The New York Times opinion piece, on Climate, 6 October 2026

0.0

out of 10, scored on 3 of 11 checks. Few checks applied, so read it with that in mind.

Opinion | The Science That Has Oil Companies Running Scared

On Monday, the U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Suncor Energy, Inc. v. County Commissioners of Boulder County, a case that could give fossil fuel companies a get-out-of-jail-free card for the harms caused by climate change. That is not exactly how Kannon Shanmugam — who represents Suncor and Exxon Mobil, another petitioner in the case — framed the argument. He said that dozens of active lawsuits that use state tort law to sue fossil fuel companies for damages because of their role in causing climate change are superseded by federal law. “This case and others like it reflect an all-too-regrettable trend of trying to resolve political issues in court, rather than leaving them to the political branches where they belong,” Mr. Shanmugam argued. If the justices agree, the lawsuits filed in state courts will likely be dismissed. If that were to happen, it would not be a big surprise. The court has made any kind of regulatory structure or legal action on climate very difficult. Indeed, the Roberts court is the place where climate action goes to die. Right now, more than 20 civil lawsuits have been filed in state courts by municipalities that attempt to hold the industry responsible for climate damages. Two tribes have filed similar lawsuits. Eleven state attorneys general are pursuing consumer fraud and related claims against the industry. All in all, several cases are now in the discovery phase and moving toward trial. In addition, Vermont recently passed a climate superfund law that, if it survives court challenges, could force fossil fuel companies to pay an assessment for climate damages. In Washington State, the first wrongful death lawsuit against fossil fuel companies is moving forward. The plaintiff is asking the courts to hold the companies liable for the death of a 65-year-old woman, Juliana Leon, who died in her car during a 108-degree heat wave. Most of these lawsuits were not filed by tattooed, vegan anticapitalists, but by sober-minded public officials desperate for money to repair sea walls, fight more intense wildfires and prepare their cities for a hotter world. Many are motivated by a lesson that many of us learned when we were children: You break it, you fix it. Why shouldn’t that apply to fossil fuel companies whose products have ruptured the climate? The Supreme Court’s decision in Suncor v. Boulder, depending on how broadly it is written, could kill many, if not all, of these cases. If it does, it could save fossil fuel companies hundreds of billions of dollars in damages and punitive awards and help them avoid high-profile courtroom showdowns in which they are cast as greedy, deceptive planet wreckers. We are having trouble retrieving the article content. Please enable JavaScript in your browser settings. Thank you for your patience while we verify access. If you are in Reader mode please exit and log into your Times account, or subscribe for all of The Times. Thank you for your patience while we verify access. Already a subscriber? Log in . Want all of The Times? Subscribe .

Read the original article on nytimes.com (opens in a new tab)
Watchdog assessment and method

No findings.

Nothing in this article was flagged. The checks that applied all came back clean: False claim about the science, False claim about policy and Misleading headline.

How the Watchdog checks articles

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The New York Times

  1. 3 NovWhy Southwestern Floods Won’t Solve A Water Crisis0.0
  2. 2 Nov‘Devastating’ Damage as Hard Rains and Flash Floods Batter the Southwest0.0
  3. 2 NovWilliam Nordhaus Has Died. Nobelist Influenced Climate Policy.0.0
  4. 1 NovFlooding in Parts of Arizona and Colorado Prompts Evacuation Orders6.0
  5. 1 NovHonk if You Know Why Delhi’s Air Is So Bad0.0

Everything we scored from The New York Times

See how 16 outlets covered this story