Crime05 October, 20262 min read
Judge Nicholas Hilliard Says Police Unlawfully Searched Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor Homes
57outlets comparedA wider view of the story
23 Western Mainstream20 West Asian5 Other9 Other source typesThis article is an automated aggregation of coverage from news outlets. Our editorials offer in-depth analysis curated by the NewsCord team.
High Court rules Thames Valley Police warrants to search Mountbatten-Windsor properties were unlawful. Police acknowledged warrants were unlawfully issued and seized evidence may be excluded.
Save coverage image
Warrants Quashed, Case Continues
A London judge said police investigating Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor unlawfully searched his homes after agreeing that the search warrants were unlawful and must be quashed. Judge Nicholas Hilliard told the High Court that “the fact that the search warrants were quashed does not bring an investigation to an end, or mean that the whole of the investigation was unlawful.”
Thames Valley Police accepted that “the initial court's decision to issue warrants under the specific piece of legislation used was incorrect and therefore these must be legally quashed,” while insisting the criminal investigation into misconduct in public office remained ongoing. The judge said the issue of whether police could keep the seized property would not be settled until next year, with a further hearing expected in 2027.
How the Error Happened
Thames Valley Police said it applied for search warrants under section eight and nine of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, but the Central Criminal Court determined only section eight warrants were needed. The BBC reported that the judge explained why police could keep hold of the former prince's items, saying “there would be little point handing property back if it could then simply be lawfully seized under some other provision.”
The court heard that Thames Valley Police seized documents and electronic devices when it raided Mountbatten-Windsor's homes earlier this year. The judge said the warrants were unlawful because the issuing judge had not considered whether items being seized were subject to legal privilege or “special procedure material,” and the court heard that such protected material was not covered by the warrant.
Next Steps and Stakes
Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor opposed Thames Valley Police's bid to retain the seized material, and the judge said another hearing was expected in 2027 to decide whether the material could be used as evidence. The BBC said Mountbatten-Windsor opposes the police's bid to retain the evidence, and the judge said “another hearing is expected in 2027.”
Thames Valley Police said it accepted the warrants were legally quashed but said legal proceedings were ongoing to decide how material seized during the searches would be managed and whether it could lawfully be retained. The judge said the investigation into alleged misconduct in public office by a man in his 60s from Norfolk remains ongoing, while the court’s ruling left Mountbatten-Windsor’s legal challenge and the evidence-management fight continuing.