The New York Times, on Gaza, 21 September 2026

2.8

out of 10, scored on 6 of 11 checks.

Israel FA says Republic of Ireland coach has ‘stupidity, ignorance and hypocrisy’ after genocide comments

Select an underlined passage to see the reasoning.

View all 4 checks

The Israel football association says the Republic of Ireland head coach has displayed “stupidity, ignorance and hypocrisy” after Heimir Hallgrimsson said his team would be “playing against genocide” when the countries meet in the Nations League. The Republic of Ireland are set to face Israel twice over the international break, with the first game due to be played on September 27. Advertisement On the weekend Hallgrimsson said in a press conference that the team were “not playing with genocide, we are playing against genocide”. “So we’re playing against Israel. We’re not playing with Israel,” he added, per the Times. “Hopefully we can play good football. That’s my job here. I’m hired here to think about the football things and others on other things.” The Israel FA replied on social media to the head coach’s comments on Monday, saying “we’re not playing with ignorance, hypocrisy and stupidity, we’re playing against the coach who embodies them”. “We have contributed to the world and humanity in countless fields, earning an impressive number of Nobel Prizes along the way,” the statement read, tagging the official Republic of Ireland football team page. “Unfortunately, we have not yet found a cure for stupidity, ignorance and hypocrisy displayed by Ireland’s national team coach.” The Athletic has approached the Football Association of Ireland (FAI) for comment. Over 70,000 people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run health ministry, since the Hamas-led attack on Israel on October 7. About 1,200 people were killed in Israel during the attack, according to the Israeli authorities, who also said around 250 people were taken back to Gaza as hostages, in figures reported by the New York Times. A U.N. investigative body concluded in 2025 that Israel had committed genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, but Israeli officials deny that and say they have allowed humanitarian aid. The statement from the Israel FA is the latest development in the tensions surrounding the fixtures, with FAI chief executive David Courell saying on Friday a request to avoid the sides meeting in future had been rejected by UEFA. European football’s governing body defended their policy in a statement to The Athletic. Advertisement “Decisions to avoid certain teams being drawn against each other are made taking into consideration several factors, especially conditions between the two countries leading to structural risks for security,” a UEFA spokesperson said, adding it “handles every situation very carefully on its own merits and monitors all facts and developments”. Israel has not hosted UEFA matches since October 2023 due to security issues. Their designated ‘home’ game against the Republic of Ireland will take place in Debrecen, Hungary on September 27. The return fixture on October 4 has been moved away from Dublin to a behind-closed-doors venue in Serbia.

Read the original article on nytimes.com (opens in a new tab)
Watchdog assessment and method

The headline editorialises.

The double standard

Palestinian deaths in Gaza are attributed to a source the article labels as Hamas-run, while Israeli deaths are attributed to Israeli authorities with no equivalent qualifier, applying a stricter credibility standard to the Palestinian figure.

How it builds, in Casualty paragraph: Gaza figure vs Israel figure

  1. Source labelled by political affiliation: Hamas-run

    Over 70,000 people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run health ministry

    Source identified by its political character, implying partisan unreliability

  2. Source named neutrally: Israeli authorities

    About 1,200 people were killed in Israel during the attack, according to the Israeli authorities

    Source identified by institutional role only, no political qualifier

  3. Second-hand sourcing adds credibility layer for Israeli figures

    who also said around 250 people were taken back to Gaza as hostages, in figures reported by the New York Times

    Israeli authority figures further laundered through a named prestige outlet

  4. UN finding balanced against Israeli denial

    A U.N. investigative body concluded in 2025 that Israel had committed genocide against Palestinians in Gaza, but Israeli officials deny that and say they have allowed humanitarian aid.

    A documented UN conclusion is placed in immediate tension with an official denial, softening its standing

The same decision, both sides

Whether the source's political character is named in the attribution

The Gaza death toll source is labelled by its political identity, casting implicit doubt on the figure.

Over 70,000 people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run health ministry

The Israeli death toll source is described by institutional role alone, with no equivalent qualifier.

About 1,200 people were killed in Israel during the attack, according to the Israeli authorities

Whether a secondary prestige source is added to reinforce the figure

The Palestinian casualty figure receives no secondary source to bolster its credibility.

Over 70,000 people have been killed in Gaza, according to the Hamas-run health ministry

The Israeli casualty figure is additionally anchored to the New York Times, lending it extra authority.

in figures reported by the New York Times

What a reader is left with. A reader is left with the impression that the Palestinian death toll is a politically tainted figure requiring scepticism, while the Israeli death toll is a straightforwardly reliable one, even though both originate from the party with the strongest interest in the count.

How the Watchdog checks articles

Spot something we missed? Report this article

More from The New York Times

  1. 9 OctNavi Pillay, South African Jurist, Is Awarded the Nobel Peace Prize3.0
  2. 9 OctIsrael Denounces the Decision to Award the Nobel Peace Prize to Navi Pillay3.0
  3. 7 OctOn This Day, Oct. 7: In 2023, Hamas-led Militants Launched Surprise Attacks on Israel3.0
  4. 6 OctWhat Went Wrong in the Effort to Free the Oct. 7 Hostages?0.0
  5. 2 OctIsrael Lists 170 Killed in Gaza It Says Were Militants Posing as Media Workers3.0

Everything we scored from The New York Times