CNN, on West Bank, 18 November 2026

6.0out of 10Serious

72-year-old Palestinian woman shot and killed by Israeli settlers near newly established outpost

Tap a highlight to see why it matters.2 findingsSee it marked on cnn.com

A 72-year-old Palestinian woman was shot and killed by Israeli settlers in front of her home in the occupied West Bank on Tuesday, according to Palestinian officials and eyewitnesses. Fadda Fuhaidat was shot in the head after midnight near the city of Jericho, where Israeli settlers took over eight Palestinian homes two weeks ago. Fuhaidat’s 19-year-old granddaughter, Nagham, told CNN the Israeli settlers have been harassing residents in the area since moving in.

The incident on Tuesday in the West Bank, which is territory where Israeli civilians are prohibited from entering. But how the shooting unfolded is in dispute and remains under Israeli police investigation, as well as a review from Israel Defense Forces (IDF) commanders. According to Nagham, a group of armed settlers came toward their neighborhood and began firing indiscriminately late Monday evening.

Six Palestinians were shot and injured, according to the Palestinian Health Ministry. Nagham said her mother called her husband, Arafat, and asked him to come help. Arafat sped over and hit the settlers’ car by accident, Nagham said. As Arafat stepped out of his car, he was shot in the leg and required medical attention, she said. When Fuhaidat heard gunshots, she ran into the street to see what was happening. A bullet struck her in the back of the head, Nagham said, killing her in front of her home.

According to an Israeli military official, a Palestinian car struck the vehicle with Israeli settlers, sparking an argument that quickly escalated. Several additional Israelis and Palestinians arrived at the scene, the official said. As Palestinians threw stones at the Israelis, the official said Israeli settlers fired shots at the Palestinians. One of the bullets from an Israeli settler killed Fuhaidat, the official said. Two weeks ago, dozens of Israeli settlers moved into homes in this area with the backing of the settler organization Nachala and the Binyamin Regional Council, which claimed the homes were purchased.

After settlers moved into the homes, the head of the Binyamin Regional Council Israel Ganz said, “We are dismantling the Oslo Accords through action, house by house, family by family.” The Oslo Accords, signed in 1993 between Israel and the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO), were designed to pave the way for the establishment of a Palestinian state and the realization of a two-state solution. The IDF said it took two Palestinians into custody after the incident — Arafat and his son, according to Nagham — accusing them of “the deliberate collision and attack on the Israelis.”

Left out here: Leaves out what changes the picture

Israeli soldiers stopped the ambulance taking a wounded man to a hospital in Ramallah and arrested him, according to the Guardian and Al-Monitor. Without this, a reader sees the arrests only as custody after the incident, not as soldiers stopping an ambulance on its way to hospital, and so believes settlers alone blocked ambulances.

How we know

No Israeli settlers were arrested, the Israeli military official said. Nagham said that settlers stayed in the area and blocked ambulances from reaching the injured. “It is a clear false claim … why did the army protect the settlers? They should get arrested, not us. We didn’t do anything wrong,” Nagham said.

Read the original article on cnn.com (opens in a new tab)
What we found (2)

CNN attributes the claim that Israeli settlers shot Fadda Fuhaidat to Palestinian officials and eyewitnesses, and gives the Israeli military account that a Palestinian car struck a settler vehicle. In its own voice, however, it states as fact that settlers illegally drove into Area A and began the incident, although its next sentence says how the shooting unfolded is in dispute.

  1. States one side's claim as fact

    Serious

    “began when settlers illegally drove into Area A”

    Why this matters
    States in the outlet's own voice, with no attribution, that settlers drove into Area A and that this started the incident. The words illegally and began when present one side's account as established.
    The impression it gives
    That settlers entering Area A started the incident, and that this is settled.
    The context
    The next sentence says how the shooting unfolded is in dispute. The Israeli military account in the article is that a Palestinian car struck a settler vehicle, and the BBC reports conflicting accounts of what happened.

    How we know

    Show it in the article

    Written straight

    How the incident began is disputed. Nagham says a group of armed settlers came toward the neighbourhood and began firing, while an Israeli military official says a Palestinian car struck a settler vehicle.

  2. Leaves out what changes the picture

    Minor

    What is missing

    Israeli soldiers stopped the ambulance taking a wounded man to a hospital in Ramallah and arrested him, according to the Guardian and Al-Monitor. Without this, a reader sees the arrests only as custody after the incident, not as soldiers stopping an ambulance on its way to hospital, and so believes settlers alone blocked ambulances.

    How we know

    Show where it belongs

How other outlets reported it

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from CNN

  1. 23 OctWashington Post journalist says attack by Israeli West Bank settlers has only ‘strengthened’ her resolve0.0
  2. 23 OctNetanyahu orders closure of West Bank after five Israelis wounded in shooting attack3.0
  3. 23 OctIsrael begins demolitions in West Bank city after two soldiers killed in shooting attack3.0
  4. 21 OctHow Israel under Netanyahu has reshaped the West Bank0.0
  5. 19 OctAmid US pressure on settler violence, Israel arrests at least 10 suspected of West Bank attacks on journalist, diplomats6.0

Everything we scored from CNN