Published Updated

Narendra Modi Holds Talks With Vladimir Putin and Masoud Pezeshkian Ahead of BRICS Summit
Image: نورنیوز

Iran · updated 20m ago · 3 min read

Narendra Modi Holds Talks With Vladimir Putin and Masoud Pezeshkian Ahead of BRICS Summit

Happened

Modi met separately with Putin and Pezeshkian in New Delhi ahead of BRICS summit. Pezeshkian arrived in New Delhi for BRICS, to hold bilateral talks with Modi.

Split on

Whether BRICS expansion is a constraint.

Left out

10 of 11 outlets skipped it: a BRICS Pay system modelled on UPI is planned.

84outlets compared

ABCABC4 UtahAl JazeeraAl-Arabi Al-JadeedAl-Jazeera NetAnewZAP NewsCGTN

Same story, two versions

tap a side to read it in full

EuronewsEuronews

"What was seen until last year as an achievement -- the expansion of BRICS -- today looks like a big constraint on BRICS," Pant added.
Read the original

India TodayIndia Today

Prime Minister Narendra Modi addressed the BRICS Business Forum, highlighting the growth and resilience of the economic bloc as it marks 20 years.
Read the original
VS

Euronews highlights expansion as a constraint, while India Today stresses growth and resilience.

Modi meets Putin, Pezeshkian

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi held separate talks with Russian President Vladimir Putin and Iranian President Masoud Pezeshkian in New Delhi on Friday as the 11-member BRICS summit approached.

Modi thanked Pezeshkian for Iran’s high-level participation in BRICS

ABCABC

The AP report said Modi and Putin discussed cooperation in political, economic, defense, energy and other sectors, and it said the leaders exchanged views on regional and global issues including Middle East conflicts.

Image from ABC
ABCABC

Modi thanked Pezeshkian for Iran’s high-level participation in BRICS “despite the challenging circumstances,” a reference to the Iran war, the report said.

The Al Jazeera account said the Russian and Iranian presidents arrived in India ahead of an 11-member BRICS summit set to be dominated by wars in the Middle East and Ukraine, and it said Modi reiterated that conflicts should be resolved by dialogue and diplomacy.

Al Jazeera also said Modi met Iran’s President Masoud Pezeshkian and underscored the need to protect freedom of navigation and commerce, as well as the safety and well-being of ship’s crews.

US dominance and fault line

Ahead of the summit, Al Jazeera reported that the presidents of Iran and Russia criticised US dollar dominance ahead of the BRICS summit in India.

In the same Al Jazeera framing, the report said countering the US role in the global economy and the effects of its war on Iran were expected to lead the agenda as the 11-nation bloc met on September 12.

Image from ABC4 Utah
ABC4 UtahABC4 Utah

Euronews said Harsh V. EPant of India’s Observer Research Foundation expected the Gulf conflict to be the “central fault line this time during the BRICS summit,” and it quoted Pant saying “What was seen until last year as an achievement -- the expansion of BRICS -- today looks like a big constraint on BRICS.”

The Al Jazeera report also said the leaders shared perspectives on “the conflicts in West Asia and the Black Sea region, which have impacted maritime trade and the safety and security of Indian seafarers,” and it said Modi emphasised continued efforts to ensure lasting peace and stability in the region.

Euronews added that Modi wrote on social media that “With the virtuous, one may debate and share friendship; with the unvirtuous, one should have no dealings whatsoever,” as Putin, Xi Jinping and Pezeshkian were set to attend.E

What’s at stake for India

Multiple reports linked the summit’s Iran agenda to India’s balancing act, with Al Jazeera saying Modi met both Putin and Pezeshkian while emphasising freedom of navigation and the safety and well-being of ship’s crews.

forced India to stop direct crude oil imports

ABCABC

ABC4 Utah | Other said India’s relationship with Tehran remained constrained by geopolitics as severe U.S. sanctions and secondary penalties on businesses trading with Iran forced India to stop direct crude oil imports.

Al Jazeera said the BRICS summit was set to be dominated by wars in the Middle East and Ukraine and that the conflicts had impacted maritime trade and the safety and security of Indian seafarers.

Euronews reported that Harsh V. EPant expected the Gulf conflict to be the central fault line and that the BRICS group markets itself as a forum for 11 “emerging markets and developing countries,” listing Brazil, China, Egypt, Ethiopia, India, Indonesia, Iran, Russia, Saudi Arabia, South Africa and the United Arab Emirates.

In the same Euronews account, it said Modi was scheduled to hold talks with Putin later on Friday as India looked to build on one of New Delhi’s most important strategic relationships, with Putin’s arrival in New Delhi on Friday and Xi Jinping set to attend from Saturday to Sunday.E