor
What is missing
The article does not mention that settlers beat AFP photojournalist Jaafar Ashtiyeh in Aqraba ten days earlier, or that Israeli authorities have long been criticised for failing to hold settlers accountable. Without this a reader takes the calls for an investigation as a reliable remedy.
How we know
- Al-Monitor reported“Israeli authorities have faced longstanding criticism for failing to hold settlers accountable”Washington Post journalist hospitalized after Israeli settler attack in West Bank (opens in a new tab)
Show where it belongs

Every underline is part of a finding. Press one to see why.

Washington Post CEO demands probe into settler attack on photographer in West Bank

The Washington Post CEO Jeff D'Onofrio on Saturday called for an investigation into the attack on one of the paper's photojournalists in the West Bank by Israeli settlers, and thanked US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee and President Isaac Herzog for their words of condemnation of the attack."We appreciate Ambassador Huckabee's call for a robust investigation and accountability following the violent and unwarranted attack on our colleague, photographer Heidi Levine, in the West Bank," D'Onofrio wrote in a statement shared on X."We are also grateful for the supportive words of President Herzog and the condemnation issued by Israeli political leaders and dozens of former security and defense officials," he added, and also called on Israeli authorities to "conduct a prompt, thorough, and transparent investigation, hold those responsible accountable, and reaffirm their commitment to protecting press freedom and the safety of journalists."https://t.co/eVCB5gVVtS— Washington Post Communications (@WashPostComms) October 17, 2026Levine, who is an Israel-based photographer for the Washington Post, was wounded on Friday during an altercation between extremist settlers and Palestinians in the West Bank.Footage seen by The Jerusalem Post appears to show Levine kneeling on a path in a press jacket and helmet, as colleagues run over to carry her to safety.Police launched an investigation into the incident after receiving an IDF report of the West Bank clashes, according to an Israel Police spokesperson.Huckabee calls for investigation, Herzog condemns attackHuckabee called for the investigation, arrest, and prosecution "to the fullest extent of the law" of the participants in the attack. "Attacking a female photographer is [a] despicable act of terror carried out by masked cowards. Dishonorable act of senseless violence," he said.President Herzog condemned the “shocking violence” and said he had called Levine to apologize.“I expressed my deepest sorrow to Heidi and apologized for what she went through. The despicable behavior of the perpetrators of this attack does not represent the citizens or the values of the State of Israel.”

Read the original article on jpost.com

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

What we found

Softens settler violence

Gives a contested claim the last word

Writes Palestinians out of their own story

Leaves out what changes the picture

Uses the occupation's words

One side gets the space

Leaves out what changes the picture

Washington Post CEO demands probe into settler attack on photographer in West Bank

How other outlets reported it

More from The Jerusalem Post